KMC Comic Book Tiers (v2.0)

Started by DarkSaint8530 pages

super adaptoid I wouldn't place him, unless we had specific versions. At least Amazo has the base 5/7 members.

gorr? do we consider him skyfather or high trans? I think Trans.

ghost? hm? mm? (ironman villain) - The creepy guy who could phase? Loved him. I would say MM.

mister negative? hm? mm? - Depends on how one views his control power, tbh. I am inclined to say MM.

Mister Negative - MM.

Gorr - Off the list entirely.

how the eff is guardian (alpha flight) lh when tony is only hm?? THAT is an egregious error....

Originally posted by leonidas
how the eff is guardian (alpha flight) lh

Mungiforce.

it was a rhetorical question but yeah, he needs to be moved down for sure.

and why is man-beast lh? 😕

Originally posted by leonidas
and why is man-beast lh? 😕
The Hell? XD

Are we going to get a Skyfather list anytime soon?

Yeah, I'll edit their current placements for sure.

Any consensus about the other proposals yet?

not sure. not many comments. but i think medusa was high meta or mid meta not low meta for sure.

Mister Negative - MM

Mongoose - MM

U-Foes - Vector and Ironclad both for HM. Probably the others too but I need to re-read their stuff.

Also, Namor to LH.

MM Mongoose didn't he take on both Thor and Spiderman? Don't know about other showings though.

Whoops, I wasn't thinking of Mongoose at all, wrong character. Nix my vote on him.

you're probably not far off with him anyway. he had one good showing blitzing masterson but was handled easily later. spidey was shown to be fast than he was. he does have some additional weapons that might get him to hm, maybe. unless i'm missing a couple of showings for him, mm/hm is about right i think.

Sorry for the delay... a few of my opinions:

super adaptoid- Yeah, I'm not sure how we would define his 'base'..?
u-foes- Defer
midgard serpent- Trans
gorr- Trans
mongoose- MM
gray gargoyle- MM
ghost- MM
mister negative- MM

👆

Made the following changes:

midgard serpent- Trans
gorr- Trans
mongoose- MM
gray gargoyle- MM
ghost- MM
mister negative- MM

*Kept Super-Adaptoid and U-Foes off the list. Also moved Guardian and Man-Beast down a tier.

Any other proposals that need sorted?

Why would Magik be considered a meta when zatanna, mirror master, black bolt, juggernaut, hellstrom, she hulk, magneto and some other people are considered heralds? She's a candidate for ss on earth and is a hell lord and ss in limbo.

Where would hope summers and danger be placed?

I actually agree and suggest illyana to lh. /shrug

As for danger I’d say hm. Hope is a lot tougher because of how specific her powers are. Against mutants she’s almost like black Alice. Not quite but I think they comparison isn’t terrible. But against anyone else...? Not sure she can be fairly placed on the list. Not sure what the others think.

I thought Magik was already LH. Agreed, she should go there.

Danger - HM

Hope, no accurate way to place her.

^ i like the way this guy thinks. 👆