Originally posted by Syren
I agree that in order to make judgement it helps terrifically to actually have relevant experiences, but I'm not sure about the way you worded this comment. Surely if those inmates you mentioned had morals and standards they wouldn't be able to bring themselves to commit the act that they frowned upon in the first place? I understand it's seen as punishment, an eye for an eye etc. And certainly in that sort of establishment it does go overlooked, but I doubt you can allow the 'punishers' to be credited with ethics. It's just not the correct term, IMO 😬
It's the correct term, just twisted and perverted(like the mind of a criminal). There is no other way to describe it. Have you ever actually spoken with a criminal? It's odd the way they see things. They can have the most stable sense of honor you ever encountered, but still do something seen by others as dishonorable. They may see something like killing someone inferior to them as honorable(it's sort of an animalistic thing, Alpha males and all that), while obviously, a normal citizen wouldn't.
Now, while most people wouldn't say a criminal had morals or standards, dealing out punishment for a crime is showing that you have exactly that. Regardless of their title. A prisoner, who has done something wrong in the eyes of the law, can still see his own view of what is right, and what is wrong. What I said was that rape is so severe that most prison inmate view it as wrong.
A murderer sees a rapist and thinks "that disgusting pig. how would he like getting raped? i think he should experience it"(of course, i'm paraphrasing. If i were to be literal, the censors would bleep out most of the words). Then the murderer goes and rapes the rapist. Eye for an eye, as you stated. The murderer, who doesn't find killing wrong, finds rape wrong, yet his justice system is twisted. In order to deal out the punishment, yes, he'd have to resort to doing the actual deed he finds wrong. Kind of like how the government puts murderers to death on death row. Does the government not have morals and standards?
Forgive me f I wasn't clear, it's one of those things that are hard to explain.