MCU Thor vs MCU Hulk compared

Started by quanchi1129 pages

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Thor was wrecking Hulk until he got unfairly 2v1'd by Grandmaster. Everyone but you and Quanchii knows that. Also, Thor Launched Hulk WAY HARDER than Hulk did to Thor in Ragnarok. Did you even watch the movie? Thor had an arena hammer and sent Hulk flying so hard and far that the entire crowd, including GM were in awe. Hulk then decided to cheaphot and ragdoll Thor to no effect. Thor just got up and brushed it off with no injuries at all. Also, don't talk to me about bleeding. Hulk was bleeding from Chitari weapons in Avengers 1 and was looking like they were wrecking his shit. I could also say the same thing about all the blows Hulk landed on Thor and he wasn't bleeding either.

Bottom line is this, Hulk has a worse ass kicked per appearance record than Thor does, despite having fought less foes and certainly less powerful foes. That's pure fact.

Thor was winning because he has superior skill but he didn’t beat the Hulk.

No one thought he’d be a challenge to the Hulk. That’s why they were in awe. After

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Thor was wrecking Hulk until he got unfairly 2v1'd by Grandmaster. Everyone but you and Quanchii knows that. Also, Thor Launched Hulk WAY HARDER than Hulk did to Thor in Ragnarok. Did you even watch the movie? Thor had an arena hammer and sent Hulk flying so hard and far that the entire crowd, including GM were in awe. Hulk then decided to cheaphot and ragdoll Thor to no effect. Thor just got up and brushed it off with no injuries at all. Also, don't talk to me about bleeding. Hulk was bleeding from Chitari weapons in Avengers 1 and was looking like they were wrecking his shit. I could also say the same thing about all the blows Hulk landed on Thor and he wasn't bleeding either.

Bottom line is this, Hulk has a worse ass kicked per appearance record than Thor does, despite having fought less foes and certainly less powerful foes. That's pure fact.

Thor was winning because he has superior skill but he didn’t beat the Hulk.

No one thought he’d be a challenge to the Hulk. That’s why they were in awe. After their fight Thor was the one in pain not the Hulk.

Hulk has less skill than Thor. If Hulk had the same skill as Thor he’d annihilate him. He doesn’t though hence why each guy brings different advantages to the table. When both guys are in the same situations Hulk is stronger and more physically capable than Thor.

Superior feats doesn’t determine superiority especially since they are exclusive to generally one character. It’s how these guys match up. Thor has plenty of other advantages than physicality such as skill and various other abilities as well as determination. This is what makes their fights do great in the comics as well as on the big screen.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Thor tanked the full force of a Neutron Star for several minutes...

Until Hulk has a feat of durability on that level, Thors durability is greater than Hulks...

That is ridiculous and you know it. Hulk is physically superior to Thor and you know it. The feat just shows Thor is amazing but we already knew that. Problem is Hulk is more amazing physically than Thor is.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Even prior to IW, Thor took massive beatings from Hulk. Whilst Hulk was struggling to stand up after 2 Lightning punches from Thor.

So either Thor is more durable, or his Lightning punches are ridiculously stronger than Hulks punches.

Take your pick.


Which beating? The ground and pound? IMO Odin saved Thor there, he was done and dusted until he was energised with power and irrc almost looked shocked once he got up bursting with power. Similar thing happened in the scene with Hela, he was near ko/death until he suddenly instantly recovered once he saw Odin, that's how I interpreted those moments anyway.

Thor was injured after the fight and Hulk was not despite taking far more hits so your point cannot be true.

100% skill.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Which beating? The ground and pound? IMO Odin saved Thor there, he was done and dusted until he was energised with power and irrc almost looked shocked once he got up bursting with power. Similar thing happened in the scene with Hela, he was near ko/death until he suddenly instantly recovered once he saw Odin, that's how I interpreted those moments anyway.

Thor was injured after the fight and Hulk was not despite taking far more hits so your point cannot be true.

??

You can't just completely make things up and add "IMO".

Thor wasn't dusted. Thor wasn't even hurt. We saw his head turn, completely unhurt, and in a rage he blasts Hulk.

It's like saying Hulk was dusted when Thor was kicking his ass across the arena.

He connected Hulk didn’t. Thor is strong enough to hurt the Hulk. No one said otherwise. Thor woke up sore the Hulk was not.

Hulk wasn't zapped with an obedience disk, unable to defend himself, as Thor leapt 100 feet into the air and landed with a flying punch on his face.

And Thor was fine.

TWICE in that fight actually, Hulk landed on Thor's face with brutality. If Thor was half as blood thirsty as Hulk, Banner would've been a stain on Thor's fist imo. That ground and pound was brutal. He landed feet and fists down on Thor, with an immediate ground pound. How many times did he hit Thor? A dozen undefended shots to the face?

The fact that Thor was unharmed is pretty crazy imo.

'Odin saved Thor' smh..

How can this still a debate after Ragnarok and IW? At this point it's pretty clear that Thor > Hulk.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
??

You can't just completely make things up and add "IMO".

Thor wasn't dusted. Thor wasn't even hurt. We saw his head turn, completely unhurt, and in a rage he blasts Hulk.

It's like saying Hulk was dusted when Thor was kicking his ass across the arena.


So are you saying Odins appearance in the 2 scenes where Thor is getting his ass handed to him hardest, looking on the verge of defeat only to turn the tide after is coincidence? It wasn't.

I'm going by what I saw on screen, the only reason I put "imo" was because I'm not the writer and cannot prove it, but without the writer spoon feeding every scene to us that's what I (and everyone I spoke to personally) took from it.

Plenty of you guys have been saying exactly that though.

Originally posted by FrothByte
How can this still a debate after Ragnarok and IW? At this point it's pretty clear that Thor > Hulk.

👆

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Hulk wasn't zapped with an obedience disk, unable to defend himself, as Thor leapt 100 feet into the air and landed with a flying punch on his face.

And Thor was fine.

TWICE in that fight actually, Hulk landed on Thor's face with brutality. If Thor was half as blood thirsty as Hulk, Banner would've been a stain on Thor's fist imo. That ground and pound was brutal. He landed feet and fists down on Thor, with an immediate ground pound. How many times did he hit Thor? A dozen undefended shots to the face?

The fact that Thor was unharmed is pretty crazy imo.

No one is saying that was done fairly. Thor was ko’d but he woke up in pain because despite him being superhuman in extraordinary ways he isn’t the genetic monster that the Hulk physically is.

He was harmed just not beaten the same can be said of the force of the lightning jump punch. Look at the force wave of that punch. Both guys can withstand a lot of punishment and fight back but that doesn’t mean they weren’t harmed.

Originally posted by FrothByte
How can this still a debate after Ragnarok and IW? At this point it's pretty clear that Thor > Hulk.
Because Thor didn’t beat him despite the skill advantage. If he has durability, etc. he should mop the floor with the Hulk but he doesn’t so that alone should lead you to the conclusion you’re wrong here.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
So are you saying Odins appearance in the 2 scenes where Thor is getting his ass handed to him hardest, looking on the verge of defeat only to turn the tide after is coincidence? It wasn't.

I'm going by what I saw on screen, the only reason I put "imo" was because I'm not the writer and cannot prove it, but without the writer spoon feeding every scene to us that's what I (and everyone I spoke to personally) took from it.

Plenty of you guys have been saying exactly that though.

Nah, it's definitely iyo because I haven't seen anyone else interpreting those scenes that way. It doesn't even make sense my friend.

Thor even says to Hulk - You didnt smash anything.. I WON THAT FIGHT

As pertains durability, Hulk has absolutely nothing to compare to this:

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Nah, it's definitely iyo because I haven't seen anyone else interpreting those scenes that way. It doesn't even make sense my friend.
It is his opinion just as it is yours. Popularity holds no weight in a debate. You were never good at debating you should probably stop.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Knocking Hulk away twice is "wrecking"? You mustn't have been in many fights. Thor launched Hulk when he used Hulks OWN momentum against him, the subsequent hammer shots had nothing like the same kind of affect and were just pissing Hulk off.
Um, Lol! Momentum? This isn't baseball. Thor smashed Hulk across the arena and severely damaged the wall. Thor used his SKILL and waited for the perfect opportunity to blast Hulk. He was also CLEARLY HOLDING BACK as he kept saying stuff like "You're embarrasing me in front of all these people" and "I know you're in there Banner, don't worry I'll get you out". Thor wasn't trying to Hurt Hulk until Hulk pissed him off enough to make him Go GOD MODE. Then Thor was wrecking his shit and had to be cheap shotted by Grandmaster for Hulk to "Win" Give me a break, it's clear as day that after Ragnarok and IW, Thor is greater than Hulk in pretty much every category. I'll concede Strength to Hulk though.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Thor even says to Hulk - You didnt smash anything.. I WON THAT FIGHT
They both disagreed but Thor lied a lot in that film. His ego tends to get in the way. He was letting his ego running wild about killing Thanos as well. Sure he believes in his abilities but he sometimes runs into delusional thinking. He sure as **** didn’t end up killing Thanos despite his delusions.

😂