Not even, common I know you've read lethal protector, in that series alone, venom had spidey at his mercy at least 3 times, in i think spectacular spiderman 375,,,,(I don't remember) the comic where spidey and venom make an uneasy truce, venom was sufficating spidey to death until he got hit with sonics from behind, and a ferris wheel almost fell on his woman. Then when the collecter got a bunch of the x-men and some marvel villains, Venom was killing spiderman again until storm whacked him from behind with a lightning bolt, Venom KOed spidey in venom 18 I believe with rather ease. Even the example you're reffering to Venom gased spidey had him at his mercy took him the island and they fought yes, but spidey didn't beat him, didn't even come close, instead he faked his death and hightailed his ass of the island. Venom stayed on the island as a happy guy and EVEN THEN when spidey went to go get venom's help to fight carnage and get himoff the island, Even with the human torches help and spidey's own sonic gun, venom was once again getting the best of him, both of them actually, spidey only got out of that alive after jonney hit him from behind with a lazer. then spidey nearly got killed along with supes in that crossover at venom's hands. Then venom had spidey at his mercy again in along came a spider.....time after time venom kicks spidey's ass. Spidey can't take him on without interference, dumb luck, or a decent amount of sonics or fire. The only time that spidey has successfully taken down venom without any of these was in the exile returns, but that wasn't parker it was ben and even then he had a little dumb luck on his side. the only other reaaaally embarrasing defeat was when spderman baked down venom with a lighter (ridiculous, but the whole comic was more or less a big in-joke anyway).