Originally posted by carver9Of course she was. She was commanding him to stop. He just refused. He still told the truth when she asked him a question, but he wasn't a puppet under her control.
Because she wasn't trying to compel. Answer this because I'm trying to see how you think this works? Do you think once she wraps you, it automatically make you see visions, compel you and make you tell the truth?
I think you're going through a fan crisis, realizing that the lasso doesn't work the way you thought it does.
Originally posted by Smurph
Of course she was. She was commanding him to stop. He just refused. He still told the truth when she asked him a question, but he wasn't a puppet under her control.I think you're going through a fan crisis, realizing that the lasso doesn't work the way you thought it does.
So you think anytime she screams something, it means that she wants the lasso to do it? Did you read the comic? Be honest.
This is a command by the way. Do you see her saying "I command you..."
Originally posted by Smurph
She screamed a command Carver. She was desperately trying to stop Superman.You sometimes have stupid moments Carver, but you're not this stupid.
But she didn't force Max Lord to remove Superman from his mental compromise for a reason. She literally states that anything temporary will result in all of this happening over and over again. It's right there in the comic. This ability isn't always active by the way. Lol... this discussion is this stupid because if the lasso works, it works. There's no rule book that says "only telling the truth works while commands doesn't". This is what make your argument dumb AF. We literally have evidence of the lasso working on him. It's not part of a trick. It either works or it doesn't. Maybe you have a bio or something that shows otherwise. Post it here, please.
Originally posted by Smurph
She screamed a command Carver. She was desperately trying to stop Superman.You sometimes have stupid moments Carver, but you're not this stupid.
I'm going to say this as slow as possible for you. Just because you're in a lasso doesn't mean that the ability works right then or on everything she blirts out. This...is...not...how...the...lasso...work. Diana had to kill Max Lord because she knew this situation would be a rinse and repeat. Keeping the lasso on Max forever so that Superman wouldn't fall prey to Max telepathy is also a STUPID way of debating this. She took a route that she knew would permanently remove Max Lord spell.
Originally posted by Smurph
Zod can fly, Carver. He can literally turn in any direction. And sure, he can shoot HV wherever he wants.He can also maintain it while turning, with massive range.
Your argument about him not getting a chance is utter nonsense. There's no point in replying to someone who dodges and denies.
I'm here for a BZ on the topic. Three posts each, short and simple. Three judges, you can veto anybody you think is biased. Let's see if you can convince anybody else of your lasso argument.
The only reason I asked if you wanted to use these scans is because this Zod got wrapped TF up by Diana before he even realized what was going on and he couldn't move and like the others, he was submissive. And yes, he just finished beating up on some JLA members. I'm sure you're going to take it back now because this goes against your entire idea.
Let me know.
Originally posted by carver9I didn't post scans from that comic.
The only reason I asked if you wanted to use these scans is because this Zod got wrapped TF up by Diana before he even realized what was going on and he couldn't move and like the others, he was submissive. And yes, he just finished beating up on some JLA members. I'm sure you're going to take it back now because this goes against your entire idea.Let me know.
Wtf are you talking about?
I think Carver just simply mixed up the scans.
Both the sites Smurph posted are from Post-Rebirth era
This is from Suicide Squad #18
https://imgur.com/a/5ykBjhc
This is from Suicide Squad #5
https://imgur.com/Jrjf48s
What Carver thought is non-canon, is the version he just posted(New 52 version)
Originally posted by carver9
The only reason I asked if you wanted to use these scans is because this Zod got wrapped TF up by Diana before he even realized what was going on and he couldn't move and like the others, he was submissive. And yes, he just finished beating up on some JLA members. I'm sure you're going to take it back now because this goes against your entire idea.Let me know.
As DS pointed out before, the New 52 version was retconned away
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
That was retconned away, no?