Dave Filoni on Ahsoka Tano vs Darth Vader / The Emperor

Started by quanchi11236 pages

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Somebody lock this thread already.
Why ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
He had to defeat the Inquisitors because they were an obstacle. He feigned needing them to calm down their uneasiness with allying with a known dark sider. So he needed them as I said to aid in defeating all three Inquisitors. Once he did so he proceeded to eliminate the other two good guys. If he was that fearful of Vader why not bring in more possible allies until he knew Vader's whereabouts.

Show me anything that points to the dark nexus being an undeniable amp in no way the episode went into explain. If there was a dark side nexus it wouldn't give him an advantage against Vader so who the **** cares. I didn't say he was planning on facing him I'm saying he knew it was a possibility he might have no choice after he disposed of the good guys.
You said their duel ended at that point. False. It ended after they re engaged since neither party was injured and it continued. Tano wasn't injured at all. Vader was. That's telling. Quit making excuses for why Vader didn't put down his former student or at least injure her.

Maul blinded him and had him beaten. Tano had to save his life. No one saved Tano against Vader. Different circumstances entirely so save me the trouble of seeing your troll logic.
That is his opinion you stupid ****. The show gives us the facts not some random interview where he says something. That's an opinion you pile of shit no matter how informed it is. Opinions vary. Facts are what the show gives us.

No, he didn't beat her since she wasn't injured nor was she down and out. So you're saying without the nexus Vader barely temp bfrd her and without it he could do what ? Tano left the duel with Maul so please stop. Vader and she fought longer before Vader bfrd her. Tano on the other hand didn't injure Maul at all but she did so to Vader.

Prove the nexus amped them. You continue to just debate based off speculation. What's wrong with you ? Such low standards here for debating.

Originally posted by Petrus
So you conceded the debate. No one can match my relentlessness. I've been doing this for nine years and I've broken them all who dare to test my mettle.

Originally posted by quanchi112
So you conceded the debate. No one can match my relentlessness. I've been doing this for nine years and I've broken them all who dare to test my mettle.

I've conceded nothing. I just like seeing you get pissed at me.

I'll reply tomorrow.

Originally posted by Petrus
I've conceded nothing. I just like seeing you get pissed at me.

I'll reply tomorrow.

I never get upset. I am amazing at what I do. Gather your courage, prepare to be annihilated, make peace with those you feel the need because tomorrow you die, boy.

So let me get this straight... according to the Troll, surprise attacks are completely legit. And it's only counted as a "win" when your opponent is physically injured.

I guess Maul was legit stomped by Padawan Obi-Wan then 😂

Oh the Troll with his retarded arguments never fails to embarass Maul. He embarrasses him even more so than Filoni does.

Originally posted by darthbane77
Filoni has a hard on for Ahsoka, he's extremely bias. Vader already beat her down, Palpatine would ****ing slaughter her.
With horrible injuries, it certainly wasn't easy for him by ANY stretch of the imagination.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
With horrible injuries, it certainly wasn't easy for him by ANY stretch of the imagination.

What horrible injuries? Partial mask loss? Doesn't sound like much an injury compared to what he's had elsewhere.

They made Vader look really bad in that fight. He swings his Saber around like Savage and misses everything, pathetic. Filoni didn't have to make Vader look like a mug to wank Ahsoka :/

Originally posted by Jmanghan
With horrible injuries, it certainly wasn't easy for him by ANY stretch of the imagination.

You mean the one injury from the cheap shot?

Or you mean the injuries from the explosion?

Originally posted by Darth Thor
So let me get this straight... according to the Troll, surprise attacks are completely legit. And it's only counted as a "win" when your opponent is physically injured.

I guess Maul was legit stomped by Padawan Obi-Wan then 😂

Oh the Troll with his retarded arguments never fails to embarass Maul. He embarrasses him even more so than Filoni does.

Kanan has precog and had his light saber on him. It's funny how trolls such as yourself use precog in a vs battle against a non Jedi opponent but ignore it in actual canon to sell their misguided and trollish points.

I didn't say that. I said Tano got the better of Vader no matter how you spin it. Vader didn't physically hurt her by any stretch of the Vader fanboy imagination. Tano on the other hand facially ****ed Vader.

Maul skill wise had him bested but was overconfident just like against Kanan. Your personal insults are lame. I tell it how it is without the use of double standards you switch up thread to thread. Face me directly, coward. Your inability to muster any courage to directly respond to me show the depths of your cowardice. 😂

Originally posted by Zenwolf
What horrible injuries? Partial mask loss? Doesn't sound like much an injury compared to what he's had elsewhere.
Nothing happened to Tano to injure her body in the slightest. Vader limped off the episodes conclusion. He looked oh so bad. I keep hearing all this Vader hype but he didn't look great against Kanan and Ezra. He also looked like Tano's peer not her superior getting the worse end of the exchange by episodes end.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
You mean the one injury from the cheap shot?

Or you mean the injuries from the explosion?

So you agree Vader has clear maneuverability issues I've went on at length to describe in this episode. Another Quan point D. Thor approved.

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
They made Vader look really bad in that fight. He swings his Saber around like Savage and misses everything, pathetic. Filoni didn't have to make Vader look like a mug to wank Ahsoka :/
👆

Vader is mostly hype when you break down the evidence. Every canon real time confrontation he has had he doesn't look great. Ben Kenobi lost on purpose. An unready Luke wounded him. A fully trained Luke destroyed him easily. The list goes on and on not even taking into account the Rebels appearances.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Nothing happened to Tano to injure her body in the slightest. Vader limped off the episodes conclusion. He looked oh so bad. I keep hearing all this Vader hype but he didn't look great against Kanan and Ezra. He also looked like Tano's peer not her superior getting the worse end of the exchange by episodes end.

Except....you know, that massive explosion that more than likely killed her. Vader seemed to get the better end of that deal.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Except....you know, that massive explosion that more than likely killed her. Vader seemed to get the better end of that deal.
They show Tano walking away right after they show Vader limping away. Did you even watch the end of the episode ? Your ignorance is quite frankly appalling.

Watch the end and after you do so and see her I expect an apology.

You thought she died. 😂 😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
They show Tano walking away right after they show Vader limping away. Did you even watch the end of the episode ? Your ignorance is quite frankly appalling.

Watch the end and after you do so and see her I expect an apology.

You thought she died. 😂 😂

It's ambiguous, I never said she died, but rather more than likely. Because ya know....they were dueling right next to the thing that exploded, Vader has at least his armor to protect him, Tano doesn't have any real excuse.

We'll probably find out later what happened, but it seems more likely that she died rather than survived, unless whoever writes it, has her survive in some absurd way.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
It's ambiguous, I never said she died, but rather more than likely. Because ya know....they were dueling right next to the thing that exploded, Vader has at least his armor to protect him, Tano doesn't have any real excuse.

We'll probably find out later what happened, but it seems more likely that she died rather than survived, unless whoever writes it, has her survive in some absurd way.

They show her walking after the explosion. More likely is bullshit. You clearly didn't watch the episode. You need to watch the episode because they show her alive after the explosion after they show Vader gimping.

We already know she's alive. Watch the episode. 😂

😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
They show her walking after the explosion. More likely bullshit. You need to watch the episode because they show her alive after the explosion after they show Vader gimping.

We already know she's alive. Watch the episode. 😂

😂

Yeah they show her, but that was an ambiguous ending.

I think that right now what’s important is it’s really a moment for you as a fan and for me to see more of what you’re made of. Like how strong is your faith. What do you believe? What did you see there in the final moments? ‘Cause I know what happened for sure. And I think that it would be just cruel and rob you of your own independence if I said blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You know, it’s like I didn’t put an image of Vader like dragging her head along at the end. That’d be horrible. That would be like I couldn’t even get off this lot if that happened. And yet I didn’t have a Loth cat come up and purr at her ankle as she picked it up and said “close one.” So neither of those is an acceptable outcome.

- Dave

Ambiguous ending.

Don't bother, he thinks Filoni's 'opinions' (lol) are worthless.