KMC Comic Book Tiers (v2.0)

Started by Galan00730 pages

Originally posted by Philosophía
Figured it'd be time to bump this..

Icon [Milestone] to mid-herald?

My initial thought was low herald, but admittedly, I don't remember a whole lot from Icon, so the RT will be a nice refresher. 👆

Tier 3 - Herald

High
Adam Warlock, Annihilus (/w/ CCR), Asmodel, Atrocitus, Brimstone, Cyborg Superman, Despero, Doomsday (DOS), Doomsday (Gog Wars), The Eradicator (Fortress Mode), Firestorm, Flash (Barry Allen, Wally West, Bart Allen), Genis-Vell, Godspeed, Grail, Grand Regent Thragg, Green Lanterns (Alan Scott, Hal Jordan, Kyle Rayner), Helspont, Imperiex Probes, John Constantine, Majestic, Maxima, Obsidian, Orion, Plutonian, Quasar, Qztr, Sentry (no Void), Silver Surfer, Sinestro, Spartan 3.0, Starbrand, Starro the Conqueror, Talisman, Thor, The Weird, Ultraman, Wonder Woman, Zatanna, Zod, Zoom (Hunter Solomon)

😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Tier 3 - Herald

High
Adam Warlock, Annihilus (/w/ CCR), Asmodel, Atrocitus, Brimstone, Cyborg Superman, Despero, Doomsday (DOS), Doomsday (Gog Wars), The Eradicator (Fortress Mode), Firestorm, Flash (Barry Allen, Wally West, Bart Allen), Genis-Vell, Godspeed, Grail, Grand Regent Thragg, Green Lanterns (Alan Scott, Hal Jordan, Kyle Rayner), Helspont, Imperiex Probes, John Constantine, Majestic, Maxima, Obsidian, Orion, Plutonian, Quasar, Qztr, Sentry (no Void), Silver Surfer, Sinestro, Spartan 3.0, Starbrand, Starro the Conqueror, Talisman, [b]Thor
, The Weird, Ultraman, Wonder Woman, Zatanna, Zod, Zoom (Hunter Solomon)

😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 [/B]

Thor is like Juggernaut, living on reputation. Now that he's back to having the Odin-Force and the power cosmic he should maybe be able to compete with that tier 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
My initial thought was low herald, but admittedly, I don't remember a whole lot from Icon, so the RT will be a nice refresher. 👆
👆

I'm starting it just now.

Finished:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f98/t665645.html

The info-tool and maker will be really useful in potential tourneys. 😂

Tell me what you guys think of the ranking.

Icon for mid based on reading the respect thread

dude has some solid feats from post crisis

I'd rate him above blue marvel

I'd say mid for Icon as well.

Random bump, but the discussion in the questions thread got me thinking...

Should Skuttlebutt(BRB's ship) be included on the list? If so, where should she be placed?

*Also, I added Icon to mid-herald.

Moving this to the CBvF to see if any others are interested in discussing the current character placements, and/or adding new characters to the list.

*Please refer back to the OP for the general rules/guidelines of this thread.

I wish we add cosmic and abstract tiers soon

Eclipso should be out of the list entirely, especially with the new JLD run Eclipso is definitely above skyfather, Orion should note on the sidebar his avatar is High Herald. Because New Gods' true forms are above that

Some suggestions

Skyfather:
Knull
Gorr (moves up from Trans)
Apex Luthor
GDS Darkseid
White Lantern Kyle Rayner
Michael Korvac

Trans:
Pre-Crisis Captain Marvel
Pre-Zero Hour Mon-El
John Constantine (even no prep he's ridiculous)
Invictus
Darkseid (Avatar)
Sinestrollax
Old King Thor (Without Necrosword)

Mid Street:
Comedian
Ozymandias

I wanna say Wally West and Hal Jordan all have feats above current High Herald tier but I digress.

Originally posted by MrMind
I wish we add cosmic and abstract tiers soon

Eclipso should be out of the list entirely, especially with the new JLD run Eclipso is definitely above skyfather, Orion should note on the sidebar his avatar is High Herald. Because New Gods' true forms are above that

Some suggestions

Skyfather:
Knull
Gorr (moves up from Trans)
Apex Luthor
GDS Darkseid
White Lantern Kyle Rayner
Michael Korvac

Trans:
Pre-Crisis Captain Marvel
Pre-Zero Hour Mon-El
John Constantine (even no prep he's ridiculous)
Invictus
Darkseid (Avatar)
Sinestrollax
Old King Thor (Without Necrosword)

Mid Street:
Comedian
Ozymandias

I wanna say Wally West and Hal Jordan all have feats above current High Herald tier but I digress.

I personally think should also move Mordru and Nabu out of the list, In recent JLD issues both get a lot of uber feats

Originally posted by MrMind
I wish we add cosmic and abstract tiers soon

Eclipso should be out of the list entirely, especially with the new JLD run Eclipso is definitely above skyfather, Orion should note on the sidebar his avatar is High Herald. Because New Gods' true forms are above that

Some suggestions

Skyfather:
Knull
Gorr (moves up from Trans)
Apex Luthor
GDS Darkseid
White Lantern Kyle Rayner
Michael Korvac

Trans:
Pre-Crisis Captain Marvel
Pre-Zero Hour Mon-El
John Constantine (even no prep he's ridiculous)
Invictus
Darkseid (Avatar)
Sinestrollax
Old King Thor (Without Necrosword)

Mid Street:
Comedian
Ozymandias

I wanna say Wally West and Hal Jordan all have feats above current High Herald tier but I digress.

I could just make it "pre-Rebirth" Eclipso or somesuch, because yeah... Eclipso, Nabu, and Mordru are obviously well beyond Skyfather currently.

Most of your other proposals seem fair at first glance. 👆

If Icon is pushed up to Mid Herald, Beta Ray Bill should be pushed up to High Herald since his fts piss all over Icons.

Originally posted by carver9
If Icon is pushed up to Mid Herald, Beta Ray Bill should be pushed up to High Herald since his fts piss all over Icons.

😂

like getting owned by gladiator? 😆

Let's....try and keep the infighting out of this thread, guys.

I'm against adding characters above skyfather -- because I'm pretty sure it would soon devolve into ruffled feathers for quite a few. At least for now. I'm also for taking Eclipso, Nabu and Mordru off the list, obviously.

I wouldn't want to move one-arc amping of characters to the list [i.e. Apex Lex] so I'd be against that -- besides, somebody who has all the forces at his disposal [Still force alone...assuming we consider end-of-arc Lex] probably shouldn't even be here.

I'm against Knull at all on the list for now, until he actually does something other than losing at every step.
Did we stop considering future realities as alternate realities? [i.e. Gorr, Old King Thor]. Against Gorr.
I don't think Old King Thor is only trans -- but a skyfather.
Agree with the street guys. Agree with Pre-Crisis Captain Marvel to trans.

I don't agree about including Darkseid -- only if we specify something about post-Crisis/pre-Flashpoint avatar, since in the New 52 it's a bit...different. I'm not sure if Sinestrollax is only trans -- or in general where he stands. Constantine is too big of a glass canon, so it's hard to judge.

I'll have to think a bit about the rest, and even the ones above. Just typed some random thoughts.

Originally posted by carver9
If Icon is pushed up to Mid Herald, Beta Ray Bill should be pushed up to High Herald since his fts piss all over Icons.
Imagine typing this, while Hulk is mid-herald as a slow, grounded brick, in the same tier with the likes of John Stewart, Magneto or Loki.

Didn't Sinestrollax slaughter a room full of Guardians? Can't see a translevel being doing that.

And is there a reason why Beta Ray isn't high herald? Seem like he should be there for sure. Especially with his recent feats.

Originally posted by MrMind
😂

like getting owned by gladiator? 😆

Is that how this works? Let me know

Guys, this thread isn't about personal vendettas or w/e. It's about having legitimate, intelligible discussions about character placements.

I did warn you it'd end like that, lol.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
I did warn you it'd end like that, lol.

Hey, I just gave a suggestion and then someone mentions another person getting beat up. Happens to a lot of characters. Oh well