Endless vs Marvel Abstracts

Started by leonidas18 pages

@phil--i can honestly say i don't recall any discussions revolving around the size of the companies, or the beyonder as he relates to size. but i may just not be remembering.

We agree that the infinite pre-Crisis Multiverse was bigger than the pre-ZH post-Crisis Universe. We agree that current DC is bigger than the infinite pre-Crisis Multiverse.

hmm, i'm not even 100% sure i'd agree with all those things. each version of what made up dc, STILL had essentially infinite different dimensions in them. some new dimensions have been added or removed or whatever. is one all-encompassing 'universe' with access to a literal infinity of other universes, really...."smaller" than an infinity of smaller 'alternate' universes? dude, i really have no idea. are the 52 smaller than the pre-crisis collection of alternates? again, i don't know. you can still access infinite dimensions from either, you have access to hypertime, or the bleed (like marvel has (had??) the superflow) so man, i'll be honest--i'm not sure all of those comparisons follow as neatly as you think they do. again, at least not imo.

@phil--i can honestly say i don't recall any discussions revolving around the size of the companies, or the beyonder as he relates to size. but i may just not be remembering.
Every Beyonder discussion has been about how he's millions of times bigger and more powerful than the entirety of Marvel, and in order to argue against that, you'd have to argue that DC is that much bigger, too, in terms of size/power -- even though Beyonder, himself, is also Marvel. But that's having your cake and eating it, too. Which is what's been going on since 2007.

some new dimensions have been added or removed or whatever.

This is not a whatever, though. Hypertime came into being a decade after COIE -- if I sent you back in time right now, would you say the....let's say, 1990 DC Universe is equivalent with Marvel? Would you say that one infinite Universe is equivalent with Marvel's infinite Multiverse? You're applying the knowledge you have right now about how DC has always been retroactively [Hypertime, upper dimensions comparisons etc], to argue that it's always been that size -- but knowing what you knew then, you wouldn't say the same.

This is...obvious. Nobody argues that the size of DC as it was presented in the early 90s, is the same as it is presented now [and retroactively, technically, now that also makes it that big then, too].

In DC, right now, you can go to the Monitor world, and observe the infinity of infinities inside an Orrery. Or you can go to the 4th world. Or you can go to the 5th dimension. You have infinity -- then infinity of infinities -- then infinities that makes the clusters of infinities look small etc.

How big is current DC?

posted by Philosophia

We agree that the infinite pre-Crisis Multiverse was bigger than the pre-ZH post-Crisis Universe. We agree that current DC is bigger than the infinite pre-Crisis Multiverse. We agree that the Beyonder realm was millions of times bigger than the pre-Retcon Marvel infinite Multiverse. We agree on comparing a lot of infinities with clear delimitations on which one is bigger than the other. But when it comes to comparing inter-company, well... I mean, of course, I get it. But still. DC fans have been slammed over the head for the last....15 years? On how big Beyonder is? How big Marvel is? How many levels of infinity there are? [as I said...I'm not talking about you].

Suddenly, there's things in DC that makes the Beyonder/Marvel like a speck themselves comparatively. Surely, you've seen all of this and you understand why they do this when the tables turn.

Nothing in DC makes Marvel look like a speck. It only "seems" that at the current state of affairs DC is exploring its cosmology more than Marvel. But we're talking about the entire history of each company here, do you really think anything Mr Mind posted does not apply to Marvel?

Infinite spatial and fractional dimensions? explored in detail in Dr Strange 21.

countless universes inside bubbles? Dr strange has gone to random realms like this since the 60s.

Metaverses? Howard the duck series.

infinite multiverses? Quasar and captain marvel series.

the morrison map which shows infinitely bigger realms nested inside each other? Silver Surfer 1401-45 showed such universes which are infinitely nested in each other( and make the universes inside them look insignificant) ad infinitum.

Im not sure if you were talking about me or not but i think ive been consistent in the past to point out that the two companies are equal in terms of cosmology.

Originally posted by operator616
Nothing in DC makes Marvel look like a speck. It only "seems" that at the current state of affairs DC is exploring its cosmology more than Marvel. But we're talking about the entire history of each company here, do you really think anything Mr Mind posted does not apply to Marvel?
Putting things in "" doesn't suddenly make it an illusion, though. Yes, taking into account the entire history of companies and the arguments presented, Marvel is smaller, compare to what DC is shown as.

Infinite spatial and fractional dimensions? explored in detail in Dr Strange 21.

infinite multiverses? Quasar and captain marvel series.

Yes, infinite dimensions also exist in Marvel 👆

countless universes inside bubbles? Dr strange has gone to random realms like this since the 60s.

the morrison map which shows infinitely bigger realms nested inside each other? Silver Surfer 1401-45 showed such universes which are infinitely nested in each other( and make the universes inside them look insignificant) ad infinitum.

The mainstream Universe(s) are the bubbles. The DCU itself exists inside bubbles in the 4th world:
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_medium/8/80518/6897121-0007872617-HLPSv.jpg

Darkseid's shadow was cast across the entire DC Multiverse when he fell:
https://imgur.com/X7nlqjQ

So please, let's start with something simple like this.

Show me something as big comparatively with the Marvel Multiverse as the 4th World, and we can work our way up from there. 👆

Metaverses? Howard the duck series.
Metaverse is not about size, it's about purpose. The source of all stories/cosmology - which is what the prime Universe in DC is, for all of what's built around it, as Manhattan observed. I'm mainly talking about size. I think Mr. Mind was trying to show the diversity of the DC - if not the size, with that one.

Im not sure if you were talking about me or not but i think ive been consistent in the past to point out that the two companies are equal in terms of cosmology.
I don't think we've ever talked about this so, suffice to say, it's not about you - or even necessarily one person.

Also -- I'd appreciate some scans, kind of like Mr. Mind did 🙂 I'd post them in your stead, but it's double-work and I'd be talking to myself.

lol what?

The highest numbered Marvel Universe known is this: Earth-28,744,923,048,932, on top of being a true 'Quantum Universe' - every single possibility exists, with beings that are able to exist outside this "Quantum Universe" and act upon it without causing new Universes to split off.

There are two videos by the Imaginary Axis that discusses the Multiverses of both:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGDoIFvVAwM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAt0xpQe934

Alongside the First Firmament, these are five other Eternities, each one the living embodiment of 'infinite multiverses', with Infinity becoming the embodiment of the Seventh Multiverse (the one pre-Secret Wars). They themselves were also shown to have existed and have returned from a place called the Far Shore, and took the First Firmanent to a place beyond the Far Shore, where everything begins.

Last time I checked, DC comics doesn't have anything on this kind of scale.

Originally posted by leonidas
as i said, i was just using death as an example--marvel doesn't really have a known equivalent to vertigo death (though that marvel parody seems to indicate that marvel would be happy to say vertigo death also rules death in marvel--i'd be very cool with that....) if we assume a multi-eternity though, then the other pillars likely exist as well. my point was though that at the highest levels the entities (like ultimate supreme beings) are relatively equivalent imo. 👆

Now you're saying it but for years TOAA and LT were treated as untouchables at abstract level, Galactus and Odin untouchables at skyfather level (God forbid anyone suggest any skyfather coughMordrucough could beat Odin, the poor fella gets banned by your reports).

Why would anyone be exempt from the same logic? Because they are forum's sacred cows?

and maybe they are exceptions, but they prove my point. in marvel it's the same--higher dimensional beings lose to lower ones who aren't as powerful as beings below them. how many times in marvel or dc has a 'god' or 'new god' been whipped down by a random earth hero? each time that happens, a lower level being defeats a higher one whether they originate from the fourth world or the sphere of the gods. it's no where near as rare as you think it is, imo, or maybe you just don't think the 4th world is a higher dimensional plane than the earth universe is? what difference does it really make if the 4th world is bigger than dc's earth universe if earth heroes can beat down 4th worlders?

Because most of the times those are retconned by writers as avatars. Thanos losses are accepted as retconned by Starlin but same can't be accepted for new gods? Hypocrisy much?

@mrmind--you do like your list of scales, eh? lol. scale is irrelevant when you have lower dimensional beings beating higher dimensional ones. again, scale doesn't necessarily translate to power. in marvel, pym grew large enough to reach the 16th dimensional overspace, the realm that exists beyond the multiverse, but i don't think anyone is calling pym a supreme being--aside from scientist supreme. 👆

That was retconned as Loki messing with Pym. And he wasn't in 16th dimension and marvel dimensional space isn't structured as DC is.

@phil--not really a fair shot. in the latest jl arc the terms universe, world and multiverse were used with complete and almost random abandon. the witch mark arc also made a mess of terminology talking about magic on EARTH, then skipping around to dimension, universe and multiverse--all seemingly used interchangeably. terminology has ALWAYS been grossly mishandled by both companies. masters and abhi have been wrangling over terminology in several threads. sides choose and highlight the terminology that best suits their needs.....

regardless, i find comparing 'infinities' is a useless exercise. how big is overspace? underspace? the realm of the one below all? the realm of the one above all? bigger than the beyond realm? no idea. just because a caption doesn't say 'this realm is this many times bigger than this realm!' doesn't mean everything in marvel is small. i mean, really?

i don't believe i have ever been of any opinion other than the one that says dc/marvel are relatively the same 'size' throughout their existences--though i don't ever really recall having this level of discussion about it. i mean if we're comparing, do we factor into the marvel side the countless MULTIVERSES that make it up and that interact directly from time to time with marvel's mainstream multiverse? i mean you're factoring in the dark multiverse so i guess we should include the countless multiverses for marvel, and the megaverses beyond those? and how big is a megaverse? are the other multiverses in marvel bigger than the mainstream one? i sure as hell don't know. and the realm of overspace--does it surround all those megaverses? or the beyond realm? the realm where the infinites exist which appears to be beyond the multiverse as well (if we view eternity as a multiverse)?

the exercise becomes absurd imo. you want to say dc is bigger? 👆
i....really don't care. my only issue is with being TOLD it's bigger, like if you don't believe it you're an idiot as though it were some simple, abc comparison. it's not. at all, and never has been.

not sure why the issue of which is bigger really means anything anyway when lower dimensional beings beat higher dimensional ones all the time in BOTH companies.

This honestly feels like a bitter rant at this point.

Soon, we'll see it argued that the DeMatteis' Macroverse in Silver Surfer is the same as the 4th World. Be prepared for a new era.

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Alongside the First Firmament, these are five other Eternities, each one the living embodiment of 'infinite multiverses', with Infinity becoming the embodiment of the Seventh Multiverse (the one pre-Secret Wars). They themselves were also shown to have existed and have returned from a place called the Far Shore, and took the First Firmanent to a place beyond the Far Shore, where everything begins.

Last time I checked, DC comics doesn't have anything on this kind of scale.


Marvel has seven multiverses then? Because DC has infinite multiverses.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/8/80518/6897137-0147744403-Hv5aV.jpg

Originally posted by Philosophía
Soon, we'll see it argued that the DeMatteis' Macroverse in Silver Surfer is the same as the 4th World. Be prepared for a new era.

Good, I can argue random new gods creating universes as an actual feat, random GLs creating countless alternate realities etc

Originally posted by abhilegend
Marvel has seven multiverses then? Because DC has infinite multiverses.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/8/80518/6897137-0147744403-Hv5aV.jpg

Aside from the fact that those six Multiverses (the First Firmament is a Universe) all existed before the present Eternity chronologically. As in, those Eternities existed long before the present Marvel Universe, continued to exist afterwards the next Multiverse succeeded them.

Here is what exists within the Eternity/Multiverse we are familiar with for Marvel:

Universes where the natural laws of nature differ; pocket universes where Gods and demons live; Universes where natural laws range from science to magic, but share concepts; Universes with spatial dimensions measured in "irrational numbers", with Universes with spatial dimensions lower than 2.726(etc) or higher than 6.298(etc) each having their own clusters, each administered to by the Living Tribunal.

So, unless you try to claim that the DC Multiverse somehow encompasses all of the above and more, the scale starts to weigh in favor of the Marvel Multiverse. And with the existence of the other Eternities, there is the possibility that all of them bore similar structures as their youngest brother.

past multiverses in DC Comics are just the same Multiverse that underwent cosmological changes due to drastic cosmic events, which is why you have entities able to remember the events and worlds of DC all the way back to Pre-Crisis. I.e. all the big "Crisis events" took place within the confines of the Bleed, meaning all the changes to the structure of the Universe/Multiverse were confined to the Bleed during the cross-over events where that happened.

There are only "multiple multiverses" in the Bleed now because Convergence's ending resulted in the Anti-Monitor being stopped before he could destroy the original, Pre-Crisis Multiverse, effectively turning every iteration of the DC Universe (those within the Bleed) into one cohesive whole, with each "multiverse" existing in its own grouping within the Bleed.

With the multiple Eternities, on the other hand, it would be as if Relic's Universe still existed, rather than collapsing and dying out completely to make way for the DC Universe as we know it. The Eternities are ancient Multiverse embodiments, each of them predating the modern Marvel Multiverse, each of them still alive.

Putting things in "" doesn't suddenly make it an illusion, though. Yes, taking into account the entire history of companies and the arguments presented, Marvel is smaller, compare to what DC is shown as.

And just so we're clear you completely agree with Mr Mind's argument correct? So limbo, gods sphere, 4th and 5th dimension completely dwarf the entirety of marvel including the beyond realm, right?

Hm. You seem to have failed to follow the discussion right here. It's not a matter of 'pocket dimensions' inside bubbles. The mainstream Universe(s) are the bubbles. The DCU itself exists inside bubbles in the 4th world: https://static.comicvine.com/upload...72617-HLPSv.jpg

It seems you failed to follow the discussion because nowhere did i ever mention pocket universes. I was merely claiming that Marvel has an instance similar to that New Gods arc. Anyway here is Dr Strange going to a realm where each atom is a fully fledged universe:

https://imgur.com/2e58c0fc-021c-4835-a000-2f46ae87350c
https://imgur.com/d21644aa-355e-4bbe-ab26-bfc5ef699475

Also im assuming you're aware of the size of the beyond realm?

Darkseid's shadow was cast across the entire DC Multiverse when he fell: https://imgur.com/X7nlqjQ

So please, let's start with something simple like this. Show me something as big comparatively with the Marvel Multiverse as the 4th World, and we can work our way up from there.

Great feat for Darkseid. Personally i was always under the impression that it referred to his essence as dying and dragging the multiverse with him, not actually literally falling on the multiverse. But it's open to interpretation i guess. Morrison did seem to turn the New Gods to living concepts.

Anyway, here's the scan from surfer's run: Basicaly the idea is that Surfer's universe (616) and other all mainstream universes (referred to as the "macroverse" in this story arc) exist inside a bigger universe which in turn exists within a bigger one, ad infinitum (so infinite layers above)

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NF2ZQHVZLDc/VoTbjsoLz0I/AAAAAAAAUSQ/N2OSXdR8-Eo/s1600-Ic42/RCO018.jpg
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-nx8f_HDNWpo/VoTbj9sKfpI/AAAAAAAAUSQ/NvcczoF8IRY/s1600-Ic42/RCO019.jpg

Also Dematteis followed up on that idea in Defenders i believe.

Metaverse is not about size, it's about purpose. The source of all stories/cosmology - which is what the prime Universe in DC is, for all of what's built around it, as Manhattan observed. I'm mainly talking about size. I think Mr. Mind was trying to show the diversity of the DC - if not the size, with that one.

The metaverse in DC was previously featured in a superman story where it contained every possibility, that's what i was referring to not the new one which you're referring to. But Marvel has all kinds of diversity, it had something called the "ideaverse" in deadpool comics a few years back.

I don't think we've ever talked about this so, suffice to say, it's not about you - or even necessarily one person. Also -- I'd appreciate some scans, kind of like Mr. Mind did smile I'd post them in your stead, but it's double-work and I'd be talking to myself.

Fair enough.

^^ Check the latest Doomsday Clock issues, Op.

Originally posted by operator616
And just so we're clear you completely agree with Mr Mind's argument correct? So limbo, gods sphere, 4th and 5th dimension completely dwarf the entirety of marvel including the beyond realm, right?

It seems you failed to follow the discussion because nowhere did i ever mention pocket universes. I was merely claiming that Marvel has an instance similar to that New Gods arc. Anyway here is Dr Strange going to a realm where each atom is a fully fledged universe:

https://imgur.com/2e58c0fc-021c-4835-a000-2f46ae87350c
https://imgur.com/d21644aa-355e-4bbe-ab26-bfc5ef699475

Also im assuming you're aware of the size of the beyond realm?

Great feat for Darkseid. Personally i was always under the impression that it referred to his essence as dying and dragging the multiverse with him, not actually literally falling on the multiverse. But it's open to interpretation i guess. Morrison did seem to turn the New Gods to living concepts.

Anyway, here's the scan from surfer's run: Basicaly the idea is that Surfer's universe (616) and other all mainstream universes (referred to as the "macroverse" in this story arc) exist inside a bigger universe which in turn exists within a bigger one, ad infinitum (so infinite layers above)

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-NF2ZQHVZLDc/VoTbjsoLz0I/AAAAAAAAUSQ/N2OSXdR8-Eo/s1600-Ic42/RCO018.jpg
https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-nx8f_HDNWpo/VoTbj9sKfpI/AAAAAAAAUSQ/NvcczoF8IRY/s1600-Ic42/RCO019.jpg

Also Dematteis followed up on that idea in Defenders i believe.

The metaverse in DC was previously featured in a superman story where it contained every possibility, that's what i was referring to not the new one which you're referring to. But Marvel has all kinds of diversity, it had something called the "ideaverse" in deadpool comics a few years back.

Fair enough.

the imgur links for that similar new god arc is broken my guy, would love to see it. seems interesting

Soon, we'll see it argued that the DeMatteis' Macroverse in Silver Surfer is the same as the 4th World. Be prepared for a new era.

Re-read the arc. The Macroverse was playing the role of the multiverse in that arc. It's because the microverse was featured as well, so Dematteis wanted to differentiate between levels of reality. Where the macroverse meant the collection of regular sized universes. While the microverse was the small scale universe. And yet there were infinitely higher universes than the macroverse

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
the imgur links for that similar new god arc is broken my guy, would love to see it. seems interesting

https://imgur.com/a/RXC7HqJ

@philosophia please refer to these scans.

Every Beyonder discussion has been about how he's millions of times bigger and more powerful than the entirety of Marvel, and in order to argue against that, you'd have to argue that DC is that much bigger, too, in terms of size/power

that is a pretty stupid stance to take. /shrug

the beyonder was a bit different though i guess in that he was the literal manifestation of his realm. the monitors for example, are not actual embodiments (ie conceptual entities representing the whole of their sphere). i GUESS beyonder (pre retcon) could be seen as being a form of abstract entity. maybe. anyway, this isn't an argument i've made, so.....

This is not a whatever, though. Hypertime came into being a decade after COIE -- if I sent you back in time right now, would you say the....let's say, 1990 DC Universe is equivalent with Marvel?

yes....depicted differently though but still filled with infinite worlds...

Would you say that one infinite Universe is equivalent with Marvel's infinite Multiverse?

but dc has never been just one universe....there have always been different worlds/dimensions/times whatever.

You're applying the knowledge you have right now about how DC has always been retroactively [Hypertime, upper dimensions comparisons etc], to argue that it's always been that size -- but knowing what you knew then, you wouldn't say the same.

but that's what the new map is--retroactively applied. we assume the outer spheres have always been in place. if the prime universe/es are small infinitesimal in comparison anyway, it really doesn't matter much how they have fluctuated--i mean from a comparison stand point. if the 3d worlds are almost imperceptible at the higher scales, what does it matter if they've grown some or shrank some--meaningless to the overall size of the multiverse, no?

and hypertime may have only been introduced, but again we need to look at it retroactively imo. but even if not, there were still infinite different worlds in dc. there always has been.

This is...obvious. Nobody argues that the size of DC as it was presented in the early 90s, is the same as it is presented now [and retroactively, technically, now that also makes it that big then, too].

i'd have argued it. 👆

[quote]In DC, right now, you can go to the Monitor world, and observe the infinity of infinities inside an Orrery. Or you can go to the 4th world. Or you can go to the 5th dimension. You have infinity -- then infinity of infinities -- then infinities that makes the clusters of infinities look small etc.

i'd argue it's always been that way, just the infinities now are better defined and ordered and followed by writers.

before the prime universe was shattered by krona into the multiverse that first universe was as infinite as the later multiverse was imo. or at least i've always viewed it that way. the universe was the window, the fractured universes were shards. it's even been drawn that way.

marvel has a similar theory regarding the celestials creating the multiverse. marvel has simply never been as ordered as dc's set up right now. strange made mention of infinities within infinities when talking about the number of universes in the multiverse and even tried to talk about the number being TRANSFINITE. a silly number that i think the writer wanted to imply was GREATER than infinity.

again, my underlying assumption has been, and remains that the 2 companies are essentially the same size. just too many infinities to suggest otherwise imo.

Originally posted by abhilegend
[B]Now you're saying it but for years TOAA and LT were treated as untouchables at abstract level, Galactus and Odin untouchables at skyfather level (God forbid anyone suggest any skyfather coughMordrucough could beat Odin, the poor fella gets banned by your reports).

Why would anyone be exempt from the same logic? Because they are forum's sacred cows?

😂

wtf are you even talking about....? sacred cows?? and where have i ever said marvel's supreme being>dc's? and you didn't get banned for saying mordru could beat odin but it's hilarious that's how you're trying to paint it. lol i don't even think i reported you in that thread, though i said i would. i didn't have to, you made yourself difficult for mods NOT to notice. but glad you're over it though lying about why you were banned isn't the best idea. 👆

Because most of the times those are retconned by writers as avatars. Thanos losses are accepted as retconned by Starlin but same can't be accepted for new gods? Hypocrisy much?

lol what? every time any new god has been beaten by any earth hero or villain has been retconned now? and any time a hero or villain has beaten a god has also been retconned? dude.....

That was retconned as Loki messing with Pym. And he wasn't in 16th dimension and marvel dimensional space isn't structured as DC is.

if that was retconned i never saw it. that would be for the best, but scan? and no sh!t they aren't structured the same. i've said that i hundred times. doesn't mean an outer realm doesn't scale though. universes within universes has been a thing in marvel for a long time.

and bitter rant?? lolol i've been nothing but cordial during this entire discussion. your opinions of everything dc related vs everything marvel related are known by....everyone. which is why your opinion is so meaningless to everyone. you are the consummate dc fanboy, incapable of looking at things in an unbiased way. everyone knows just who and what you are. since i don't want any repeats of our last go-round, carry on talking to whoever will entertain you.
👆