Originally posted by AncientPower
We have a winner.Even if you try to weasel out of this with appeals to authorial irrelevancy, which are in and of themselves hilarious.
Appeals to authorial irrelevancy are what you do all the time with Avellone, lol.
I already rank Kun highly - much moreso than most other people. If Veitch's new book puts Kun near Palpatine, then I won't be the one complaining.
Originally posted by AncientPower
Avellone's referring to a project and concepts that never saw the light of day. LMFAO at you trying to equate the two.I never said you would be, I just don't appreciate instant dismissal of new sources such as this when we have no reason to do so.
1. I'm talking about him referring to Darth Revan kicking Traya and Surik's asses.
2. Instant dismissal? I'm just saying don't get your hopes up high when it's contradicted by official sources - like the last time Veitch commented on his own works.
Originally posted by SunRazer
1. I'm talking about him referring to Darth Revan kicking Traya and Surik's asses.2. Instant dismissal? I'm just saying don't get your hopes up high when it's contradicted by official sources - like the last time Veitch commented on his own works.
Yes, his concepts of Darth Revan massively differs from the Revan we actually know. His idea of Darth Revan is much more in line with Dark Revan.
Except the contradictions aren't nearly as brazen as you make them out to be.
1. Most of the Darth Revan we know comes from KotOR II, actually. But I'm not opposed to dismissing Avellone's opinion, only that you can't do that and then laugh at other people for maintaining their standards with Veitch, lol. One could say the same about how Veitch views Kun or Palpatine.
2. They're directly contradicted by licensed material, including his own. That's all I'm making it out to be.
Originally posted by AncientPower
A Darth Revan that never lived up to the hype, you mean? Kun's placement by Veitch is directly implied and stated in actual sources, there's the difference.
What are you talking about? This is the same Darth Revan that Avellone wrote. He's using that one. lmfao
You do realize that Veitch himself penned Sidious as the most powerful dark side master ever in official sources, right?