Superman vs. Thor (with a twist)

Started by celeyhyga177 pages
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
My post was a genuine question. With the merging of the timelines, THAT Superman (who was depowered) is now merged with P52 Supes, who fought with WW for 1000s of years, whilst depowered, right?

Originally posted by Stoic
Exactly. Even reduced to human, Thor is still relatively superhuman.

Does the last part of your statement make sense to you? I mean about the 1000's of years.

It think it was nearly a thousand(give or take) and not thousands if we extrapolate from the wording. Even then they went out of their way to make it ambiguous everytime they gave figures.
*shrug*

Originally posted by Supermutant
How in the world did you get that from what I posted? My whole point is that with no powers or equal bodies Thor will be the more skillful fighter. You are the one mentioning that Clark was still a low level super human there. So you had one low level super human vs another one in Savage.

Lolwut? How did you equate to Thor being more skilled when Superman has shown more skills than Thor ever has. Because Savage with an amp beat him AFTER Clark already had fought a tough fight?

Lol you mentioning context then show a "fight" where Aquaman is begging Clark to take a fall. 🤪

LMAO, Clark even goads Arthur to go full tilt against him.

exactly so now Superman has been fighting as long as Thor has plus even severely depowered he's a major threat to Aquaman going all out.

At this point if not even worth opening a thread with Clark in it no matter the circumstances. They can have fun with that.

😂

Typical. Why don't you prove a depowered Thor is stronger or more skilled than Superman.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It think it was nearly a thousand(give or take) and not thousands if we extrapolate from the wording. Even then they went out of their way to make it ambiguous everytime they gave figures.
*shrug*

It was a thousand years. And there were battles lasting centuries (at least that's how I interpreted it, and the fact that Thor said a battle lasted a thousand years supports it). So DS misremembered.

As for the topic, Supermutant is arguing New 52 Superman (regardless of Abhi being right on context or not) when that doesn't apply anymore the way he's arguing? Or that the arguments for Thor still require ignoring what the OP almost certainly meant(that they're in normal human bodies, not Thor having this size and density advantage), or ignoring if we go that route they're arguing hypotheticals while ignoring what a powerless Superman has done on panel?

OK, a fairly low feat for a Parademon was a reanimated Parademon with a large hole in his torso was much stronger than Batman. Given Batman's mediocre feats has him stronger than a SWAT team, I'm gonna say this is at least on the level Stoic is arguing Thor's hypothetical. A powerless, amnesiac Superman did fine against a bunch of them.

Or we could go with him overpowering a spell that could restrain 6 men.

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/RRev89_TEPWbuDxZ1ZtIecpRoTHxJvZgO8zcIoqhKv8eIZpgNsBxVrR4bTs6qBIZ90yg-ihiBcm8=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/ASGBuEAOHblc4bfKQePDC_IuQ9_0Vu9qe_Jy9SZxqEnwNrUfzz3Fjitjr-wdR1EFOrysmUAED-u7=s1600

Or him taking blows from Earth-Man, stronger than a full powered Thor, let alone hypothetical powerless Thor but still superhumanly dense and massive.

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/0jm5TToF089bDaw8OZOoyD4ZryN1KVLBWZlGxsoxHV6wlA3SD9nopZHibWQw7wUdEKrtGHHjw3EL=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/TsIYd34TV3AHLYIM2tkKOxpWh8YzSLGsF_Olk4uOL36FZq542o-bSOEk462Vmiw2Q-Hx6Y4rvD84=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/u7zNVUJPEAfTyx8PW9I2Km579MqvyEAEnRhTFrVBypwTtEbh9wgwapLbmW0_ETsaDyYXtL9Of8X4=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/87NWVamHZk_R6MaODRIiWSl7GN-Cv8r8b5eSeKqtvbrv0hjL77qgdXSl6s7FJhbTI3OULtCEOhGb=s1600

Or surviving reentry heat while powerless.

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/1b4gMW6ZD8fb_KMkYZuuwxXPp-HdYEsZ3NBEIk7R9_Mw9ICGri82mbGfRESQX6ef2THDE-3iTmn0=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/P7fK0ee7SWPJZXf-Cs5C7grUUFGATvHnW4Uf_JLSdn72k-v4gS8fbpZeR1dZ7-fuF6RLeEWrqB_G=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/7QUYnTkbuyxeymU3RUUMrehGQcPhBNcF6haFRfgK4vlTlqj-YQcCv09AydLKAv-7gLweCvIyX3bI=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/Y20AV6uAs0DmgOY9tv-1xOpvy-JuGkfkZITzfgM60JJgSPfUpRZioDf3euOtPat95NW20uxg0-xI=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/zpTcFiVAA9CJrev-ZHL30y4zg5lrnnA-V4VGGo9JMPsZ5E5q0OdevhFle5lss87haKXZ9Dp3Dwnt=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/T4LWFRCHwgeYPCRF1yoyE-FqrG0EhNrYiP5OASRHyNvVD2dgqbFTikHSDjfbVWmmTaOIpR4fUXlI=s1600

https://2.bp.blogspot.com/ssTeQONGPUDeoyZ03lC1bA-BARz7n4gJqHLQNdY_48fV_3m18Ln6OZHbe3_OgWSYgJh98CeHNpem=s1600

I mean if depowered Thor gets the benefit of people arguing hypothetical strength based on his weight/density, then surely Superman should get the benefit of what he's actually done on panel while powerless, right? RIGHT?

Abhi...

https://tinyurl.com/

Bump

Thor would beat the shit out of Superman.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thor would beat the shit out of Superman.

Can powerless Thor lift half million tone with one hand?

Originally posted by NemeBro
By realizing that Thor being "100% human" means that he doesn't have access to the bone and muscle density he does as an Asgardian. What is the confusion here?
Originally posted by abhilegend
Can powerless Thor lift half million tone with one hand?

? Do you now know the definition of powerless? Thor has lost his Asgardian powers, and still been stronger than the Thing. I would not use that as evidence in a "powerless" thread.

Thor. He is way cooler

A completely powerless Clark Kent beat the crap out of Dreadnaut, who had all the powers of Captain Marvel, Martian Manhunter, Elongated Man, Aquaman, and Superman.

Thor gets beaten.

Thor bodies Clark

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
? Do you now know the definition of powerless? Thor has lost his Asgardian powers, and still been stronger than the Thing. I would not use that as evidence in a "powerless" thread.

So I guess not.
Originally posted by Booya_69
Thor bodies Clark

How?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thor would beat the shit out of Superman.

How?

Originally posted by cdtm
A completely powerless Clark Kent beat the crap out of Dreadnaut, who had all the powers of Captain Marvel, Martian Manhunter, Elongated Man, Aquaman, and Superman.

Thor gets beaten.

And he even took Captain Marvels best shots, and was about to kill him.

https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/11125/111256151/5586486-3930545635-rBoYV.jpg

And the scene after that, is this:

Without any powers at all, Clark Kent beats a monster with the entire JLA's powers.

Batman, eat your heart out.

Thor loses to a powerless Clark Kent. Thor WITH powers loses to a powerless Clark Kent.

Originally posted by cdtm

And he even took Captain Marvels best shots, and was about to kill him.

https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/11125/111256151/5586486-3930545635-rBoYV.jpg

And the scene after that, is this:

Without any powers at all, Clark Kent beats a monster with the entire JLA's powers.

Batman, eat your heart out.

Thor loses to a powerless Clark Kent. Thor WITH powers loses to a powerless Clark Kent.

Ignore it all you want. Scans don't lie

If Batman being faster, stronger, or more durable than Wonder Woman counts, so does this.

Who is naked?

Originally posted by deft
Who is naked?

Who do you want to be naked?

Hahaa what the ****.
That is insane.