ROTS Sidious vs. Rebels Vader and Revan

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
I want to hear your thoughts on how close a fight do you think it would be if the two faced off.

Close? Not very close? Very close? Borderline stalemate? What?

Guess it depends on which iteration?

Valerian, your answer: He thinks Plagueis would defeat Valkorion in an combat.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Valerian, your answer: He thinks Plagueis would defeat Valkorion in an combat.

Well, dude did lose to an exhausted Jedi on a dark side nexus.

Couldn't even kill a goddamn antique R2. 😬

You're hurting my feelings even more. 🙂

Time to get the rope and stool. 🙂

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
the rope and stool. 🙂

Two more things that would probably kill Valky.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Guess it depends on which iteration?

1: SoR Vitiate

2: Valkorion

3: End-game (chap. III) Vitiate

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
1: SoR Vitiate

2: Valkorion

3: End-game (chap. III) Vitiate

And which iteration of Sheev?

Originally posted by The_Tempest
And which iteration of Sheev?

RotS and DE.

The Emperor ca. ROTS can take any iteration of Valky, by virtue of being the more powerful Sith. I expect it would be quite close.

I told you, Valerian. Temp is one evil mother****er. 🙂

It's ok, Skillz. I got the answer I was looking for:

Originally posted by The_Tempest
I expect it would be quite close.

edit

So how 'bout dat argument?

There is no argument. I want things to remain as they are, the PT vs. SWTOR war going on around here is too much fun to simply toss aside. Actually, I've told you about my personal agenda for this forum. You should've known why I want things to remain as they are. You saying 'I expect it would be quite close' is all I wanted. For now.

Besides, I'm leaving in like 10 mins.

This isn't a PT vs SWTOR war. That ended years ago.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
This isn't a PT vs SWTOR war. That ended years ago.

Let me rephrase: Sheev vs. Valk.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
There is no argument. I want things to remain as they are, the PT vs. SWTOR war going on around here is too much fun to simply toss aside. Actually, I've told you about my personal agenda for this forum. You should've known why I want things to remain as they are. You saying 'I expect it would be quite close' is all I wanted. For now.

Besides, I'm leaving in like 10 mins.

You can't win, can you?

Valkorion is only a means to an end. The Godlander will rule this forum supreme.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
You can't win, can you?

You trained me, so it'd be your failure if I can't tbh.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
You trained me, so it'd be your failure if I can't tbh.

A wise Master never reveals all his secrets.

Seriously. You're a sharp guy, knowledgeable about both characters, schooled well by a number of reputable debaters. You try to remain fairly moderate in the PT/SWTOR debate.

You're as credible as anyone to take up Valk's banner against me in, if not a debate, an honest conversation.