Dr. Manhattan vs Thanos

Started by BrolyBlack18 pages
Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Oh, I'm sorry, does Manhattan have a magic axe forged with the fire of a star, meant to be wielded by the king of a race of gods? No? Didn't think so.

Your argument essentially is "because a magic scalpal didnt heal the patient, healing the patient on a subatomic level won't work either."

You see how silly that sounds?

What's Thanos relevant feats.
1. Making blaster a bubble gun (matter manipulation)
2. Creating a pseudo scene to trick gamora (didn't actually change reality).
3. Killing half the universe with a snap
4. Using time gem to reverse gem from being destroyed.

From those feats we can only infer other things WITHIN REASON. NO WILD SPECULATION.

DM relevant feats
1. Can clone himself many times
2. Can see the future
3. Can become intangible
4. Can resurrect himself from total annihilation.
5. Can matter manipulate and remove intrinsic fields
6. Can perceive things on a Picosecond or less scale.
7. Can make himself resistant against harm (walking on the sun).

Questions that need to be addressed.
1. Can Thanos snap his fingers and kill DM permanently (DM can't resurrect)?
A. Will he think about that tactic and choose to do it within the first few moments of battle?

2. Will DM see the future and act accordingly?

3. Are we in control of both characters or will they operate (choose their tactics) in a manner typical of their film counterparts?

If 1. is a yes then Thanos can win if DM does not act first
If 1 is a no then DM wins

If 2 is a yes then DM wins
If 2 is a no then go to 1.

If 3 is a yes the DM wins.
If 3 is a no then go to 2.

Lol. Classic h1 exaggeration of one side while completely downplaying the other.

Not even worth responding to.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Lol, the leaps of logic that people are making for Manhattan are amazing, yet the snap is irrelevant. The mental gymnastics are hilarious. Thanos just erased half of all life in the universe from existence, but you start rubbing your balls because Manhattan can blow up regular people by looking at them.
😂

Bias is all. Deep down they know Thanos mauls this nude prima donna. Better feats, better competition, more abilities, more powerful, etc.

Originally posted by Impediment
Manhattan can disintegrate the atoms of the Infinity Stones even more so than Wanda did.
Based off what? Lets forget how long it took Wanda to do so for a moment. Is Thanos holding the stone up like vision just faced her while she blasted it? Does he stand there and just wait? How does this occur in your mind?

Originally posted by ares834
Pretty sure the argument is that durability is irrelevant against Manhattan's powers. I can't say if that's true for the film, but it's certainly the case in the comic.

This is what I'm talking about. You can't just say durability is irrelevant against a guy who has never even fought a super human, or effected anything more advanced than Earth based technology. It's insane.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
Wanda has damaged wildly more durable objects than DM has
I think you missed the tank the Doc fans are masturbating about.

Originally posted by ares834
But Thor almost killed Thanos. You don't need to be anywhere near universal to kill him.
A weapon designed to kill someone of his caliber and the attempt failed so what is your point? You do not needuniversal power to kill Manhattan either but Thanos has the abilities to reality warp him. Nothing he can do about it. Thanos has the better reaction feats against super powered opponents not some guy quivering in his panties about nuclear war.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Lol. Classic h1 exaggeration of one side while completely downplaying the other.

Not even worth responding to.

I tried honestly to be objective. There are some unknowns here. I stated that we can infer WITHIN REASON.

I'm pretty sure I'm spot on in the assessment. If I missed something pertinent then please enlighten me.

I forgot to mention that DM can teleport himself and others.
He has the capability to teleport the gauntlet off

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
This is what I'm talking about. You can't just say durability is irrelevant against a guy who has never even fought a super human, or effected anything more advanced than Earth based technology. It's insane.

Depending on his powers you can.

Originally posted by ares834
Depending on his powers you can.
You need to prove it, kiddo. Killing some thugs and decimating a tank is not the same thing. Your silly imagination tactics aside you know Thanos drums this pitiful excuse for an opponent.

Like I said, I don't know about the film's version of Manhattan.

Originally posted by ares834
Like I said, I don't know about the film's version of Manhattan.
Do you honestly think thisnlue naked man has a chance against the most powerful villain in cinematic history?

1. DM can remove intrinsic fields.
2. DM can teleport objects (gauntlet, Thanos head, Thanos to the center of the sun)

Originally posted by h1a8
1. DM can remove intrinsic fields.
2. DM can teleport objects (gauntlet, Thanos head, Thanos to the center of the sun)
Thanos rewrites reality. Bye bye, naked guy.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos rewrites reality. Bye bye, naked guy.

Thanos cannot do such things.
He can matter manipulate to a limited extent yes (changing the gun into a bubble blower), but his so called reality warping is just creating illusions.

if he could then how would he rewrite reality in his favor?

Originally posted by h1a8
Thanos cannot do such things.
He can matter manipulate to a limited extent yes (changing the gun into a bubble blower), but his so called reality warping is just creating illusions.

if he could then how would he rewrite reality in his favor?

We see it change but revert back after he left. The blasts turned into bubbles. Turns Manhattan into bubbles.

😂

Poor naked blue guy.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We see it change but revert back after he left. The blasts turned into bubbles. Turns Manhattan into bubbles.

😂

Poor naked blue guy.

👆

Originally posted by quanchi112
We see it change but revert back after he left. The blasts turned into bubbles. Turns Manhattan into bubbles.

😂

Poor naked blue guy.

An illusion. Not real.

The gun shot bubbles, the blast wasn't shown to turn into bubbles.

Like Thanos turned anyone he faced into bubbles.
He will suddenly do it here, and from the jump?

Apparently, it’s called the “Illusion” gem now. Not the “Reality” stone.