Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Started by Juk3n220 pages
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Physically speaking I would say the two are about even in most categories.

While it is true to say DCU makes it's humans a little tougher than the MU, Stating Batman and Steve Rogers as equal PHYSICALLY, is quite insane. I mean hell, dig deep enough and im pretty sure you can find some Batman speed feats (CQ dodging/stealth dissapearing and bullet dodging) comparable to some of Spider-mans', but that doesn't mean...?

Cap and Batman are not equals in the physical sense. Cap ftw.

Cap wears him down after a long fight. But Cap wins 10/10.

Capn ftw 10/10 too overwhelming

Originally posted by Juk3n
While it is true to say DCU makes it's humans a little tougher than the MU, Stating Batman and Steve Rogers as equal PHYSICALLY, is quite insane. I mean hell, dig deep enough and im pretty sure you can find some Batman speed feats (CQ dodging/stealth dissapearing and bullet dodging) comparable to some of Spider-mans', but that doesn't mean...?
That doesn't actually take deep digging.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Physically speaking I would say the two are about even in most categories. Captain America does have the stamina advantage, and probably the speed advantage, but Batman have the skill advantage in my opinion.

It's split for the most part in my opinion.

Besides stamina and speed advantage. Cap is also stronger and more durable. Thanks to his enhanced mind Cap should always be a step ahead of Bruce during the fight.

But I too view Bruce a hair more skilled.

Brubaker and Busiek stated that Cap is superior to Batman.

Originally posted by Juk3n
While it is true to say DCU makes it's humans a little tougher than the MU, Stating Batman and Steve Rogers as equal PHYSICALLY, is quite insane. I mean hell, dig deep enough and im pretty sure you can find some Batman speed feats (CQ dodging/stealth dissapearing and bullet dodging) comparable to some of Spider-mans', but that doesn't mean...?

It's quite insane?

How so?

Captain America is faster when it comes to running speed, and has greater stamina but that's about it. Batman cancels out any of those advantages with the fact he is more skilled.

When it comes to the other physical categories, with their gear they are equal.

I don't have to dig deep at all to find various Batman feats, of incredible strength, and speed such as bullet dodging etc.

Originally posted by Daredevil1
Besides stamina and speed advantage. Cap is also stronger and more durable. Thanks to his enhanced mind Cap should always be a step ahead of Bruce during the fight.

But I too view Bruce a hair more skilled.

So you say. I have vast feats of strength and durability from Batman, that tell me his on par with Captain America.

Travel speed wise, Captain America is superior, and he has greater stamina but that's about it

Enhanced mind?

This is Batman we are talking about.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
It's quite insane?

How so?

Captain America is faster when it comes to running speed, and has greater stamina but that's about it. Batman cancels out any of those advantages with the fact he is more skilled.

When it comes to the other physical categories, with their gear they are equal.

I don't have to dig deep at all to find various Batman feats, of incredible strength, and speed such as bullet dodging etc.

don't bring up bullet dodging like it's a feat exclusive to batman.

captain america is a veteran of the great war, we're talking dodging machine gun fire, grenades, snipers (guy in a flag costume as a target), tanks, etc.

and cap has actually schooled spider-man.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
don't bring up bullet dodging like it's a feat exclusive to batman.

captain america is a veteran of the great war, we're talking dodging machine gun fire, grenades, snipers (guy in a flag costume as a target), tanks, etc.

and cap has actually schooled spider-man.

I'm not saying it's exclusive. The other poster was the one who brought it up and I simply stated that you don't have to dig deep. Many beings can do it.

Captain America schooled Spider-Man?

Everyone knows that outside of a comic book, Spider-Man would stomp either Captain America or Batman. Spider-Man not only holds back against human beings, even peak human beings, but would especially against someone like Captain America. Captain America also has had a chance to study Spider-Man etc.

I can bring up stupid things from Batman too. These two have plenty over the top feats. It's not exclusive to only Captain America.

^ i'm still waiting for the "batman 1000lbs lifting feat before the venom arc" 😗

Originally posted by psycho gundam
^ i'm still waiting for the "batman 1000lbs lifting feat before the venom arc" 😗

You never asked for it. Hold on.

I was looking through my computer and I saved this one from a while back.

I'm disappointed i thought batman never stands down.

He didn't stand down. He and Captain America just realized that fighting each other was pointless.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
He didn't stand down. He and Captain America just realized that fighting each other was pointless.
cap would have kept on going if batman didnt say anything. batman wanted to stop the fight so he was convincing cap for them to let it go. it was batman who quit

Batman is the mentally superior one, so it's evident he would come to the conclusion first that it was pointless.

Captain America agreed as you saw. He knew that they weren't enemies and that they were being played.

Batman didn't stop because he was afraid or anything of the sort. As we saw, he can obviously hold his own.

Batman just sees the bigger picture.

can't use cross-overs anymore.

@ rage. granted, but even if you accept that as fact, he still couldn't budge a lower weight after that. what was the result of that issue?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Batman is the mentally superior one, so it's evident he would come to the conclusion first that it was pointless.

Captain America agreed as you saw. He knew that they weren't enemies and that they were being played.

Batman didn't stop because he was afraid or anything of the sort. As we saw, he can obviously hold his own.

Batman just sees the bigger picture.

that's not the point if he was afraid or not or if they are each others enemies or not. he backed down from the fight. if he didn't say anything it would have kept on going. and even bats said there cap could beat him but the fight would take along time though.