Yoda, Mace Windu, & Obi-Wan vs Darth Sidious, Count Dooku, & Darth Maul

Started by Hewhoknowsall8 pages

The Naboo generator room is where Maul fought, right?

Yoda would beat Sidious 5.5/10, Yoda was winning and Sidious just got the upper ground and threw senate pods, in a duel which this will likely come to Yoda wins. And he has shown to be able to reflect Sidious's Force Lightning

Mace Windu would beat Dooku, again this area is saber centered, and Dooku's lightning (or at least in the movies) is sort of pathetic, and has Dooku shown all that good TK?

Obi Wan beats Maul, or at least holds him off with his Soresu.

Dooku was a master at TK.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
The Naboo generator room is where Maul fought, right?

Yoda would beat Sidious 5.5/10, Yoda was winning and Sidious just got the upper ground and threw senate pods, in a duel which this will likely come to Yoda wins. And he has shown to be able to reflect Sidious's Force Lightning

For how long?

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Mace Windu would beat Dooku, again this area is saber centered, and Dooku's lightning (or at least in the movies) is sort of pathetic, and has Dooku shown all that good TK?
Ja.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Obi Wan beats Maul, or at least holds him off with his Soresu.
Beating Maul and holding him off are two completely different things.

I say Obi-Wan could beat maul and possibly Dooku because in ROTS, Sidious says to Grievous: "Soon I will have a more powerful apprentice," yet Obi Wan bet Anakin, his "more powerful apprentice" on Mustafar. But then again in AOTC Dooku beats Obi-Wan and Anakin.

Originally posted by truejedi
[QUOTE=12223564]Originally posted by mattatom
[B]*Subjekt. And that's Darth Subjekt to you.
[/QU 😘 [/B]
WTF did I do to you? I didn't post that shit. Why give me the sick look?

Originally posted by Raptor 7789
I say Obi-Wan could beat maul and possibly Dooku because in ROTS, Sidious says to Grievous: "Soon I will have a more powerful apprentice," yet Obi Wan bet Anakin, his "more powerful apprentice" on Mustafar. But then again in AOTC Dooku beats Obi-Wan and Anakin.

What the hell are you talking about? You couldn't even get the quote correct, and we're supposed to take you seriously? Go home.
He says, "Soon I will have a new apprentice. One far younger and more powerful." Anakin was more powerful than OB1 and only lost cause he wasn't thinking clearly after just joining the darkside, being blinded by this new power and rage and regretting everything that he's done (hence the crying scene). That was a circumstantial victory anyways.

Maul was forged to be the perfect tool for the darkside. He was one of the deadliest Sith apprentices in history. And OB1 got curb stomped (that's right, I said it!) by Dooku not once, but twice. A>B>C arguments don't work around here.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
WTF did I do to you? I didn't post that shit. Why give me the sick look?

nope the sick look was to the other guy. for being bossy! but i was just kidding anyway. Subjekt, you only get nice smilies from me!!

kisses

You can at least address me by my name, since you know it. I wasn't being [i]bossy[/b] just helpful.

i hit quote without looking who you were mattatom. I almost put your name, but I couldn't remember for sure that it was YOU who had said it.

And i was just kidding anyway.

Lol, one sick smiley face, and all hell breaks loose!

Originally posted by truejedi
i hit quote without looking who you were mattatom. I almost put your name, but I couldn't remember for sure that it was YOU who had said it.

And i was just kidding anyway.

Lol, one sick smiley face, and all hell breaks loose!

You should check before you quote! Edit button?

I gathered that much.

Proof that Obi Wan > Maul?

Proof that Anakin > Obi Wan?

@Lucien

"for how long?" Yoda caught the lightning with his bare hands and overpowered Sidious. You can tell because at the end of their Force-tug-of-war Sidious starts going like "ah!!" and his face turns to that of fear. Both of them got knocked back.

So it's proven that Yoda is indeed capable of reflecting Sidious's lightning back at him. And in this enclosed space, it will go down to a saber fight, not a Force fight.

Although it isn't certain who's better at sabers, Yoda or Sidious.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
"for how long?" Yoda caught the lightning with his bare hands and overpowered Sidious. You can tell because at the end of their Force-tug-of-war Sidious starts going like "ah!!" and his face turns to that of fear. Both of them got knocked back.

So it's proven that Yoda is indeed capable of reflecting Sidious's lightning back at him. And in this enclosed space, it will go down to a saber fight, not a Force fight.

Although it isn't certain who's better at sabers, Yoda or Sidious.

By "how long" I meant "how often could that happen." The RotS duel shows Yoda breaking that stalemate and sending both him and Palpatine flying. But unfortunately for Yoda, his age and Ataru drained him and it wasn't enough to keep him going, unlike Palpatine. Even if a rematch changed in Yoda's environmental favour, if Palpatine holds on long enough or Lightning's things up a bit, a rotunda-repeat could very well happen.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
By "how long" I meant "how often could that happen." The RotS duel shows Yoda breaking that stalemate and sending both him and Palpatine flying. But unfortunately for Yoda, his age and Ataru drained him and it wasn't enough to keep him going, unlike Palpatine. Even if a rematch changed in Yoda's environmental favour, if Palpatine holds on long enough or Lightning's things up a bit, a rotunda-repeat could very well happen.

How LONG =/= How often

Wasn't enough to keep him going? Huh? Yoda just was unlucky and fell off. Since Sidious had the high ground, Yoda decided that the battle was lost and fled.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
How LONG =/= How often
Oh Christ, don't start arguing grammatical semantics with me, boy.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Wasn't enough to keep him going? Huh? Yoda just was unlucky and fell off. Since Sidious had the high ground, Yoda decided that the battle was lost and fled.
Read.

And scroll down to "By allowing the Force to flow throughout their body, they could overcome their physical limitations (including old age, as was the case with Master Yoda) and perform amazing feats of acrobatics, such as somersaults and backflips, not only for attack, but also to evade the attacks and strikes of their opponents."

And then:

"This form was also considered not as effective for prolonged combat, as the nature of Ataru could greatly tax the body. Fatigue was theorized to have been a contributing factor in Qui-Gon Jinn's defeat at the hands of Darth Maul."

The Rots novelization even stated that Sidious grew stronger as Yoda grew weaker. No doubt due to Ataru's taxing effects on the body.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Proof that Obi Wan > Maul?

😆

Every1 is krankee 2dei!

To hwkellsawouhbvab... whatever your name is... as far as Anakin > OB1.. GL said it when describing that fight. The quote is something like, "At this time in Sith, Anakin is the most powerful Jedi. OB1 just has more experience." It's somewhere in the special features. I'd love to go look it up for you, but I'm sure you have the movie and if you want the proof, you know where to start looking.

I'm still waiting for a response to my post from He. I know he was online and posting after 10pm, so what the hell?

He could be away eating dinner or doing hw or something... or if hes not a student or studying in some way, maybe hes busy with family stuff? or idk maybe other things. but u can't expect ppl to post constantly... lol

so whats up guys?

I'm guessing ur bedtime is at like 4 hrs ago?

Originally posted by kotorfan
He could be away eating dinner or doing hw or something... or if hes not a student or studying in some way, maybe hes busy with family stuff? or idk maybe other things. but u can't expect ppl to post constantly... lol
I doubt it. He can post miscellaneous crap on other threads six hours after I last responded to him, but he doesn't respond back? He likes to ignore posts that defeat his points. Ugh.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
I doubt it. He can post miscellaneous crap on other threads six hours after I last responded to him, but he doesn't respond back? He likes to ignore posts that defeat his points. Ugh.
Like DS?