Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Started by carver9220 pages

I think this sums up who'll won this fight. 😉

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=i_BVqa4gpdM&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Di_BVqa4gpdM

Originally posted by carver9
Leo...

I agree, just pointing out one of the scenes where Batman admits Cap is superior. There is another time as well.

fair enuff. in bats defense, he only suggests that cap MIGHT be able to beat him. which, as far as bats goes, is pretty high praise indeed.

Originally posted by carver9
I think this sums up who'll won this fight. 😉

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=i_BVqa4gpdM&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Di_BVqa4gpdM

that's actually pretty funny. 👆

Originally posted by leonidas
😂

just so's everyone in the forum can see this. again, you were challenged, again, no scans to back up this 'supposed' superiority. you don't wanna post because i'll 'discount' them. L. O. L. like i was supposed to be impressed by bp carrying some random guy? i wasn't the only one to make fun of that 'vastly superior feat'. hilarious. your insistence on using 'common sense' is a LAUGHABLE cry given that we're talking about, you know, COMIC BOOKS. not exactly icons of common sense. your refusal to remove batman from your little 'peak human box' is both funny, and sad. the cries of pis and the need to discredit anything he does that does NOT fit in your little box really is priceless. it's like batman threatens you personally or something. you say stop being a fan. i say stop being a blind hater, you say use common sense, i say look at what's on panel and stop hiding behind pis as those superhuman feats have been repeated over and over. but keep clinging to the notion that bats is simply a rl peak human, who shouldn't be able to do 80% of the things he's done 100% of the time through his career. i know it lets you sleep better at night. 👆

to reiterate though--you came in riding someone else's coattails (as cowards do in the forum) and claim cap is superior--vastly--while saying i can't accept it, and despite it being shown 'over and over again' you can't prove it. at all. at least the entire forum can see that you've blatantly run away. again. can't blame you though. your stance is a hater stance, and those stances rarely work out. back to ignore bunky. 🙂


Dammit leo, stop scaring off n00bs.

uhuh

If this is classic Batman I reckon its a long hard fight, but Steve takes him. The 2 are on the same level skill wise, but Steve has greater physical stats. I read on another thread that current Batman got done in h2h by Twoface and the Joker. That version of Bruce would get crushed very quickly by Mr Rogers.

Originally posted by Mr Master
*****************

I posted this a long time ago somewhere in this thread.

----------------------------------------------------

Here are the 3 times Batman and Captain America faced off [b]on panel.

(grant it, they're crossovers, but at-least it's a rough idea)

----------------------------------------------------

Writers: Ron Marz/Peter David (DC vs Marvel)

----------------------------------------------------

Writer: John Byrne (Batman & Captain America)

----------------------------------------------------

Writer: Kurt Busiek (JLA/Avengers)

----------------------------------------------------

All 3 interpretations are similar imo. [/B]


stoned

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
He has no environmental advantage, that's some crap you just made up on the spot. Cap has no equal in terms of using the environment. Do you know anything about Cap besides what he looks like?
you've never read batman have you? batman FROM THE SHADOWS could take down 5 heavily armored Buff goons with the best semi automatic rifles with NOTHING BUT THE FREAKING SHADOWS. NO GADGETS! and I think you not only are blinded by bias cap America fanboyism You Underestimate The batman. Cap is stronger that maybe true But batman one shotted Gorilla Grodd
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/158/batgrodd21il.jpg/
That takes some power to do that

Steve is faster,stronger can take more punishment, far better at h2h nuff said

faster stonger yes. Better h2h my ass.

Originally posted by Mr Master
stoned

yep. clearly the companies are of the opinion that cap wtf stomps batman. 😐

Originally posted by iscaremonkeys
you've never read batman have you? batman FROM THE SHADOWS could take down 5 heavily armored Buff goons with the best semi automatic rifles with NOTHING BUT THE FREAKING SHADOWS. NO GADGETS! and I think you not only are blinded by bias cap America fanboyism You Underestimate The batman. Cap is stronger that maybe true But batman one shotted Gorilla Grodd
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/158/batgrodd21il.jpg/
That takes some power to do that

shh, it's pis..... 😂

Originally posted by LeonBuco666
far better at h2h nuff said

on-panel proof?

Cap wins.

Not sure what is the real argument against this...

Goddammit this again

Let me put some old school learnin' in ya loll

Cap will beat the Bat no getting around it
It will happen

Spidey will beat the Bat
Again no getting around it

Most vilians and heroes that give these 2 trouble will be bad for the Bat

Again no getting around it, it is just a matter of life (or at the very least fake life in a fake universe off paper and ink)

Originally posted by pym-ftw
Cap wins.

Not sure what is the real argument against this...

im auguring that bats is a better hand to hand fighter. Uses the environment better, is a better tactician, and the fact that cap is stronger but Bats is strong in his own right.
Originally posted by maxivitopowe
Goddammit this again

Let me put some old school learnin' in ya loll

Cap will beat the Bat no getting around it
It will happen

Spidey will beat the Bat
Again no getting around it

Most vilians and heroes that give these 2 trouble will be bad for the Bat

Again no getting around it, it is just a matter of life (or at the very least fake life in a fake universe off paper and ink)

cap does not beat bat.
Spidey beats them both 1vs1

Bats is not a better tactician. I know that's the first resort to hype of Bats but it's not better than Captain America.

If there was prep some of that would matter.

Originally posted by maxivitopowe
Goddammit this again

Let me put some old school learnin' in ya loll

Cap will beat the Bat no getting around it
It will happen

Spidey will beat the Bat
Again no getting around it

Most vilians and heroes that give these 2 trouble will be bad for the Bat

Again no getting around it, it is just a matter of life (or at the very least fake life in a fake universe off paper and ink)

😂

and that's been about the extent of the cap side of the debate. cap wins, accept it. fact of life. excellent argument. 👆

more to the point, the more recent debate has revolved around how many bats takes out of 10, and how close the fights would be.

And the Bat side has just insulted the cap side...

Again how is this not a stomp?

Batman would be a solid fight for Bucky in h2h, but Steve is just beyond street level.

Originally posted by pym-ftw
And the Bat side has just insulted the cap side...

Again how is this not a stomp?

Batman would be a solid fight for Bucky in h2h, but Steve is just beyond street level.

i insulted the argument put forth because that argument goes 180 degrees contrary to what both companies have shown repeatedly, and what both characters have DONE, over and again. you think it's a stomp, so maybe YOU can provide the on-panel evidence that would support that stance? i've been asking to see the "overwhelming" evidence that should be so common sensical that it, apparently, doesn't even NEED to be supported. so far, nothing. bear in mind again, in order to support a stomp, cap has to have feats that FAR AND AWAY surpass any comparable feat of batman's. i'm....a bit familiar with both characters so, i would love to see the feats that you think support your stance that this is so clearly a stomp. this is of course classic bats. so, care to take a stab?

Cap wins the majority, whether someone thinks that means 5.1/10 or 10/10 doesn't really matter.

You want me to refresh the evidence every page?

What do you want to argue first?

Strength
Speed
Damage soak
Durability
Reaction speed