Superman/Martian Manhunter vs Silver Surfer/Thor (average versions)

Started by -Pr-8 pages
Originally posted by carver9
Because low showings are not acceptable on the forum, and it's not acceptable here.

If only you followed your own rules.

Originally posted by -Pr-
If only you followed your own rules.

Lol... what I think as low showings is completely different than what you think. Superman and Damage stalemating is a low showing in your eyes while I see nothing wrong with it.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol... what I think as low showings is completely different than what you think. Superman and Damage stalemating is a low showing in your eyes while I see nothing wrong with it.

This is exactly my point. It's not a low showing if it happens regularly, correct?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
This is exactly my point. It's not a low showing if it happens regularly, correct?

A low showing is a low showing. Fighting beings like Damage and stalemating against him isn't a low showing.

Hulk is Hulk is Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
A low showing is a low showing. Fighting beings like Damage and stalemating against him isn't a low showing.

Why not?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Why not?

Because Damage was consistently shown as a Superman tier character. Why is it a low showing?

Originally posted by carver9
Because Damage was consistently shown as a Superman tier character. Why is it a low showing?

So you think his highs are equal to Superman's highs? Or his averages are equal to Superman's averages?

I'm not answering a question with a question, it's more what makes him Superman tier- because it's leading to the conclusion I'm trying to help you understand with your logic.

If his averages are equal to Superman's averages, but his highs are not equal, and he has lows that are worse.....how are you defining an Average showing for Damage? He had like 5 showings lol.

You talk about consistency. How many showings does Damage need to establish an average, if Surfer only needs 5?

Dont you get it? Only he determines whats high, average, and low.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So you think his highs are equal to Superman's highs? Or his averages are equal to Superman's averages?

I'm not answering a question with a question, it's more what makes him Superman tier- because it's leading to the conclusion I'm trying to help you understand with your logic.

If his averages are equal to Superman's averages, but his highs are not equal, and he has lows that are worse.....how are you defining an Average showing for Damage? He had like 5 showings lol.

You talk about consistency. How many showings does Damage need to establish an average, if Surfer only needs 5?

His averages is stomping the JLA, merking Wonder Woman, even having Wonder Woman saying Damage is stronger than Superman. His showings are pretty high. I'll ask again, why is Damage a low?

Originally posted by carver9
merking Wonder Woman

So he is some transgender amazon that determines to make Wonder Woman replace Aquaman?
A mermaid king; the king of the merfolk.

https://www.yourdictionary.com/merking

>😮

Carver:

Originally posted by carver9
Most people on here know what a low showing is.

Carver, 3 posts later:

Originally posted by carver9
Lol... what I think as low showings is completely different than what you think. Superman and Damage stalemating is a low showing in your eyes while I see nothing wrong with it.

It's not a low showing. 😡

Set Superman and Damage aside for a second and just think about the difference between

"Most people on here know what a low showing is"

vs

"what I think as low showings is completely different than what you think"

Originally posted by Smurph
Set Superman and Damage aside for a second and just think about the difference between

"Most people on here know what a low showing is"

vs

"what I think as low showings is completely different than what you think"

👍🏾... I see what you're saying. There's different levels to this, though, but I get your point.

According to carver, Poison ivy>Justice League.

Originally posted by carver9
Even you don't believe Damage comes close to Hulk but let's play that game if you want. The same Damage that couldn't break free from Poison Ivy plants and got knocked TF out? Is that the Damage above this version of Hulk that withstood 100s of thousands stars exploding? You have to be a troll...

https://ibb.co/SwvRDgf
https://ibb.co/HK5M4hd
https://ibb.co/d2Rck1m

Why are you bringing Gladiator into this? Hulk and Gladiator has fought twice. Use those as a reference of fts, please. Then you're the guy who's trying to debate against statements while at the same time posting green Lantern fts from statements. 🤦🏿


Originally posted by carver9
Let me pull a Darksaint. The same Damage that got beat by Poison Ivy?

Originally posted by carver9

You can keep nitpicking all you want but at this point, Superman needs a team to take on Hulk... especially if he is getting stalemated by someone like Damage who got taken out by Poison Ivy and a King Kong wannabe.

Well, Ivy certainly is superior to Superman.

what was it batman hush? christ can you believe that was almost 20 years ago? time flies

Originally posted by carver9
His averages is stomping the JLA, merking Wonder Woman, even having Wonder Woman saying Damage is stronger than Superman. His showings are pretty high. I'll ask again, why is Damage a low?

So two feats and a statement is enough to be consistent for him?

Originally posted by abhilegend
According to carver, Poison ivy>Justice League.

Ding ding ding, we have a winner.

If two feats are all that's needed to establish an average, Damage gets KOd by Ivy and Congorilla. I don't even need to bring his showing against Batman up.

Which means his average is either getting stomped by a King Kong wannabe, or stomping Wonder Woman. And round and round we go......

Originally posted by MrMind
what was it batman hush? christ can you believe that was almost 20 years ago? time flies

Yes, Hush.

And yes, we are old as fuck.

...

Let's face it. Only one thing left for us to do: