Silver Surfer vs Thor

Started by Rols92 pages

In the comics they were not holding back. Maybe you like to think they were but none of the gems had a meaningful effect on Thor. Ever wonder why Warlock didnt bother using his gem again?

This is the key to your misconception. If you start off with this incorrect assumption then whatever the comics say will make no sense and the only option is to "interpret" when in fact there is nothing to interpret and it's clear as night and day that try as they might they could not even restrain him let alone ko him or kill him. It was like a grown up beatin up on kids.

Do you think Maxam and Drax were holding back when they double teamed Thor and struck him at the same time? If they were holding back then why didnt Drax simply not hold back and take Thor himself? Why did they feel the need to double team him, not that it made the least bit of difference as they both got KO'd in rapid succession. Drax has probably never been struck as hard. The power gem was literally knocked out of his body.

Read SS #86 page 2 -15 both SS and BRB did not want to fight Thor, all they've wanted was to take him to Asgard and as stated By SS pg.14 "you behave as a madman. you must be restrained as one." Pg.16 BRB beat Thor, what did they do? BRB explained to SS whats happening to Thor then both of them observe Thor while Thor was in the ground hallucinating and talking, why didnt 1 or both of them took this chance to finally put un end to him? Pg. 19 While Both heroes were discussing and was not even paying attention Thor blasted them.

Warlock and infinity watch #23 Pg. 1 "My goal is to help him despite the fact that some years he nearly beat me to death." Warlock thought pg. 20 "I began to realize the folly of my intentions to physically overpower Thor in order to cure his troubled soul." Then Warlock blasted Thor with Karmic blast just to overload his spirit enough to blackout but did not work.

In these series all the heroes involved were trying to help cure Thor of his madness not beat him to death. This is why im saying it would be diff. story if they wanted to kill Thor.

Dont even get me started about the downplaying of the Char. involved in these series Ie. SS #86 SS not landing a single shot against Thor.
Warlock chronicles #7 SS was brought down by BRB with a single Shuryuken 🙂 uppercut which put SS into unconciousness. I mean he took a few shots from Thor before going down, same from Tyrant.
Infinity Watch, SS, Dr. Strange Vs BRB, Bandits. They lost against BRB and the bandits.
this would mean BRB>>>>>>Tyrant>>>>>>>>>MThor>>>>>>>>SS.

Originally posted by Accel
That's ABC Logic, which just doesn't always work, especially no for this fight.

I agree.

Another example: at least as far as I am aware of, everytime Surfer has gone up against Hulk, he has defeated Hulk hands-down, whereas Thor has always had his hands full with Hulk. By that reasoning: if Surfer beat Hulk, and Hulk stalemated Thor, then SS > Thor.

Of course, one could rightfully argue that Thor was not using his full potential against Hulk (or Superman). To counter though, I would say, well that's how Thor typically fights: he rarely uses all those dimensional, energy-absorbing and whatnot powers. So to be consistent, again, SS should beat Thor based on how Thor typically fights.

But (sigh) he hasn't...and that does bug me cuz SS is my fave character, whereas Thor...eh.

Nonetheless, Marvel canon has Thor > SS.

Regardless, I do Not see SS beating Warrior Madness Thor: WM Thor has ten times the power of "regular" Thor (though there are some eer moments in SS #86--like when 1) SS misses Thor with a cosmic bolt, and 2) doesn't fire off another one while Thor's hammer is returning to him). However, I do have questions about the first SSvsThor fight.

I've elaborated on this in other threads, but basically it's this: before Surfer got his own first series, he had had his power reduced in FF#72 to a mere fraction of what it was (this was not a 1-shot deal: SS mentioned in subsequent FF issues how he now possessed only a fraction of his former power). Yet, when he got his first series, it was as if the sonic-shark incident never happened! Even if Loki helped empower Surfer for that first fight with Thor, initially SS fought Loki to a stalemate, which means, at best, Loki could only have doubled Surfer's power--again, no where near what SS's power used to be.

In any event: the sonic-shark incident was never mentioned ever again...and frankly, I've always found that bogus. Nonetheless...Marvel canon stands at Thor > Surfer. I don't like it, but there ain't much I can do about it.

I've heard this stated on the boards, but where was it stated in comics that his strength was multiplied by 10? I believe that was just an exaggeration.

I read it somewhere in his bio. Cant rember for sure but its in 1 of my collection, ive got to dig it dough.

Both times the Surfer woke up from being easily KO'd he was surprised to still be alive. If you don't listen to me, listen to the Surfer. He certainly knew the second time around that he could easily end up dead but try as he might he wasn't able to come close to KOing thor. Are you seriously saying that although the Surfer does not have the power to drop thor to his knees that he has the power to kill him and that he would hold back to such an extent even when 1) he says he is no longer holding back and 2) he is fighting for his own life? And if Surfer is as powerful as you say, then why did he need to team up with Warlock for something you claim he should have had no problem handling by himself? Not that teaming up with Warlock made the least bit of difference as they both were lucky to escape alive.

Im not saying SS is a lot more powerfull than Thor, What im referring to is that SS was holding back against that fight for reason of him helping Thor and also ive read all SS comics and in that fight he was not potrayed well. Both Warlock and SS has fought opponents more powerfull than Madness Thor yet in this fight they didnt show what theyre really capable off, theyre resolve, there Characters. Also there at times that SS would rather surrender causing great harm to himself rather than kill un opponent, I cant give you Issues # right now cause ive got to dig it out.

In the comics they were not holding back. Maybe you like to think they were but none of the gems had a meaningful effect on Thor. Ever wonder why Warlock didnt bother using his gem again?

Sorry I really refuse to beleive that the gems have no effect on MThor.
Karmic was useless to Thor but there are other use of the soul gem, heck it had an affect against eternity>>>>>>>Mthor. Space gem could easily teleport MThor to asgard then Odin could pass death sentence to Thor, Reality Gem nuff said.

i think SS would win dont ask me how or why i just think he would......they should make them fight again

I would be curious to see how this "upgraded" Surfer would do against Thor.

ok i just read all bout thor and i already read up on ss and i think thor would win this 6/10

Originally posted by zbucsz
ok i just read all bout thor and i already read up on ss and i think thor would win this 6/10
and how does he beat SS?

just go all out and blast his ass crush his head wit his hammer

Originally posted by zbucsz
just go all out and blast his ass crush his head wit his hammer
SS is to fast for thor to hit.

and also if SS wants he can stop time around him

so ur sayin thor can hit him at all? im sure thors hammer can stop time or something

On KMC, Silver Surfer can smoke anybody short of Thanos. However, in a comic Thor would probably win.

Originally posted by Rols
I read it somewhere in his bio. Cant rember for sure but its in 1 of my collection, ive got to dig it dough.

Im not saying SS is a lot more powerfull than Thor,

Of course not, that would be silly. He is much less powerful. He cannot even hurt Thanos while Thor (with no power gem or belt of strength) has come close to KOing Thanos single-handedly.

What im referring to is that SS was holding back against that fight for reason of him helping Thor and also ive read all SS comics and in that fight he was not potrayed well.

Yet the Surfer specifically said he was not holding back and still got the stuffing knocked out of him. Fact is, the Surfer is not and never has been as powerful as Thor and he and others have said so many times.

He might be able to take a calm Thor out with a surprise attack (the same way Thor might be able to take out Thanos) but a ticked off Thor is a different matter altogether and the angrier Thor got more pathetic the Surfer's attacks seemed. Who can forget the funny scene where the Surfer decided to unload on Thanos.

In any case, its obvious that it's not a good idea to mess with an angry asgardian. Thor himself has been knocked around by other Asgardians like Heimdell who layed him out with one punch.

Both Warlock and SS has fought opponents more powerfull than Madness Thor

And they would have lost those fights as well unless those characters had weaknesses that Thor does not have.

yet in this fight they didnt show what theyre really capable off, theyre resolve, there Characters.

Sure they did. They came up against a far more powerful force than either one individually and despite the risk to their lives they both did their best to take control of the situation. In the end you can see the Surfer was carried out unconcious on a stretcher but his willingness to fight to the end and come to the rescue of someone he dislikes (Warlock) shows his character. If not for the Surfer, Thor might well have killed Warlock. Surfer intervened and Thor took his anger out on the Surfer instead. Of course, Warlock once again rescued Surfer from having his head crushed.

Also there at times that SS would rather surrender causing great harm to himself rather than kill un opponent, I cant give you Issues # right now cause ive got to dig it out.

Of course this is true but it's not true here when Surfer specifically said he was not holding back and he also was trying to keep Warlock from being killed, perhaps to repay Warlock for saving his skull when Thor ko'd him the first time.

Sorry I really refuse to beleive that the gems have no effect on MThor.
Karmic was useless to Thor but there are other use of the soul gem, heck it had an affect against eternity>>>>>>>Mthor. Space gem could easily teleport MThor to asgard then Odin could pass death sentence to Thor, Reality Gem nuff said.

It's obvious that none of the characters holding the gems are capable of using them properly, certainly not enough to affect a god. Even the elders could not properly utilize the powers of the gems. Did you forget what Thanos did to the Gardener?

I read it somewhere in his bio. Cant rember for sure but its in 1 of my collection, ive got to dig it dough.

Im not saying SS is a lot more powerfull than Thor,

Of course not, that would be silly. He is much less powerful. He cannot even hurt Thanos while Thor (with no power gem or belt of strength) has come close to KOing Thanos single-handedly.

I was referring to MThor feat level being 10x than norm Thor.
I had thought that Thor alway have the belt of strenth in him, Thanos fought Thor with power gem and I think he could have seriously injured him if he wanted to, but again they were there to help him. He could easily wipe out Thor from existence using reality gem. again they were there to help him.

Yet the Surfer specifically said he was not holding back and still got the stuffing knocked out of him. Fact is, the Surfer is not and never has been as powerful as Thor and he and others have said so many times.

He might be able to take a calm Thor out with a surprise attack (the same way Thor might be able to take out Thanos) but a ticked off Thor is a different matter altogether and the angrier Thor got more pathetic the Surfer's attacks seemed. Who can forget the funny scene where the Surfer decided to unload on Thanos.

In any case, its obvious that it's not a good idea to mess with an angry asgardian. Thor himself has been knocked around by other Asgardians like Heimdell who layed him out with one punch

You are only refering everythin about SS base on this storyline, if you read his series then youll understand what im talking about, he is able to do more than just blast or H2h. I mean look at his durability issue in here BRB took him with 1 punch in part 7 , heck the whole freakin team lost to BRB and a bunch of bandits, i mean what kind of writing is that.
This is my opinion and interpretition, the heroes trying to help Thor is eather holding back or poorly written. Well never reach an agreement because every writer writes there Char. diff. according to the plot. Ie. Thanos showing against Odin, i mean he should have no problem taking Thor if he has this kind of showing against Odin.

It's obvious that none of the characters holding the gems are capable of using them properly, certainly not enough to affect a god. Even the elders could not properly utilize the powers of the gems. Did you forget what Thanos did to the Gardener?

Are you saying Thanos having have the gem for that long is not capable of using it properly, i mean he friggin resurected Capt. Marvel just for consultation. Pip and Dr. strange could have easily transported MThor to Asgard and let Odin deal with the situation and i dont think Mthor can resist a transportation. Lets see karmic blast + mind blast slow Mthor down, enough for pip to transport Mthor to Asgard for Odin to deal with and this would result in the death of Thor.

Originally posted by zbucsz
so ur sayin thor can hit him at all? im sure thors hammer can stop time or something

nope........ he has no speed limit 🙂

Originally posted by batdude123
On KMC, Silver Surfer can smoke anybody short of Thanos. However, in a comic Thor would probably win.
in comics SS is always shown as the stongest hero 🙂

Originally posted by Rols
[B]I was referring to MThor feat level being 10x than norm Thor.
I had thought that Thor alway have the belt of strenth in him, Thanos fought Thor with power gem and I think he could have seriously injured him if he wanted to, but again they were there to help him. He could easily wipe out Thor from existence using reality gem. again they were there to help him.

What makes you think he could wipe Thor out of existence? Again, your knowledge of Marvel comics seems limited. All the evidence has been that none of the gems (used individually) can overcome Thor.

You are only refering everythin about SS base on this storyline, if you read his series then youll understand what im talking about, he is able to do more than just blast or H2h.

None of his powers can do anything to Thor. In Marvel comics, Gods are immune to a lot of things that would affect most characters.

I mean look at his durability issue in here BRB took him with 1 punch in part 7 , heck the whole freakin team lost to BRB and a bunch of bandits, i mean what kind of writing is that.
This is my opinion and interpretition, the heroes trying to help Thor is eather holding back or poorly written.

If it was just one isolated comic it can be poor writing but the entire series across a number of marvel product lines is based on the premise that Thor can wipe the floor with the Surfer. Surfer himself has admitted to this in the past and in this comic also we see Sif obviously worried about what Thor would do to the Surfer. Turns out she was right.

Well never reach an agreement because every writer writes there Char. diff. according to the plot. Ie. Thanos showing against Odin, i mean he should have no problem taking Thor if he has this kind of showing against Odin.

Thanos didnt do anything to Odin. All he showed was that he can take one hell of beating and not die. And yes, in a pitched H2H fight he will almost always beat Thor as long as Thor does not have the power gem.

Are you saying Thanos having have the gem for that long is not capable of using it properly, i mean he friggin resurected Capt. Marvel just for consultation. Pip and Dr. strange could have easily transported MThor to Asgard and let Odin deal with the situation and i dont think Mthor can resist a transportation. Lets see karmic blast + mind blast slow Mthor down, enough for pip to transport Mthor to Asgard for Odin to deal with and this would result in the death of Thor.

Huh? What are you talking about? Neither the Karmic blast or mindblast had any effect on Thor. Didnt even knock him down. In fact, it was specifically stated "my mindblast isnt even slowing him down". Given that this is the case, it's a bit of a stretch to think that somehow it will when another equally impotent attack is used. There's a reason why Warlock and Moondragon didnt bother using their gems after the first time.

This is why Maxam says "maybe this is a situation that calls for brute force". Well, that didnt work either for while his sucker punch hurt Thor, it just ticked him off more, and when he and Drax (with power gem) double teamed Thor, it just ticked him off even more, and the result was that Maxam and Drax were layed out before they knew what hit them.

Thanos, undoubtedly boosted by technology as he always is (and might as well be considered his own capability), did very well to go toe to toe with Thor with the Power Gem. But as Thor was growing in power he would have broken out and killed them all as they all feared.

As for teleporting, Thor can teleport whereever he wants. Also, Odin could have killed him but chose not to for obvious reasons and learned that it wasnt berserker rage but insanity resulting from all the times Odin screwed with Thor's mind.

Originally posted by Loot
force:

surfer = thor (they are both in class 100)

speed:
surfer wins this one, do i have to explain why? once he was in a galaxy far far away (no this is not star wars) and in five minutes he was able to come to earth, 99% of speed of light, hability to Dimension Travel: Once its maximum speed is reached, the board can enter hyper-space to quickly reach any section of the universe.
Phasing: The board has the Monstrous ability to render itself and its rider(s) temporarily immaterial. This power is used to enable them to pass through a barrier or to travel through space without risking collision damage with spaceborne particles.

Invulnerability:
Surfer - Cl1000 resistance to Fire, Heat, Cold, Radiation, Toxins, Disease and Aging

thor - has CL1000 Resistance to Disease

it seems to me they are almost equal, but surfer wins again.

Fighting habilities:

thor wins in this one, surfer was a scientis not a warrior, although surfer is improving as fighter, thor is far superior.

Healing factor:

altough thor has the ability to heal faster, surfer can heal others, and heal himself, with Unearthly ability.

and what about the rest of the powers, thor has mjolnir and thanks to that he don´t get his ass kicked in 5 secondes (exagerating), but surfer can re-arrange molecules ( Reconstitute matter to his own desires),
The Surfer has the power to channel cosmic radiation into his body and transform it into useful forms, including sustenance and energy for his other powers, Telepathy, the ability to emit blasts of Unearthly intensity from his hands, and i could go on and on.

This is the best post I have read on the topic. I think SS wins based on his power. SS is amazingly powerful, and underrated as a thinker. He oftentimes simply outsmarts opponents, knowing the limits of their powers almost immediatly (cosmic aweareness).

Originally posted by Stupid Rookie
This is the best post I have read on the topic. I think SS wins based on his power. SS is amazingly powerful, and underrated as a thinker. He oftentimes simply outsmarts opponents, knowing the limits of their powers almost immediatly (cosmic aweareness).

Lot's of mistakes in this post and it glosses over important differentiators.

force:

surfer = thor (they are both in class 100)

Wrong. Class 100 can be anything from lifting 100tons + 1lb to infinity. Surfer is strong, he has knocked people into orbit, but in strength he is nowhere near Thor. One only has to look at the relative effect of Surfer and Thor on Thanos or, even better, Galactus. Furthermore, in a head to head conflict, Thor can draw the power cosmic right out of the Surfer and can control cosmic forces at a level beyond what the Surfer can.

speed:
surfer wins this one, do i have to explain why? once he was in a galaxy far far away (no this is not star wars) and in five minutes he was able to come to earth, 99% of speed of light, hability to Dimension Travel: Once its maximum speed is reached, the board can enter hyper-space to quickly reach any section of the universe.
Phasing: The board has the Monstrous ability to render itself and its rider(s) temporarily immaterial. This power is used to enable them to pass through a barrier or to travel through space without risking collision damage with spaceborne particles.

This person is confusing straight line speed with combat speed. Thor is better in both. He can travel faster than the speed of light, easily crossing dimensions, or just plain teleport. In combat, he has FTL reflexes and can keep up with speed machines like the Gladiator. Whereas Surfer becomes immaterial to avoid objects in space at high speed, Thor can actually navigate meteor storms at those speeds.

Invulnerability:
Surfer - Cl1000 resistance to Fire, Heat, Cold, Radiation, Toxins, Disease and Aging

thor - has CL1000 Resistance to Disease

it seems to me they are almost equal, but surfer wins again.

Surfer may or may not be more invulnerable to heat, cold, radiation, toxins, disease and aging (there's no clear evidence one way or the other) but he is certainly more vulnerable to concussion than Thor and the Gladiator. Thor had to strike the gladiator and BRB a number of times to knock them out but with the Surfer, once was enough twice, even when he was fighting for his own survival and that of Warlock.

What's even more relavent is that Thor has demonstrably far greater attacking power which means that even if they are both equally resistant to battle damage Thor has a much better chance of knocking out the Surfer. Add in faster reflexes and it becomes a done deal.

Fighting habilities:

thor wins in this one, surfer was a scientis not a warrior, although surfer is improving as fighter, thor is far superior.

Fighting ability is a combination of skill and instinct and you are correct on this one.

Healing factor:

altough thor has the ability to heal faster, surfer can heal others, and heal himself, with Unearthly ability.

Surfer does win this one. He should be able to heal himself whereas Thor takes much longer. But in the course of a fight this is meaningless.

and what about the rest of the powers, thor has mjolnir and thanks to that he don´t get his ass kicked in 5 secondes (exagerating), but surfer can re-arrange molecules ( Reconstitute matter to his own desires),
The Surfer has the power to channel cosmic radiation into his body and transform it into useful forms, including sustenance and energy for his other powers, Telepathy, the ability to emit blasts of Unearthly intensity from his hands, and i could go on and on.

With the hammer Thor can actually do things beyond anything the surfer can do (such as rearranging molecules) and actually remove souls, absorb all cosmic energy, or one-shot ko the surfer with the anti-force blast to name a few. Without the hammer Thor can control the power cosmic (externally, not internally like the surfer) and assault his opponents with cosmic storms of far greater scale and power than what the Surfer can manage to channel through his small body.

As god of the storm Thor has control over any energy flow and can whip it up into whatever form he wishes. This has been demonstrated many times. The surfer can shoot cosmic blasts out of his hands but they aren't all that impressive. He hit thor from behind a few times and couldn't even knock him off his feet. And let's not forget that Thor can let loose the god-force straight out of his own body. All he has to do is grapple the surfer and cut loose, incinerating the surfer at point blank range.

Although he would probably just do what he did before as it seemed quite easy.

What makes you think he could wipe Thor out of existence? Again, your knowledge of Marvel comics seems limited. All the evidence has been that none of the gems (used individually) can overcome Thor.

Sorry you are greatly overstamating madness Thor here, Granted he is very powerfull, and i admit he is a lot stronger than SS, But only the soul and mind gem was used on Thor, what makes you think he is immune to the others. IE. Space, time, reality.

None of his powers can do anything to Thor. In Marvel comics, Gods are immune to a lot of things that would affect most characters.

In your opinion, not ours. I seemed to remember Thor scared of a warning shot from SS, and also how both Thor and SS defeated Millinea who is by far more powerfull than Thor And dont tell my that was all Thors doing cause id call that Bull.

If it was just one isolated comic it can be poor writing but the entire series across a number of marvel product lines is based on the premise that Thor can wipe the floor with the Surfer. Surfer himself has admitted to this in the past and in this comic also we see Sif obviously worried about what Thor would do to the Surfer. Turns out she was right.

Again your opinion as you like Thor, We SS fans have a diff. opinion as weve seen diff. feat of SS surpassing the one in Blood and Thunder crossover.

Thanos didnt do anything to Odin. All he showed was that he can take one hell of beating and not die. And yes, in a pitched H2H fight he will almost always beat Thor as long as Thor does not have the power gem.

Yes, i totally agree with you on that but why didnt Thanos display that kind of firepower against Madness Thor in there first encounter, heck why didnt he used reality gem to take him out. My opinion, because they were there to help him not out for blood.

Huh? What are you talking about? Neither the Karmic blast or mindblast had any effect on Thor. Didnt even knock him down. In fact, it was specifically stated "my mindblast isnt even slowing him down". Given that this is the case, it's a bit of a stretch to think that somehow it will when another equally impotent attack is used. There's a reason why Warlock and Moondragon didnt bother using their gems after the first time.

Again this is why i said your only based this Characters feat on this particular crossover. The soul gem has diff. other feats not just Karmic Blast, read Warlock and the Infinity Watch, Warlock Chronicles, miniseries. And regarding the Mind Gem MoonDragoon use it to heal Thor out from his madness by destroying Valeria issence. It was not an attack.

This is why Maxam says "maybe this is a situation that calls for brute force". Well, that didnt work either for while his sucker punch hurt Thor, it just ticked him off more, and when he and Drax (with power gem) double teamed Thor, it just ticked him off even more, and the result was that Maxam and Drax were layed out before they knew what hit them

Do you also remember in part 2 of this crossover How easily BRB knock Thor out and then in part 7 Thor easily swat both Maxam and Drax w/power gem, heck Drax fought Insane GenisVille but lost yet he didnt show the kind of brutality displayed on that fight against MThor. Do you see the inconsestency of the Cha. in here, it just depends on the writer, showing high and low feats according to story plot.

Thanos, undoubtedly boosted by technology as he always is (and might as well be considered his own capability), did very well to go toe to toe with Thor with the Power Gem. But as Thor was growing in power he would have broken out and killed them all as they all feared.

Sorry but i have a diff. interpretion of that, They feared but they feared his health more so. This team bloodlusted against Madness Thor, Thor killed horribly bare in mind thats just my opinion.

As for teleporting, Thor can teleport whereever he wants. Also, Odin could have killed him but chose not to for obvious reasons and learned that it wasnt berserker rage but insanity resulting from all the times Odin screwed with Thor's mind.

How did you get that result. Odin Stated it was the Madness and was afraid that it might be too late to cure, but obviously it was not.

Wrong. Class 100 can be anything from lifting 100tons + 1lb to infinity. Surfer is strong, he has knocked people into orbit, but in strength he is nowhere near Thor. One only has to look at the relative effect of Surfer and Thor on Thanos or, even better, Galactus. Furthermore, in a head to head conflict, Thor can draw the power cosmic right out of the Surfer and can control cosmic forces at a level beyond what the Surfer can.

Again that is your opinion, we all know how SS jobbs to Thanos. Regarding Thor absorbing SS pc, has he done it, no, then dont assume he can. Ive only seen Quazar done it.

This person is confusing straight line speed with combat speed. Thor is better in both. He can travel faster than the speed of light, easily crossing dimensions, or just plain teleport. In combat, he has FTL reflexes and can keep up with speed machines like the Gladiator. Whereas Surfer becomes immaterial to avoid objects in space at high speed, Thor can actually navigate meteor storms at those speeds.

Read some SS issue will you or check respect thread, dont assume.

Surfer may or may not be more invulnerable to heat, cold, radiation, toxins, disease and aging (there's no clear evidence one way or the other) but he is certainly more vulnerable to concussion than Thor and the Gladiator.

He once carried a virus that could completly decemate the population of the universe but was anaffected by it. Checked the respect thread for other invulnaribily feat. My opinion SS better invulnarability than Thor.

What's even more relavent is that Thor has demonstrably far greater attacking power which means that even if they are both equally resistant to battle damage Thor has a much better chance of knocking out the Surfer. Add in faster reflexes and it becomes a done deal.

Where, If your refering to Blood and Thunder thats just crap, obviously it was meant to cure Thor of his Madness but some people took it diff.
Ive seen SS took a planetary blast without a scratch, he has also dished out planetary blast as well.

With the hammer Thor can actually do things beyond anything the surfer can do (such as rearranging molecules) and actually remove souls, absorb all cosmic energy, or one-shot ko the surfer with the anti-force blast to name a few. Without the hammer Thor can control the power cosmic (externally, not internally like the surfer) and assault his opponents with cosmic storms of far greater scale and power than what the Surfer can manage to channel through his small body.

As god of the storm Thor has control over any energy flow and can whip it up into whatever form he wishes. This has been demonstrated many times. The surfer can shoot cosmic blasts out of his hands but they aren't all that impressive. He hit thor from behind a few times and couldn't even knock him off his feet. And let's not forget that Thor can let loose the god-force straight out of his own body. All he has to do is grapple the surfer and cut loose, incinerating the surfer at point blank range.

Although he would probably just do what he did before as it seemed quite easy.

You obviously dont read SS issue, all your opinion is biased on Thor, try reading some SS issue before you start downplaying SS, its just very sad the way your describing him.

Blood and Thunder Crossovers
Feats (power level) according to this series compared to these individuals characters own issues;
- MThor *High end feat showings
-Warlock and Infinity Watch *Low end feat showing
-Dr. Strange *Low end feat showing
-Thanos *Normal feat showing
-SS *Low end feat showing
-BRB *Normal feat showing
-Infinity Gems *Low end feat showing
Just my 2 cents.