Thor vs. Captain Marvel

Started by Josh_Alexander8 pages

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Are Quan and Josh high?

Thor took the full power of a star. He is the most durable Avenger, more so than Hulk or Carol (going by feats at least).

I already rebuked the "Full Power of a star" statement by Etri in other threads.

Ohh, and last time I checked:

Black hole>>>>Neutron star

Originally posted by Silent Master
If this was Thor vs a DC character, quan and josh would be using the same feats to prove that Thor is superior. but since it's against a Marvel character they like better. the feats don't count.

I'm honestly baffled people were dumb enough to think "Kevin Feige said" was a valid argument. This wasn't even coming from people who are newcomers, but people you'd think would know better by now.

No, IIRC you tried to play a semantic game by saying the beam was larger than him and thus he technically didn't get hit with 100% of the power.

I'm reminded of Joss Whedon saying Buffy was as strong as Spider-Man.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, IIRC you tried to play a semantic game by saying the beam was larger than him and thus he technically didn't get hit with 100% of the power.

Yes, which is actually the reason why he didn't receive the FULL/ALL power of the Neutron star.

To receive the full power/energy of a star you would have to harvest every single beam of energy coming out of it. In other words, you would require a DYSON SPHERE

-Which is basically as structure that sorrounds the entire sun to harvest all it's light and radiation.

Saying that Thor received the full power of a star is like saying that I harvest the full power of the sun with the solar panel in my backyard 😂

P.S: It was no game, it was science 😉

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I didn't say that Thor couldn't survive in space for a period of time. I said the amount of time he can be in the void without repercussion is unknown.
Also, we don't know HOW he was travelling through space whilst Hemidall's absence.

On the other hand, CM is certainly inmune to space.

When did Loki survived a fall from space and ended up on Earth?

Carol obliterated a Kree [B]battleship with her body like a spear through a bare chest. Thor tearing metal from a space shuttle is in no way comparable to that.

Also, Thor ripping chunks of ships is a feat of strength not resistance. And, I already said I believed Thor to be stronger. [/B]

And what makes you certain that Carol is immune to space whereas Thor is questionable?

Originally posted by FrothByte
And what makes you certain that Carol is immune to space whereas Thor is questionable?

Because in the end scene we see her travelling at the speed of light alongside the Skrulls in search of a new planet.

Even if Carol travels so fast, she would spend a good amount of time in space traversing galaxies...So, she is clearly confortable with the term void.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Thor needed help taking on ships? Who was helping Thor take out ships in Infinity War?

If you're referring to Valkyrie, she took out some ships on her own but she didn't help Thor with the ships that he took down. And he did this without his powers.

in Ragnarok. He has his axe but without it he is nowhere near as powerful so moot point.

Yes, some not all. These were not military grade sporting weapons designed to bury earth. The kree ships and weaponry>>Gms pitiful forces. Thor needed help against a much weaker division whereas Marvel did so with relative ease.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Quan just cant stand that Hulk is out of the top 2 Avenger powerhouses. While Thor is clearly still in.

Dont worry Quano, Maybe Hulk can make it to no.3 if he goes World Breaker or something.

I like Thor and hulk the same. I do not like Cm anywhere near those two but unlike you I am objective. Thor is not as strong as the hulk. See Avengers 1, Ragnarok, and Infinity War as proof.

All within hulks power unlike build me a great weapon mr. dwarf.

😂

No, it's not. it's just like saying someone that survived a nuke going off a 100 feet away took a nuke.

You're just trying to downplay the feat, it's a typical troll tactic.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, it's not. it's just like saying someone that survived a nuke going off a 100 feet away took a nuke.

You're just trying to downplay the feat, it's a typical troll tactic.

Use the quote button you idiot. You just pop in and vomit all over the threads.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I like Thor and hulk the same.

Nah youre a Thor Hater.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Nah youre a Thor Hater.
You can pretend but I unlike you repped the character in a battlezone.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You can pretend but I unlike you repped the character in a battlezone.

Nah you hate him. Everyone here knows this. Youre an emotional wreck and got all emotional over the spanking Hulk got over the last couple of films. That and Thor being shown to be (without question) the most powerful Avenger (pre Cap Marvel).

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Nah you hate him. Everyone here knows this. Youre an emotional wreck and got all emotional over the spanking Hulk got over the last couple of films. That and Thor being shown to be (without question) the most powerful Avenger (pre Cap Marvel).
They are tied. You can pretend though. It only makes you look like a Trumper in the end. Ignore all evidence to the contrary and feeling up the conclusion.

I have supoorted Thor for years. Plenty of sigs created with comic Thor. You are just upset because Hulk is stronger.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Because in the end scene we see her travelling at the speed of light alongside the Skrulls in search of a new planet.

Even if Carol travels so fast, she would spend a good amount of time in space traversing galaxies...So, she is clearly confortable with the term void.

If she was traveling in the speed of light then she would have been pretty much invisible to our eyes. And even if she was, I don't see how that makes it sure that she's immune to space whereas Thor is not.

We see Carol flying through space (but only for a brief period of time). We see Thor walking around, talking and working out in space. I don't see why Carol's feat somehow makes it clear that she's immune whereas Thor is questionable.

Seems like you're applying double standard.

An unbiased person would simply conclude that they can both survive in space, as that is what their feats suggest.

Originally posted by quanchi112
They are tied

Whatever you say Thor Hater.

Evidence? Lol

You mean like when Hulk couldnt overpower a Thor without any Uru weapon? That evidence?

The fight you claimed before hand would prove Hulk was the real powerhouse on the Avengers 😆

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Whatever you say Thor Hater.

Evidence? Lol

You mean like when Hulk couldnt overpower a Thor without any Uru weapon? That evidence?

The fight you claimed before hand would prove Hulk was the real powerhouse on the Avengers 😆

It further established Hulk was stronger. He ragdolled and caught his attacks with his superior strength. Each film showed Thor is strong enough to contend with the hulk but he needs to evade and rely on his fighting prowess to win which he has not done.

Tony stark proved it in Ragnarok. Strongest avenger.

Yeah Hulk fanboys always need Stark trolling as an argument.

I think Hulk fanboys are just naturally dense.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Yeah Hulk fanboys always need Stark trolling as an argument.

I think Hulk fanboys are just naturally dense.

A direct statement you ignore because you are a fanboy. I like them equally. Thor is a better fighter more of a true hero whereas hulk is the reluctant hero who is a loner. Great for different reasons. Hulk is stronger. Obviously.