Silver Surfer Vs Superman 2022 edition.

Started by Smurph23 pages

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hence, tenuous, as it isn't shown. I don't think it's a stretch to say Surfer, a guy who has been all over the universe, would know what Strontians are weak to.

Is MY interpretation tenuous? Sure. I don't know either - Surfer doesn't say he's using cosmic awareness, just as he doesn't say that he heard about it surfing the cosmos.

Logan however seems to have picked something up, which means either he dissected and studied Strontians first hand, or he heard about it somewhere. And if we allow that in the Marvel U there exists knowledge on Strontian weaknesses such as pressure points, it follows that radiation wavelengths would also be, whilst not COMMON knowledge, knowledge.

Especially if someone like Hulk can discern it mid-battle.

Yeah, agreed, until we're explicitly told otherwise, all things are possible. Are all things equally likely? Of course not.

Given Surfer's ability to instantly know the species around him, their abilities, their chemical makeup, etc, I would suggest that our interpretations are not equally tenuous.

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Aster is the intelligentest man I've ever known.
Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Aster is the intelligentest man I've ever known.
and jealousy? 🙂

Originally posted by Smurph
Yeah, agreed, until we're explicitly told otherwise, all things are possible. Are all things equally likely? Of course not.

Given Surfer's ability to instantly know the species around him, their abilities, their chemical makeup, etc, I would suggest that our interpretations are not equally tenuous.

Strontians don't have an inherent radiation weakness though. It's Gladiator specifically and those who go through Gladiator treatment in the service of Shiar.

Surfer knowing the species DNA makeup doesn't gives him the ability know their weaknesses anymore than anyone else who can scan DNA. You're simply extrapolating the fact that Surfer knows Gladiator's weakness to his cosmic awareness based on nothing.

Originally posted by Smurph
Yeah, agreed, until we're explicitly told otherwise, all things are possible. Are all things equally likely? Of course not.

Given Surfer's ability to instantly know the species around him, their abilities, their chemical makeup, etc, I would suggest that our interpretations are not equally tenuous.

He hasnt shown the ability to know their abilities via awareness either that I can think of.
Only a couple showings, but that was based on knowing their race and the races abilities. Again, likely through time in the cosmos.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Strontians don't have an inherent radiation weakness though. It's Gladiator specifically and those who go through Gladiator treatment in the service of Shiar.

Surfer knowing the species DNA makeup doesn't gives him the ability know their weaknesses anymore than anyone else who can scan DNA. You're simply extrapolating the fact that Surfer knows Gladiator's weakness to his cosmic awareness based on nothing.

But it's not just DNA. He knows the physical and chemical totality of all the beings around him. More than that, he perceives and understands the universe as a quantum field.

I'm not hinging anything on the Gladiator showing. I just think that not acknowledging the obvious is dumb.

Originally posted by Smurph
But it's not just DNA. He knows the physical and chemical totality of all the beings around him.

Does he now? He knows what race they are but other than that it's just your guess.

More than that, he perceives and understands the universe as a quantum field.

When did he do that?

I'm not hinging anything on the Gladiator showing. I just think that not acknowledging the obvious is dumb.

What's more obvious, he knew Gladiator's weakness just like every other race who knows it or that he's ignorant of a major species in the universe and decided to scan Gladiator and instantly knew his weakness despite never showing this ability before or after?

TBH, I think this argument about whether Sufer can sense others' weaknesses wouldn't change much about this fight

In character fighting( this isn't Surfer's go-to move as far as I know), Superman keeps attacking Surfer, Superman possibly can avoid these weakness exploitations, Superman also has great senses(from what I knew, these senses seem pretty on par/very close to with cosmic awareness) and exotic abilities himself can use to attack Surfer etcetcetc

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
TBH, I think this argument about whether Sufer can sense others' weaknesses wouldn't change much about this fight

In character fighting( this isn't Surfer's go-to move as far as I know), Superman keeps attacking Surfer, Superman possibly can avoid these weakness exploitations, Superman also has great senses(from what I knew, these senses seem pretty on par/very close to with cosmic awareness) and exotic abilities himself can use to attack Surfer etcetcetc


Surfer fans and marvel fanboys like dumbo know its the only way Surfer can beat Superman. That's why it's always the same tactic for more than a decade based on a vague panel in a single comic always the first argument.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Does he now? He knows what race they are but other than that it's just your guess.

No, I was quoting the comic. https://imgur.com/Z9wLgWb

Originally posted by abhilegend
When did he do that?
In Slott's run, when he showed the blind woman what it was like to observe the universe in quantum terms.

Originally posted by abhilegend
What's more obvious, he knew Gladiator's weakness just like every other race who knows it or that he's ignorant of a major species in the universe and decided to scan Gladiator and instantly knew his weakness despite never showing this ability before or after?
Well, you have my answer on that point. I'd phrase it differently but it's splitting hairs.

Originally posted by Smurph
Yeah, agreed, until we're explicitly told otherwise, all things are possible. Are all things equally likely? Of course not.

Given Surfer's ability to instantly know the species around him, their abilities, their chemical makeup, etc, I would suggest that our interpretations are not equally tenuous.


But I never said equally tenuous.

I said the Glads showing was a tenuous showing for his cosmic awareness. Just as you have supplementary evidence that Surfer has these senses, I have supplementary evidence that Strontians and their weaknesses are known throughout the galaxy/universe. We are not shown Logan dissecting Strontians, so someone would have told him (he just says he's studied how to kill them).

But is that really it for the Cosmic Awareness evidence? That and HE using it?

Originally posted by qwertyuiop1998
TBH, I think this argument about whether Sufer can sense others' weaknesses wouldn't change much about this fight

In character fighting( this isn't Surfer's go-to move as far as I know), Superman keeps attacking Surfer, Superman possibly can avoid these weakness exploitations, Superman also has great senses(from what I knew, these senses seem pretty on par/very close to with cosmic awareness) and exotic abilities himself can use to attack Surfer etcetcetc

I mostly agree. In fact, I think the only thing the Gladiator showing tells us is that Surfer will sometimes think in those tactics, but I agree, not his usual route.

I think it's interesting how that changes depending on how narrowly you apply the full capacity rule but that's not an argument I feel like wading through.

It just shows that he will threaten, but says nothing on how he actually does it in a fight, though.

Originally posted by Smurph
No, I was quoting the comic. https://imgur.com/Z9wLgWb

He says he can comprehend their love in physical and chemical totality. Flowery way to tell that he's able to smell the pheromones.

That was disappointing lol, I thought you had something.

In Slott's run, when he showed the blind woman what it was like to observe the universe in quantum terms.
Issue number?

Well, you have my answer on that point. I'd phrase it differently but it's splitting hairs.

Yeah, I thought so. It's cosmic awareness because it's Silver Surfer, that's what it boils down to.

He's always been given the privilege to do pretty much anything without ever doing it on this forum, something no character has ever been afforded, not even Galactus lol.

Originally posted by Smurph
I mostly agree. In fact, I think the only thing the Gladiator showing tells us is that Surfer will sometimes think in those tactics, but I agree, not his usual route.

I think it's interesting how that changes depending on how narrowly you apply the full capacity rule but that's not an argument I feel like wading through.


Surfer actually fought Krosakis with Gladiator's power. No acknowledgement of the radiation weakness or Surfer ever trying to do it.

I remember Norrin being in awe and shock once he found out about Hawaiian surfers vin

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
I remember Norrin being in awe and shock once he found out about Hawaiian surfers vin

what about somali surfers

Originally posted by Ambient
You do know the cause of that time still disturbance right Phil? It’s the time gem man! It froze the Marvel Universe whole, a complete control of time universally as opposed to Surfer’s limited speed induced time stop. Surfers speed just can’t compare to an all out Universal time stop.

You left out a tiny but important detail in that Surfers fight with the Runner Phil.

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/82885051/F86C53B3-5103-414A-BBB8-2F0E4467E4E4.jpeg.html

https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/82885054/588EBD15-A8B7-4CDB-B269-65D866154049.jpeg.html

Surfer is not at full capacity during that fight as he was unknowingly psionically manipulated to like Runner therefore it just can’t be compared.

There is just no way around red herring the time stop feat of Surfer man, it’s completely legit. The movement of the board shows Surfer moving within that time stop, Doom seeing them is after the fact base on the on panel reaction and his surprise statement, “what’s this? The sky riding sentinel has returned already? If he saw them at time of narration, he wouldn’t be surprised to great them outside his castles yard.
__________________

You're confusing the source of the effect with the effect itself. If Batman produces a 1kg rock, or Firestorm produces a 1kg rock -- the rock is still 1kg, and if one can lift the rock, it means he can lift 1kg. If Firestorm removes all of the oxygen on Earth, and you don't require oxygen, you survive. If Lucifer removes all of the oxygen on Earth, you can also survive, because the effect is the same. The 1kg doesn't get 1kg-er. Zero oxygen doesn't get Zero-er. Time doesn't get stopper-er, it stops -- and you can either move in it, or you cannot. Silver Surfer cannot do so, as show on panel.

You've cropped the Doom scan because you want to remove the context, to troll abhi with hyperbolic silver age randomness that nobody takes seriously. There's a few things that we can discern in the full scan:

Doom talks. He stops mid-sentence in the panel he's talking because Surfer comes at 'time stop' the next panel. Thus -- the very obvious silver age hyperbole that can be substituted with "the board comes very fast".

The aforementioned board -- it's it that travels and transports fast to the destination. It is not only not a time stop speed feat, it's not a feat that is pertinent to the Surfer's own speed sans the board.

Furthermore, as Darksaint repeatedly points out, this is not impressive even for travel speed, although if you want to prove that Surfer's board can go near-lightspeed, I guess that's awesome. Or perhaps you want to show that Surfer's board can access hyperspace by exceeding the speed of light, which shortens distances, and which he has beforehand also used to transport the fantastic four, thus the huge energy behind them as they arrive? Also awesome. But we already knew that the board can travel near-lightspeed in normal space and FTL in hyperspace.

But, when Surfer has to physically perform actions, using the board to cover distances, we can see that even in the most dire of circumstances at his utmost limit, he cannot save Shalla and Mantis both from an explosion inside 1 second:

Pertaining to the Runner, again with the cropped scans -- but it's ok, I posted the full ones before. Runner makes people "like" him [that's what the 'psionic manipulation is] but, as shown in the full scan of the cropped panels you posted, Surfer says that he has no affect on the power cosmic - https://ibb.co/Js7HSKJ

Nevertheless Runner directly overpowers him, significantly outspeeds him in every area of the fight, steals his board and essentially humiliates him with his speed and potency, as Surfer is helpless to defend himself.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He says he can comprehend their love in physical and chemical totality. Flowery way to tell that he's able to smell the pheromones.

That was disappointing lol, I thought you had something.

Issue number?

Yeah, I thought so. It's cosmic awareness because it's Silver Surfer, that's what it boils down to.

He's always been given the privilege to do pretty much anything without ever doing it on this forum, something no character has ever been afforded, not even Galactus lol.

Phoenix 😖hifty:

Originally posted by MrMind
what about somali surfers

😆

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It just shows that he will threaten, but says nothing on how he actually does it in a fight, though.
Agreed

Originally posted by abhilegend
He says he can comprehend their love in physical and chemical totality. Flowery way to tell that he's able to smell the pheromones.
Yeah, a flowery way to show that he sees things in "physical and chemical totality". Agreed.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Issue number?
Yah will pull it up later

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yeah, I thought so. It's cosmic awareness because it's Silver Surfer, that's what it boils down to.
Uh, yes?

Originally posted by abhilegend
He's always been given the privilege to do pretty much anything without ever doing it on this forum, something no character has ever been afforded, not even Galactus lol.
lol, no comment