Darth Maul vs. Vitiate

Started by Haschwalth7 pages

Originally posted by Nephthys
Anytime people start throwing around terms like "faster than light" just remember:

Canon GG.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Anytime people start throwing around terms like "faster than light" just remember:

lmfao ok 👆

Not that we're talking about canon Maul anyway.

Originally posted by The Ellimist

lmfao ok 👆

Not that we're talking about canon Maul anyway.

PIS, suppose to be a force user, nice try, his body would be incinerated by Valks power, wtf do you think happened to Nihilus or the fact, Valk needed a insanely strong force potential body.
You can do better than that.

Originally posted by Nephthys
God, I know.

The dude wrote an entire chapter that he just forgot to put into the book. How do you forget a whole ****ing chapter? Its insane.

What was it on? Probably for the best anyway, given how shit the book was.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
PIS, suppose to be a force user, nice try, his body would be incinerated by Valks power, wtf do you think happened to Nihilus or the fact, Valk needed a insanely strong force potential body.
You can do better than that.

lmao I was responding to Neph posting a different continuity's Maul striking at someone comically.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
lmao I was responding to Neph posting a different continuity's Maul striking at someone comically.

Yeah, that was pretty amusing.

Originally posted by The Ellimist

lmfao ok 👆

Not that we're talking about canon Maul anyway.

Lol, did you go to that same thread?

I believe canon is still relevant to Legends last time I checked.

Originally posted by SunRazer
What was it on? Probably for the best anyway, given how shit the book was.

It had Carth in it, as I recall. I think it also had a bunch of info on what happened to the other characters.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Lol, did you go to that same thread?

I believe canon is still relevant to Legends last time I checked.

Not even close.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
2.If you want to go down that path, we simply haven't developed enough of an understanding, to assume Light speed is the limit. SW universe is beyond our level of understanding.

No, because hyperdrives are specifically mentioned as a form of FTL travel, which makes it clear that some form of relativity is still a thing. Combine that with the observation that things like electromagnetism, time dilation and other pieces of evidence for special relativity still apply and parsimony tells us there's still a light barrier.


3. The Quote was literally in combat, which contradicts your statement, they do fight at these speeds in space combat.

That starfighters do in RotS doesn't mean that fleets in KotOR do, not when we see them not doing so.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Anytime people start throwing around terms like "faster than light" just remember:

Remember when Vitiate got nearly roasted and toasted by R2D2's retarded ancestor?

Originally posted by Nephthys
It had Carth in it, as I recall. I think it also had a bunch of info on what happened to the other characters.

Ah, so that's why the book doesn't even mention him.

Karpyshyn's a bloody idiot, lmao. And he can't write for shit either.

Originally posted by MythLord
Remember when Vitiate got nearly roasted and toasted by R2D2's retarded ancestor?

🤣

Originally posted by Haschwalth
Not even close.

Well regardless Azrongers quote is from a description of the fight from Attack of the Clones.

Originally posted by MythLord
Remember when Vitiate got nearly roasted and toasted by R2D2's retarded ancestor?

Hey man, **** you T3 is a badass. He was soloing HK's like it was nothing.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Ah, so that's why the book doesn't even mention him.

Karpyshyn's a bloody idiot, lmao. And he can't write for shit either.

He's useless for anything but video games, where the bar is lower and he can be propped up by the rest of the team. He's legitimately shit as a novelist. Remember how its accidentally implied that Bane possessed Zannah at the end and he had to hastily clarify that thats not what happened? Sloppy.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
No, because hyperdrives are specifically mentioned as a form of FTL travel, which makes it clear that some form of relativity is still a thing. Combine that with the observation that things like electromagnetism, time dilation and other pieces of evidence for special relativity still apply and parsimony tells us there's still a light barrier.

That starfighters do in RotS doesn't mean that fleets in KotOR do, not when we see them not doing so.

1. I'll concede that, but It's irrelevant because the ships are only moving 0.64c at max which is still in the relativistic pace. Not FTL.

2. they might as well not make star fighters if they can't keep up with the fleet lmfao, It's illogical to think that they can't match the same speeds as their main ships. Infact down right stupid from a tactical point of view. speed/mobility are key in battles, they will be utilizing it to the max.

@Nephtys, it's from a Non canon version of the Attack on clones, book.

Drew also screwed up Darth Bane from the EU. He appeared first in the comics shortly after Kaan's Brotherhood of Darkness was destroyed. And from that story it seemed Bane didn't plan to destroy the Brotherhood, but he just fled and then when the Brotherhood perished; Bane wished to create the Rule of Two.

Originally posted by Haschwalth
1. I'll concede that, but It's irrelevant because the ships are only moving 0.64c at max which is still in the relativistic pace. Not FTL.

2. they might as well not make star fighters if they can't keep up with the fleet lmfao, It's illogical to think that they can't match the same speeds as their main ships. Infact down right stupid from a tactical point of view. speed/mobility are key in battles, they will be utilizing it to the max.

1. That's not what I'm saying. I'm noting that having a "maximum speed" in this context makes no sense, and it makes even less sense to assume that any ships that have been fighting for a few minutes are moving at that pace, especially when it produces absurd conclusions.

2. ??? You flipped it.

Originally posted by Freedon Nadd
Drew also screwed up Darth Bane from the EU. He appeared first in the comics shortly after Kaan's Brotherhood of Darkness was destroyed. And from that story it seemed Bane didn't plan to destroy the Brotherhood, but he just fled and then when the Brotherhood perished; Bane wished to create the Rule of Two.

I actually prefer it that way. PoD is his only decent book imo.

Nah. In terms of character development it was good, true. But in terms of story, it didn't. It would have been better to see a Sith learning from the mistakes of an order, rather than outrightly "muhahahahaha, you're all weak!"

Originally posted by The Ellimist
1. That's not what I'm saying. I'm noting that having a "maximum speed" in this context makes no sense, and it makes even less sense to assume that any ships that have been fighting for a few minutes are moving at that pace, especially when it produces absurd conclusions.

2. ??? You flipped it.

1. How so? uh, it would be basic for one of those ships to hit relativistic speeds, considering those space fighters in ROTS hit it within a matter of seconds. Nothing is
absured about the movement, in these space battles, considering the battle field is millions of Miles in size.

2.What?