Does Obi-Wan know.....

Started by jedijunky11387 pages

Does Obi-Wan know.....

Does Obi-Wan know about Leia? Think about it. In ESB when luke is leaving Dagobah Obi says "that boy is our last hope.". Yoda said "No there is another." this implies that Obi doesn't know about Leia....

Any thoughts?

Does he not mean Darth, because he's the one who actually kills the emperior

he knows about leia because in a new hope he knows who the girl is talking on R2D2's holagram

Could he know Leia as Leia Organa and just not know her connection to Luke and Ani?

doesn't make much sense though does it

it could just be that obi-wan was not counting leia as an asset for a victory against the emperor and vader.

In ANH Obi-Wan never said that he knew who she was. She introduced herself at the beginning of the message. I am wondering if Leia was born after Obi- Wan takes Luke from the room? Guess we will have to wait and see.

To the best of my thinking I don't think Vader knows the twins were ever born. I think he thinks they died with Padme. That hints at the newly added dialog in ESB between Vader and the Emperor.

he new of her because in return of jedi he said she is your twin sister luke so hide your feelings or something like that he probibley will look at her before he and baby luke escape to tatooine.

Clearly Yoda didn't mean Vader. That would bee too subtle to catch attention. He was refering to Leia, setting up ROTJ.

In ROTJ he knew because Yoda told him after luke left Dagobah in ESB. You don't think Obi-Wan questioned Yoda when he said "there is another."?

Of course he knows, he's her father.

Obi-Wan could be thinking that Leia is not force-strong, but I doubt it.

Obi-Wan is not Leia's father.......??????????

Um guys. I don't know about you, but I figure once someone becomes one with the Force, that they get a lot of understanding. Probably the moment OB1 dies he becomes a whole lot more informed about what's happening around the galaxy. Call it an omniscience if you will. Otherwise, how would he know Luke was on Hoth even? It's not like the rebels sent Ghost-Ben a telegram. So, he knows that Leia is Luke's sis. But she most certainly has not been trained. And he knows if Luke fails that Vader will probably find out about Leia and hunt her down and kill her before she has a chance to be a threat.
But Yoda is a little more optimistic than Ben. Plus, Yoda was talking about me.

Of course.

Originally posted by jedijunky1138
Obi-Wan is not Leia's father.......??????????

Yes he is.

"help us darth vader, you're our only hope."

Mr Zero, Please.... this is a serious discussion.

Anakin of course is Leia's dad

Originally posted by jedijunky1138
Mr Zero, Please.... this is a serious discussion.

Im serious. Obi-wan is luke and leias dad. End . of. Story.

Originally posted by zutalurs
Um guys. I don't know about you, but I figure once someone becomes one with the Force, that they get a lot of understanding. Probably the moment OB1 dies he becomes a whole lot more informed about what's happening around the galaxy. Call it an omniscience if you will. Otherwise, how would he know Luke was on Hoth even? It's not like the rebels sent Ghost-Ben a telegram. So, he knows that Leia is Luke's sis. But she most certainly has not been trained. And he knows if Luke fails that Vader will probably find out about Leia and hunt her down and kill her before she has a chance to be a threat.
But Yoda is a little more optimistic than Ben. Plus, Yoda was talking about me.

Then why does he think Luke is there only hope?