Bane vs. Winter Soldier h2h

No weapons or armor. Just plain street clothes.
Bane knows about WS metal arm and how powerful it is. He fights to the best of his ability.
Fight is to ko or incapacitation.

Who wins?

Are we using what is shown or what is implied, IE writer's intent?

I dont see how this match would be anything else other than spite against Bane.

WS 11/10

Bane stands absolutely no chance. I don't think Bane could even take out human Thor, let alone any super soldier.

Winter Soldier punches Bane's mask through his face lmao.

Bucky tosses Bane around like the normal guy he is.

Bane gets completely and utterly overwhelmed in this fight...

Originally posted by Silent Master
Are we using what is shown or what is implied, IE writer's intent?

WS wins with only his human arm. Repeated punches to the mask.

I disagree. Bane has the skills and quickness to make it extremely hard for WS to hit him with the metal arm.
Bane is strong enough to do some real damage to WS.
Bane might break WS's back.

I see this fight as 6/10 WS.

Bucky in his current form of only having one arm would wreck Bane with ease. Bucky at full strength, Bane goes down with contemptuous ease. This is a no contest.

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. Bane has the skills and quickness to make it extremely hard for WS to hit him with the metal arm.
Bane is strong enough to do some real damage to WS.
Bane might break WS's back.

I see this fight as 6/10 WS.

He isn't at all. WS has the same super serum cap has. His one human arm is enough to kill bane outright. Bucky fell hundreds of feet without breaking any bones. Bane is likely to get one shotted right out the gate with one hard hit to the face.

Originally posted by h1a8
Writer's intent is most important and supercedes all.

Then WS wins 10/10

This is simple. Bucky can do literally everything Bane did, but better. Bucky for example wouldn't have been injured in the Lazarus Pit. He'd have just murdered everyone.

The opposite is not true. Bane can't do much of anything Bucky did. Can't book it down the highway at 40+mph, can't toss a superhuman like Cap around. Etc etc...

lol I needed a laugh so thanks H1

in regards to this match.. Bane loses 100,000,000,000,000x times over..

Bucky can literally one shot him

Originally posted by h1a8
Writer's intent is most important and supercedes all.

Per writer's intention Bane is a highly skilled human and Winter Soldier is a highly skilled superhuman

Superhuman > Human. thus WS wins 10/10.

Agreed with Rob, agree with Silent, agree with everyone: Bucky wins via punch to Bane's grill.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Per writer's intention Bane is a highly skilled human and Winter Soldier is a highly skilled superhuman

Superhuman > Human. thus WS wins 10/10.

They are both human and enhanced.
Can no human do what Bane did.

If Bane blocks or ducks a punch from WS and counters with a vicious blow then he has a good chance to win the fight.

Originally posted by John Murdoch
Agreed with Rob, agree with Silent, agree with everyone: Bucky wins via punch to Bane's grill.

Originally posted by h1a8
They are both human and enhanced.
Can no human do what Bane did.

If Bane blocks or ducks a punch from WS and counters with a vicious blow then he has a good chance to win the fight.

We are only arguing writer's intention, Bane was meant to be a highly-skilled human whereas Winter Soldier is a highly-skilled superhuman.

Therefore using writers intentions, Winter Soldier wins