SoD Maul vs DoE Bane

Started by Fated Xtasy6 pages

Your buddy there brought up camps, hun.

I'm only offering a little comment

Probably Bane

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Your buddy there brought up camps, hun.

I'm only offering a little comment


No. You were suggesting Maul is superior because of being in that camp, even if you didn't use the word camp, which is a shitty argument.

Then Neph brought up that Bane and Zannah are in that camp as well and you backtracked from saying it makes Maul superior and acted like it made Maul on par with them, which is an even more shitty argument.

👆

Kind of a complete fail all the way down.

Like your arguments normally are?

Originally posted by Nephthys
One of the best. Lets not pretend that Bane isn't in that camp as well.
On what basis?

Originally posted by Beniboybling
On what basis?

Being called one of the most powerful Sith who ever lived?

Perhaps, but that says nothing of his skill as a combatant.

What about that quote that says hes the most knowledgeable and skilled Sith up to his time?

You mean the most knowledgable and masterful over Sith techniques? Not only false if assumed to be referring to all Sith in mythos, but still unrelated to skills as a combatant.

Anyway would anyone like to present reasoning for Bane's victory?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
No. You were suggesting Maul is superior because of being in that camp, even if you didn't use the word camp, which is a shitty argument.

So i was suggesting somthing....even though I didn't use the word that would suggest something?

That doesn't make sense.

Then Neph brought up that Bane and Zannah are in that camp as well

Nope, he said Bane was in the same camp as those that have been referred to as "one of the best." he didn't mention Zannah, I mentioned her.

And you backtracked from saying it makes Maul superior and acted like it made Maul on par with them, which is an even more shitty argument.

Wrong again, but that's nothing new.

See hun, i mentioned these "camps" because he brought the matter up. He stated that Bane was in that same camp, and I stated that Zannah was as well. Now, given the context of the quote Maul is better trained than a vast majority of the Banite Sith, so no matter who is in that "camp" Maul - by virtue of Banite Power scaling and the Quote - is superior to Bane and Zannah.

Never did I say Maul was an equal to these character in my second post, the comment was merely meant to be sarcastic and to prove a point. It would be unwise to "backtrack" from my original statement, and idiotic given how Neph said nothing that warrants a concession.

So why don't you go back to your "elite" little club house on Hangouts and enjoy the drama you claim to despise, instead of shouting inaccuracies, hmm?

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Anyway would anyone like to present reasoning for Bane's victory?

Two words.

Temple. Feat.

Concede Beni

Originally posted by Beniboybling
You mean the most knowledgable and masterful over Sith techniques? Not only false if assumed to be referring to all Sith in mythos, but still unrelated to skills as a combatant.

It says "skill".

Bane defeated Kas'im, who is certainly one of the most skilled Sith in history. Apart from a deliberate gap in Bane's training, Kas'im could do nothing that Bane wasn't able to counter. Bane has also shown top levels of combat related Force techniques; disintegration, force drain, incinerating lightning, force bubbles, ion storms. I don't see how mastery of Sith techniques is unrelated to combat skills when many such techniques are combat related and he has access to techniques from some of the best Sith ever. His abilities in terms of strength, speed and skill are also certainly in the upper calibers of the mythos.

Originally posted by Nephthys
[B]It Bane has also shown top levels of combat related Force techniques; disintegration,

On fodder.

force drain,

On a nexus and on people literally regarded as Fodder.

incinerating lightning,

On fodder

force bubbles,

The Drexl thing? Reallg?

ion storms.

YouTube video

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
See hun, i mentioned these "camps" because he brought the matter up. He stated that Bane was in that same camp, and I stated that Zannah was as well. Now, given the context of the quote Maul is better trained than a vast majority of the Banite Sith, so no matter who is in that "camp" Maul - by virtue of Banite Power scaling and the Quote - is superior to Bane and Zannah.

Never did I say Maul was an equal to these character in my second post, the comment was merely meant to be sarcastic and to prove a point. It would be unwise to "backtrack" from my original statement, and idiotic given how Neph said nothing that warrants a concession.

There's no such context, you're just trying to save face.

I'm pretty sure we know that your statement said nothing, it was just a stupid comment to make that proved no point and was, yeah, kind of idiotic.

Bane, lmfao.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
So i was suggesting somthing....even though I didn't use the word that would suggest something?

That doesn't make sense.


Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Maul being the best in over 2500[?] years impresses me more if I'm honest.

Going with him


I'm pretty sure that's what you explicitly said actually.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Nope, he said Bane was in the same camp as those that have been referred to as "one of the best." he didn't mention Zannah, I mentioned her.

So you're saying "one of the best" is different from "the best in over 2500 years"

If you're actually saying Maul is the best in over 2500 years, then you're even more retarded then I thought.

Also you mentioning Zannah doesn't even remotely change the point I'm making, so don't act like nitpicking those semantics means jack shit.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Wrong again, but that's nothing new.

If I gathered every time you were wrong about some thing and backtracked by claiming you were saying something other than what you were saying I could write a book longer than the bible.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
See hun,

I am not your hun. I know you're extremely sexually frustrated in Aurbere's absence, but that's no reason to make this weirdly personal

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
i mentioned these "camps" because he brought the matter up. He stated that Bane was in that same camp, and I stated that Zannah was as well. Now, given the context of the quote Maul is better trained than a vast majority of the Banite Sith, so no matter who is in that "camp" Maul - by virtue of Banite Power scaling and the Quote - is superior to Bane and Zannah.

Banite scaling (ie. each generation being stronger) only applies to people who have actually... you know... surpassed their masters. Otherwise Maul>Sheev

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Never did I say Maul was an equal to these character in my second post, the comment was merely meant to be sarcastic and to prove a point. It would be unwise to "backtrack" from my original statement, and idiotic given how Neph said nothing that warrants a concession.

If you can actually prove the claim that Maul is the best in 2500 years you might have a point.

But I haven't seen the quote for that, and it's kinda contradicted by the fact that Sidious and Plagueis predate him and blatantly shit all over him, so unless you can prove that it's kinda just you being retarded tbh.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
So why don't you go back to your "elite" little club house on Hangouts and enjoy the drama you claim to despise, instead of shouting inaccuracies, hmm?

Funny how the guy accusing me of liking drama is the one bringing personal shit into this.

Originally posted by Nephthys
It says "skill".
Yeah in relation to mastery over Force techniques, which is great and all but in reality all Bane appears to be combatively capable of in that regard is shooting lighting and TK, nothing special.
Bane defeated Kas'im, who is certainly one of the most skilled Sith in history. Apart from a deliberate gap in Bane's training, Kas'im could do nothing that Bane wasn't able to counter.
Well actually he was defeated in sabers, destroyed even. The only reason he was doing well before was because 1. intimate knowledge of Kas'im's style 2. sheer power, he has none of those advantages here.
Bane has also shown top levels of combat related Force techniques; disintegration, force drain, incinerating lightning, force bubbles, ion storms. I don't see how mastery of Sith techniques is unrelated to combat skills when many such techniques are combat related and he has access to techniques from some of the best Sith ever.
But again, how much of that does he actually use in combat, Force lightning and TK are basic bread and butter abilities. Force drain and ion storms he's only ever used against fodder, Force bubbles is another basic ability, at least in the Bane books.
His abilities in terms of strength, speed and skill are also certainly in the upper calibers of the mythos.
Perhaps, though frankly Maul rivals his physical feats in Lockdown, when he wasn't even using the Force. Nor does his level of lightsaber training on level with Maul's. Indeed Bane's abilities have only ever been tested against his contemporaries. Certainly against Kas'im, who has the best cross-era credentials, he ended up rather outclassed.

Originally posted by Nephthys
There's no such context, you're just trying to save face.

I'm pretty sure we know that your statement said nothing, it was just a stupid comment to make that proved no point and was, yeah, kind of idiotic.

LMAO Now that's ironic. Neph you've seen my comments, rarely, if ever do I give a damn about what majority think about me.