Originally posted by BentleyYou are speculating. He's always been a match for Vader.
Kenobi just improved and dropped all his distraction. He was getting his _ss handed to him at the beginning of the match but then he let go off his doubts and fears. Without those worries Kenobi was a force to be reckoned with.Also Vader, just like Maul, lost because he underestimated his Obi-Wan, not because he was just outclassed.
Windu had Vapaad against Sheev, he won't get as big of a boost vs Dooku who has a style that will be effective vs Windu.
Maul disarmed him and had him at his mercy. Vader never disarmed or had him at his mercy. Maul is superior to Vader.
That's in his own abilities so I don't care. You have yet to prove a guy skill wise raped by Anakin touches Windu who according to Lucas is at the top level. Dooku is clearly weaker and not top level, Frenchmen.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
You 2 broken up?
Originally posted by quanchi112
I am speculating about canon Dooku. You are so emotionally weak these days. Maul wins over canon Dooku.#disneymattersnotyourfanfic
Originally posted by quanchi112
You are speculating. He's always been a match for Vader.Maul disarmed him and had him at his mercy. Vader never disarmed or had him at his mercy. Maul is superior to Vader.
That's in his own abilities so I don't care. You have yet to prove a guy skill wise raped by Anakin touches Windu who according to Lucas is at the top level. Dooku is clearly weaker and not top level, Frenchmen.
Originally posted by KurkI made it clear I was speculating but this actually tells me a lot about the current state of affairs for Star Wars debaters and their obsession with feats.
Read the battle barCanon jedi Dooku is featless, kiddo. You're speculating on a character that has only appeared in a flashback in TCW. Why don't you go debate canon sith Dooku vs Maul in another thread; or are you afraid that Dooku with feats will persevere over Maul?
I was going to quote from the RotS book, but you've already made it clear you don't acknowledge sources that don't fit your agenda. Even concerning the canon Vader comic you've stated yourself that it's merit less. The double-standards are clear now. Use what supports your stance but ignore anything that doesn't.
I don't rely on feats alone. Firstly this isn't a science and I can use my critical reasoning to have a reasonable discussion. Have you forgotten I am referred to as Mr. Reasonable.
Maul wins over any version of Dooku. I've made that abundantly clear. If you think my opinion has changed explain why my former apprentice.
I use the films and live action series. The directors don't give a shit about some novel book or comics which are cater to a separate audience altogether.
When have I used double standards ? I am consistent in my criteria across the board well in case you have forgotten I am Mr. Reasonable.
Originally posted by quanchi112Sweetie, if you want to debate characters using only their movie and TV show appearances like a normie, you're in the wrong section of the Star Wars forums. This is Star Wars: Literature & Expanded Universe. Go try the film and tv show sections. You'll infuriate fewer people there and have an overall better time 🙂 .
I made it clear I was speculating but this actually tells me a lot about the current state of affairs for Star Wars debaters and their obsession with feats.I don't rely on feats alone. Firstly this isn't a science and I can use my critical reasoning to have a reasonable discussion. Have you forgotten I am referred to as Mr. Reasonable.
Maul wins over any version of Dooku. I've made that abundantly clear. If you think my opinion has changed explain why my former apprentice.
I use the films and live action series. The directors don't give a shit about some novel book or comics which are cater to a separate audience altogether.
When have I used double standards ? I am consistent in my criteria across the board well in case you have forgotten I am [B]Mr. Reasonable
. [/B]
Originally posted by KurkThen you'll be deprived of my wisdom and become stagnate in your own personal growth. I don't seek to infuriate I seek to have reasonable discourse.
Sweetie, if you want to debate characters using only their movie and TV show appearances like a normie, you're in the wrong section of the Star Wars forums. This is Star Wars:[b] Literature & Expanded Universe. Go try the film and tv show sections. You'll infuriate fewer people there and have an overall better time 🙂 . [/B]
Originally posted by KurkI am wise not to waste my time onslemthinngtnat doesn't really matter in Star Wars. It's just want to sell more merchandise. They tried the same nonsense with their Star Trek comics but admitted it in an interview.
So you're oh so wise and reasonable, yet willfully ignorant about the finer details of Star Wars...right.
Originally posted by quanchi112Because a business is going to spend its resources on a niche area of a franchise in order to sell more "merchandise" rather than focus on the pop-culture aspect of it....right
I am wise not to waste my time onslemthinngtnat doesn't really matter in Star Wars. It's just want to sell more merchandise. They tried the same nonsense with their Star Trek comics but admitted it in an interview.
Originally posted by KurkAny business is going to sell more merchandise because it's their goal to maximize profit. That I understand but don't expect me to believe the salesman with everything they tell you. The comics, games, etc. don't matter when it comes to the films and live action series.
Because a business is going to spend its resources on a niche area of a franchise in order to sell more "merchandise" rather than focus on the pop-culture aspect of it....right
You're old enough to decide for yourself and ignore my infinite wisdom. One day you will log in and apologize to me.
Originally posted by ILS
Dooku is the only character that can do absolutely nothing worthy of note and still win threads.
I guess sh_tstomping Anakin and Kenobi, being historically a better duellist than Mace and being able to stand his ground against Yoda are no feats...?
(At least one of these feats is atributed to this specific version of Dooku)
Originally posted by BentleyYeah, he was an equal for TPM Mace. The other two feats are after he went through a significant power increase.
I guess sh_tstomping Anakin and Kenobi, being historically a better duellist than Mace and being able to stand his ground against Yoda are no feats...?(At least one of these feats is atributed to this specific version of Dooku)
Explain to me how that puts him above Maul.