Hulk vs versatility 1

Started by Stoic18 pages

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I see it as an incapacitation win. Just like Spidey burying Juggy in concrete - he's still sentient, conscious, alive and digging his way out, but he's not harming Spidey.

If I fight a young boy, and hold him down - doesn't matter if he's still fighting back, or healing, I'm still controlling his limbs.

But yeah,all the responses for Hulk seem to boil down to 'he finds a way'.

No it isn't if there's a power struggle. Incapacitated means there would be no struggle. We know that there would be, and we also know that Magneto doesn't have to power to hold the Hulk. If he does, that would mean that Magneto would outshine the Inbetweener at half power, and that doesnt really make much sense.

Good post. I can agree with that

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
If I fight a young boy, and hold him down
Originally posted by leonidas
So if mags hoists hulk in the air and controls his blood but hulk is constantly healing or fighting it would or wouldn’t count as an incapacitation win...? Because I’m having a hard time seeing how mags wins this without benefit of bfr though I’m more than willing to have someone convince me otherwise.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
What about incap'ing someone via other method?

Restraining, immobilizing, etc.?

Parker can spam webs so much, for example, that even characters who can tear it like paper will spend some time getting out of it, simply because it's so sticky and gets everywhere... 😖hifty:

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I see it as an incapacitation win. Just like Spidey burying Juggy in concrete - he's still sentient, conscious, alive and digging his way out, but he's not harming Spidey.

If I fight a young boy, and hold him down - doesn't matter if he's still fighting back, or healing, I'm still controlling his limbs.

But yeah,all the responses for Hulk seem to boil down to 'he finds a way'.

For me the problem is how long does it need to be to count as a win? If they're immobilized you're winning. But winning isn't the same as having won. Should it be the same amount of time as how long it takes someone to get back for it to count as BFR?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

I am glad you spotted that. You would never fail me.

Originally posted by Stoic
No it isn't if there's a power struggle. Incapacitated means there would be no struggle. We know that there would be, and we also know that Magneto doesn't have to power to hold the Hulk. If he does, that would mean that Magneto would outshine the Inbetweener at half power, and that doesnt really make much sense.

Magneto can just lift Hulk and hold him there casually.
Hulk cant struggle against that.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Good post. I can agree with that

I point out Iron Fist outshines Spider-Man against a common enemy, Black Tarantula, and this proves Danny should be able to defeat Shang Chi rather easily, and get countered that BT was "jobbing".

Yet Hulk outshines In Betweener, and people just accept it as a "feat". No possibility In Betweener, even at half power, was jobbing for Hulk.

No double standards there.

Has Graviton faced Hulk? He should be able to casually restrain him

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Has Graviton faced Hulk? He should be able to casually restrain him

Are you sure about that?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Has Graviton faced Hulk? He should be able to casually restrain him

Yes and Hulk one shot koed him.

Originally posted by carver9
Yes and Hulk one shot koed him.

Are you sure about that?

Originally posted by cdtm
Are you sure about that?

Yes

What?

When Hulk fought Graviton?

Carver Comics Volume 1 Issue 1?

how does he overcome bfr? Maybe I missed where someone explained it

no bfr.

Originally posted by Delta1938
For me the problem is how long does it need to be to count as a win? If they're immobilized you're winning. But winning isn't the same as having won. Should it be the same amount of time as how long it takes someone to get back for it to count as BFR?

no idea. but i think the case with the hulk here is different from ds's juggernaut example. jugg's powers don't continually escalate like hulk's do. i don't think it would be too long before hulk's strength simply exceeded mag's power. or maybe his blood adapts. i also don't know how it can be called an incapacitation when we don't even know how long someone needs to be incapacitated FOR to earn a win...? i don't see mags holding him for long--a minute? less? he can go full wb and just overwhelm mags with energy. i don't think anyone would say mags could contain wbh or deal easily with the energy hulk puts off. i think it's much more likely hulk would go full wb than there is of his losing via incapacitation. and unlike a bz where hulk was limited, there's no reason to prevent his going wb.

even staying short of that though, there is reason to think hulk might be able to overcome that type of control if he has time.

to me, an incapacitation means the enemy is prone, done, in a position where he/she/it can be killed. ww incapacitates with the lasso. the webbing would incapacitate SOME, but only delay others. i can't believe in all the time the forum's been around the rule has never been fleshed out clearly. not blaming anyone, it's just weird is all. shrug

I just don't get why people tend to lowball Hulk. Magneto stands no chance. Even Reed compared Hulk to the Phoenix Force and called him an Omega level threat...

https://comicvine1.cbsistatic.com/uploads/original/10/104431/3849925-asm692_0016.jpg

Ironman compared him to a Celestial destroying Robot (that actually fought against the entire Celestial race).

Good thing Mags easily handled Phoenix twice, then 😎

Do people really lowball him though Carver? Even in a comics forum we have to be somewhat realistic.

When two people both have planetary level strength and durability (just an example) but one of them flies, can move and react at 187,000 mph and oh yeah, shoots lasers right out of they're ****ing face or control electromagnetism, storms wtf ever. Its kind of a no brainer who wins.

Now obviously, if he clearly outclassed them so much they can't hurt him is a different story.

Originally posted by cdtm
Are you sure about that?

I'm thinking power set. By negating the gravity in a localized area he could make hulk helpless