Rouge vs. Hulk

If rogue absorbed hulks strength she wouldnt just absorb his gamma power she'd absorb all the physical properties that make him the hulk as well as part of his psyche. She would essentially be the hulk but in a sexier body. While in that state if she got angry then her physical strength would increase also. Rogues power's capacity has not been established. Shes been repelled by cosmic and mystical beings in her time but it still hasnt been laid out. Rogue would hav the full range of the hulks abilities and physical properties added to her own for 60 times longer than the amount of time she made phsical contact with him. So less say she'll hav his abilities plus her own for at least a minute. Id say thats plenty of time for her to knock him out or at least absorb his powers again. While im not saying rogue would definitely win i dont believe at all that she can be dismissed as a easily as some of you hav been doing

Hulk would give rouge his best rick james imitation and ask her. What did the 5 fingers say to the face, and then he would slap her out cold

Rogues way too fast to stand there and take that. Remember shes got ms marvels speed here. Shes faster a lot more manoeuvreable shes strong plus shes got her absorbing powers. Dont count her out. Shed absorb his powers then slap him down wiv her own set of gamma mutated hands

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
If rogue absorbed hulks strength she wouldnt just absorb his gamma power she'd absorb all the physical properties that make him the hulk as well as part of his psyche. She would essentially be the hulk but in a sexier body. While in that state if she got angry then her physical strength would increase also. Rogues power's capacity has not been established. Shes been repelled by cosmic and mystical beings in her time but it still hasnt been laid out. Rogue would hav the full range of the hulks abilities and physical properties added to her own for 60 times longer than the amount of time she made phsical contact with him. So less say she'll hav his abilities plus her own for at least a minute. Id say thats plenty of time for her to knock him out or at least absorb his powers again. While im not saying rogue would definitely win i dont believe at all that she can be dismissed as a easily as some of you hav been doing

You didn't understand the sponge analogy, did you?

She isnt as durable as Hulk. She would put up a good fight, but would lose in the end. shes fought guys like juggernaut and got her ass handed to her. She doesnt have the battle experince like the hulk nor the power!

"Dont count her out. Shed absorb his powers then slap him down wiv her own set of gamma mutated hands"

Don't ever claim that I know nothing again. Ever.

Ever.

-AC

explain yourself AC. If you read what i was saying as a whole instead of picking out quotes which mean a different thing when separated from the rest of my post then you will see that i never once said i think she could beat the hulk. I said that people shouldnt count her out. Simple as and i gave reasons why which is fair enough

People are obviously mistaking the purpose of Vs threads. Let me clear it up.

A winner is to be determined. Whether Hulk kills her fast or slow...he kills her.

It's that simple.

"Rogue would hav the full range of the hulks abilities and physical properties added to her own for 60 times longer than the amount of time she made phsical contact with him."

Anyone got a "I'm just gonna hit my keyboard with a hammer and see what comes out" decoder?

-AC

Lol yeah i luv u too

The hulk backers on this thread don't seem to know or choose to ignore the fact that physical strength isn't the deciding factor in this fight.
It doesn't matter how strong you are if you're knocked out before you can do anything. Rogue isn't draining his strength alone and leaving the rest of his faculties intact.

"It doesn't matter how strong you are if you're knocked out before you can do anything. Rogue isn't draining his strength alone and leaving the rest of his faculties intact."

What complete nonsense.

She isn't gonna knock him out though. Your whole arguments are that she will drain him to the point of being knocked out, which is impossible. Then you claim she'll drain him and knock him out with her drained power, which she still won't have the power to do because Hulk will compensate. You are ignoring that fact, denying that he'll compensate. If he gained the strength to lift 150 billion tons in seconds, how is Rogue's little draining technique gonna sap him enough to end the fight?

Answer: It's not.

-AC

Answer. She doesn't have to drain all of his strength to beat him. What good is being able to lift 150 billion tons if your mind is gone. Rogue doesn't just drain strength she steals the psyche as well.
Even IF his strength was compensated as soon as she took it, it wouldn't do him any good.

AC why cant you get it into your head rogue will be absorbing the hulks strength but also his ability to increase his strength as he angers so how will hulk compensate for that she will be starting ahead of him cos shes just adding his strength to her own. Plus shes got her far greater speed her flight and her seventh sense to anticipate an opponents actions. She could very well knock him out or just continually absorb more power over the course of the fight. None of them r going down easily but rogues got more weapons at her disposal

"Answer. She doesn't have to drain all of his strength to beat him. What good is being able to lift 150 billion tons if your mind is gone. Rogue doesn't just drain strength she steals the psyche as well.
Even IF his strength was compensated as soon as she took it, it wouldn't do him any good."

She can't drain his mind, where are you getting this stuff? He has MPD. That's why he's immune to psychics and telepaths. She's not gonna be able to instantly absorb him, deal with his 8 plus volatile personalities and stay alive while attacking him. She's going to die. If she made everyone braindead by touching them then she wouldn't be able to be hit would she? This is all dependant on the chance of her being able to GRAB him. Which is slight enough as it is. Add to the fact that The Hulk will be trying to actually hurt her, she's got nothing.

I've explained this to you. She has a max capacity. Even at max, she's not got enough to knock out Hulk. Human fists aren't gonna do anything to Hulk regardless of what they're powered by. Hulk's two foot wide fists to Rogue's face are gonna kill her. That's all it'd take, it's not a match. Rogue could not beat Hulk.

"She could very well knock him out or just continually absorb more power over the course of the fight. None of them r going down easily but rogues got more weapons at her disposal......"

So? All Hulk needs is his strength. He also has a healing factor, speed, agility. She isn't draining his ability to increase with rage. That's a personal power. She absorbs personality TRAITS, not personal background and life story.

What you don't get is that this is The Hulk. She can't fly around grabbing him whenever she feels like it. At all. She tried that against Grey Hulk (the weakest Hulk) and he smacked her with a lamp post and knocked her out of Earth's orbit.

She can't beat him. You're not proving that she can, just that you want her to.

-AC

"So? All Hulk needs is his strength. He also has a healing factor, speed, agility. She isn't draining his ability to increase with rage. That's a personal power. She absorbs personality TRAITS, not personal background and life story."

How is the hulks ability to increase his physical strength over an undetermined geometric through an increase in anger not a power rogue can absorb? Alpha get real and go and read their bios. Or better still make sure youre an avid reader of comics they both feature in. How have you been reading comics for 15 yrs to come out with ill informed rubbish like this/

geometric curve

Rogue absorbs physical properties, hence the reason she often turns into a facsimile of whomever shes touching, she absorbs personality traits and personal powers. What on earth r u on about?

AC The powers that Rogue can absorb aren't limited to those that you want them limited to. You're pulling "facts" out of your ass again. Try reading the comics.

"How is the hulks ability to increase his physical strength over an undetermined geometric through an increase in anger not a power rogue can absorb? Alpha get real and go and read their bios. "

Hahaha, read their bios. I'll be using that quote.

"Or better still make sure youre an avid reader of comics they both feature in. How have you been reading comics for 15 yrs to come out with ill informed rubbish like this"

I've been reading Hulk, X-Men, Spider-Man and Marvel comics in general since I was 5. I'm 19. What you got for me? Shhh.

"AC The powers that Rogue can absorb aren't limited to those that you want them limited to. You're pulling "facts" out of your ass again. Try reading the comics."

I'm not wanting anything. I'm proving shit to you. Nothing you or GalacticStorm just said proves me wrong.

Let's get back to the debate at hand. She cannot drain him to point of knock out. She can't drain him and kill him. Let's go by what you believe then yes?

She drains him. She's not gamma powered, so? Hulk WILL have compensated. Comics prove that he goes from strength to strength in seconds. Better yet, strength to unbelieveable-unparalleled strength in seconds.

This WHOLE debate is based around "She could drain him then knock him out", which she couldn't do.

-AC

You've proven nothing to me except that you really don't understand how Rogue's power works.
Hulk's strength is not a factor once she's absorbed his mind. Rogue's going to increase in strength and endurance while Hulk's drops. Whether Rogue is gamma powered or not is totally irrelevant, I don't know why you keep bringing this up. Rogue's taking hulk's abilities, that's what her power is.