Who Survives Thanos pimp slap???

Originally posted by Stoic
So tell us how much force that my took to dismantle the shield. If you don't know, stop pretending to know.

Since you jumped in so eagerly earlier, maybe you can tell me why the two events (being punched in space Vs being punched from earth into space) are comparable. Drag is only one component, but the WW instance clearly showed the Sun, and Maxwell Lord clearly stated a time. Even if we lowballed it massively, the distance from earth to space is incredibly tiny compared to that.

But of course, you knew that, right, before you jumped in?

Originally posted by h1a8
My post went over your head.

To prevent no limit fallacies, If a character's best showing is lifting a 2 ton car. Then that is the maximum amount they can lift in a forum, even if in the mind of the writer they can lift more than 20 tons. That's called debating with feats.

Plus this thread isn't about the speculative maximum potential of what Thanos can do. It is about what Thanos actually did.

Thanos could have struck the shield LESS than his maximum potential. Thanos can't strike with infinite force.
So we must go off what he did physically in other scenes in order to gauge his punching power.

A no limit fallacy is exactly what you have been peddling. Wonder Woman prior to surviving that punch struggled along with Superman, and J'onn to move the Earth. Did they exert infinite force to move the Earth? Of course not. You have yet to prove even one point here. Divert your attentions to Galans post. He's on the level.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Since you jumped in so eagerly earlier, maybe you can tell me why the two events (being punched in space Vs being punched from earth into space) are comparable. Drag is only one component, but the WW instance clearly showed the Sun, and Maxwell Lord clearly stated a time. Even if we lowballed it massively, the distance from earth to space is incredibly tiny compared to that.

But of course, you knew that, right, before you jumped in?

Better go back and read my statement. Understand it and we won't have to turn this into another one of your circular arguments

And you need to understand my question, lol.

I asked when did it happen. You misunderstood and jumped in.

Originally posted by Stoic
I never said anything about distance, as the punch from space to Earth isn't exactly clear. It didn't appear to be the same disrance though. Getting back to the point, I think the question was about drag, or the lack thereof. You didn't answer it. Do you have to? Nope.

Drag means nothing in this scenario, as WW was punched a greater distance, at a higher speed. So it was a useless comparison to make.

Originally posted by JBL
Where was it stated that WW was traveling at light speed and beyond? Where was it stated about WWs mass?

Where was a time stamp placed on that scene? Why wasn't she driven deeper into the planet?

Originally posted by h1a8
It wasn't stated. Just simple math
Speed = distance / time

Originally posted by JBL
So it was never stated huh? Writers don't go by your real life physics. Stop trying to add on to that feat.

In their latest run-in, Mongul nearly sodomizes Diana again. Luckily for her they were in space. Going solely by comparison, imagine a flea like Mongul being able to physically beat the life out of her, but Thanos with the IG would somehow have trouble turning her skull into mush with one blow.

Originally posted by Stoic
In their latest run-in, Mongul nearly sodomizes Diana again. Luckily for her they were in space. Going solely by comparison, imagine a flea like Mongul being able to physically beat the life out of her, but Thanos with the IG would somehow have trouble turning her skull into mush with one blow.

Non canon, of course. But you knew that 😉

I will rescue you, H1.

What if Thanos merely overloaded the vibranium in the shield? It has been done before - Immortal Hulk did it recently, but Roxxon has also destroyed an entire island of it with some bombs:

So Thanos could've replicated that Roxxon feat, albeit on a much smaller scale - overloaded the vibranium and destroyed the shield that way.

Iron Man #121 for those interested.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
What if Thanos merely overloaded the vibranium in the shield?

Then the shield would be breaking like a toothpick.

It's the special mix that makes it special, not the vibranium shit.

The next page:

And the description from the handbooks:

In short: vibranium has limits (albeit uknown), but far less than Skyfather level attacks have destroyed an entire island of it, whereas Cap has a much much smaller amount present in his shield.

Also, just for h1:

Element 😛

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Then the shield would be breaking like a toothpick.

It's the special mix that makes it special, not the vibranium shit.

I mean, Thanos DID break it like a toothpick 😛

IG can do that to any object in the multiverse.

Thousands of carvers can overload vibranium, it's a non-feat.

Agreed - but the point being, if all that's being applied by Thanos there is 2000 Carverpower...then these guys all survive it.

Tbf, alloys are almost always better than the elements.

Carbon and iron are relatively shit, put them together and you have steel, which is way better. So mixing Adamantium with vibranium would cancel vibraniums weakness out - again, we saw this with Immortal Hulk when he overloaded Panther but not the shield (when Cap saved Thor lol).

Nevermind, i just defeated my own point. Never say I didn't try to help, though, H1!

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Tbf, alloys are almost always better than the elements.

Almost.

Adamantium/vibranium alloys have a long history of being destroyed easier than the mobile phones left at carver's "repair" shop 😛

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Agreed - but the point being, if all that's being applied by Thanos there is 2000 Carverpower...then these guys all survive it.

Reality gem makes it impossible to calculate the carverpower he used.

Smh. They all die, enough with the excuses.

Originally posted by JBL
Smh. They all die, enough with the excuses.

Yeah, seriously.

Everyone in the op is a pussy. With the possible exception of hp dd.