Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Started by Master Court220 pages

For Pete's sake.

Captain America is FAR stronger than Batman.

Without gloves, a boxing punch has the power to break facial bones and even cause severe concussions. If Batman is peak, he can do more than that. Cap, however, is TRUE peak. That's what the SSS does. It didn't just make him really fit, it made him the absolute limit of human potential, something a normal man like Bruce Wayne cannot possibly do. It would require like a 24hour-a-day regime. What about those issues where we see Batman just sitting around the Watchtower staring at monitors? The SSS boosted Cap all the way to true and absolute peak and altered his body in a way as to make it maintainable through regular exercise. So Cap's punch, without holding back, would knock Batman's lights out for good.

As for Batman being "normal", I meant genetically. He's one of my favorite characters; top five. And not just because Superman's afraid of him. Batman is a very phenomenal human being, but genetically normal. No enhancements. So he's not PERFECT.

Keywords here, NO GADGETS. Hand to hand, Batman beating Captain America? That's the most insane notion I've ever heard. And yeah, I've seen Batman even dodge Superman's heat vision before. Same thing as lasers. If I remember right, it even tore some his cape off. That bastard Superman smacked him afterward, but in any case.

Cap has dodged SEVERAL bullets at once as automatic fire coming from multiple shooters at the same damn time. That's impressive even for Spider-Man. Cap has shown to be more accurate and faster than Daredevil. Batman cannot possibly do what Captain America does without his gadgets. Like playing chicken with the Nazi army while they fire thousands of rounds at him. Cap has only ever used his shield, and it's almost always been enough to get the job done.

Batman, without the gadgets, loses... badly....

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
He died was because of the strength dampeners the chainmail did its job and asorbed the impact of the bullets.

no it dident, if the chain mail blocked the bullet he would not be dead. which was the kids point.

In a total Hand to hand fight

Cap would take it 5.5/10

Originally posted by Battlehammer
no it dident, if the chain mail blocked the bullet he would not be dead. which was the kids point.

You're not getting the point. He died because his body was weakned not becuase of chainmail. Y'know you can still get badly injured or even die while wearing a bulletproof vest, put a weak person in a bulletproof vest and he would die if he got shot at point blank range.

Captain america take take this .But it will not be an easy victory.

Batman is peak human in every sense of the word. This makes him captain america's equal. He may not be as strong as the captain but he has shown that you do not need much to work with (actually they both have).

Batman's reflexes may even be better than Capt. I mean he dodge a sniper rifle from the back after it had been shot. He also moved out of deadshot bullets after he had shot it.

This is tie match on one day batman will get the win on another captain will get the win. Batman may never be as strong as the Capt. but he makes it up through other areas.


Originally posted by godking

Batman cannot match match Steve Rodgers in stamina ever . Rodgers Stamina is enhanced bu the SS no builup of lactic acids . Batman ''edge'' in skill which is debatable is not enough to to be a great advantage.

I agree but batman is more skilled; Just like how captain america is more powerful. When these two face each other, these two advantages are null and void.

Originally posted by snoopdogg

[QUOTE]Originally posted by jrodslam To close to call. Ill just say that the longer the fight goes on, the more it goes in Caps favor.

This is the correct answer.[/QUOTE]

I agree

Captain American is far stronger than Batman?

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is peak human in every sense of the word. This makes him captain america's equal. He may not be as strong as the captain but he has shown that you do not need much to work with (actually they both have).

Being "peak human" doesn't automatically make you Cap's equal because Cap's not just "peak human", he's "the pinnacle of human perfection". Bat's physical stats might be close to Steve's, but I'm pretty sure Steve has at least a slight edge in virtually every category.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman's reflexes may even be better than Capt. I mean he dodge a sniper rifle from the back after it had been shot. He also moved out of deadshot bullets after he had shot it.

Cap's crossed the room to block bullet's after they're fired, no way does Batman have better reflexes.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
This is tie match on one day batman will get the win on another captain will get the win. Batman may never be as strong as the Capt. but he makes it up through other areas.

What other areas?

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
I agree but batman is more skilled; Just like how captain america is more powerful. When these two face each other, these two advantages are null and void.

Shang Chi's skill showings are arguably just as impressive as Batman's and Cap's more skilled than Shang. That's not to say that I necessarily think that Steve's more skilled than Bruce(if anything I feel the two are right on par with each other in that department), but you'd be hard pressed to prove the claim that Bruce is superior in H2H skill.

If both had their standard gear they'd split the wins evenly, but H2H Cap should win 8/10.

But Cap is FAR stronger than Bruce. Steve obviously gets 10/10

500pounds = 226kilograms?

For someone being in the gym. 100kg aint much. And Batman is stronger than an average humanbeing? + Fighting skills.. That makes batman far to little weaker to not be dangerous. The only thing that can save Captain america is his agility and endurance.

Originally posted by darthgoober

Being "peak human" doesn't automatically make you Cap's equal because Cap's not just "peak human", he's "the pinnacle of human perfection". Bat's physical stats might be close to Steve's, but I'm pretty sure Steve has at least a slight edge in virtually every category.

Batman is also the pinnacle of human perfection, and he got that way without any drugs. Batman is at the peak of human perfection. You do not like I am sorry but this is what DC says. Take it up with them.

Originally posted by darthgoober

Cap's crossed the room to block bullet's after they're fired, no way does Batman have better reflexes.

Batman dodged a SNIPER bullet that has already been shot. The shot came from behind him.

Originally posted by darthgoober
What other areas?

Well everything except strength.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Shang Chi's skill showings are arguably just as impressive as Batman's and Cap's more skilled than Shang. That's not to say that I necessarily think that Steve's more skilled than Bruce(if anything I feel the two are right on par with each other in that department), but you'd be hard pressed to prove the claim that Bruce is superior in H2H skill.

Well it can be proven; batman can disable a person just by touching them without doing much on his part. Has Capt. Shown anything like this. Yes Capt know’s pressure points but has he ever disabled some just by touching them.

Originally posted by darthgoober
If both had their standard gear they'd split the wins evenly, but H2H Cap should win 8/10.

Standard gear: slight edge to batman wining lets say 6 wins over Capt's 5.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is also the pinnacle of human perfection, and he got that way without any drugs. Batman is at the peak of human perfection. You do not like I am sorry but this is what DC says. Take it up with them.

Originally posted by Warrior18
Nope.

Steve Rogers has been shown to be able to reach speeds of up to 60mph on foot.

He has healed from a gunshot wound to the head after being pronounced dead.

During the civil war he was absolutely battered by Iron Man and was so severely injured his leg was basically fractured in several places from the looks of the scan. He was also badly injured elsewhere on his body. Either way a very very short time after being injured he was practically fully healed and barking orders. Healing factor much? Those injuries would have utterly crippled Batman for at best weeks.

He has stated he can dodge bullets because he "sees faster".

His body simply doesn't produce harmful toxins/lactic acids meaning his muscles will be fine and unaffected even when Batman is tired.

Daredevil, a guy who has strength feats which would make Batman proud, has flat out stated Cap is physically a level above him.

No amount of physical training can bring anyone up to Cap's level since the serum takes no account of genes as it enhances a man to the absolute apex of human physical development. Hell Cap has been described as the next step in human evolution.

Then we have Ed Brubaker stating and showing on panel Cap is not 'Batman with a shield' but something else completely different.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is also the pinnacle of human perfection, and he got that way without any drugs. Batman is at the peak of human perfection. You do not like I am sorry but this is what DC says. Take it up with them.

Proof? There are scans already floating around of Cap being labeled as the pinnacle(I can track down a couple if necessary), but I've never seen any scans labeling Batman as such. Other than you, I don't think I've ever seen any other Batman fans say that he holds that kind of status in DC either...

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman dodged a SNIPER bullet that has already been shot. The shot came from behind him.

Sniper huh, so it was really far away when it was fired right? Was there a speed given for the bullet to make it more impressive than usual? And what did Batman do? Duck, sidestep, or what? Unless he preformed something a bit more complex than a simple dodge I'd say Cap moving across a room to block bullets that have already been fired is a bit more impressive.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Well everything except strength.

Based on what? Do you honestly think Batman's physical feats equal Cap's? Would you like to do a feat for feat comparison?

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Well it can be proven; batman can disable a person just by touching them without doing much on his part. Has Capt. Shown anything like this. Yes Capt know’s pressure points but has he ever disabled some just by touching them.

Yes he has. He's disabled several people with only a touch, including blinding Goliath when he(Cap) was in the aged body of the Red Skull(before Red Skull was in a cloned body of Cap's).

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Standard gear: slight edge to batman wining lets say 6 wins over Capt's 5.

I disagree but to each their own. I still say they split even with standard gear.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is also the pinnacle of human perfection, and he got that way without any drugs. Batman is at the peak of human perfection. You do not like I am sorry but this is what DC says. Take it up with them.

Batman dodged a SNIPER bullet that has already been shot. The shot came from behind him.

Well everything except strength.

Well it can be proven; batman can disable a person just by touching them without doing much on his part. Has Capt. Shown anything like this. Yes Capt know’s pressure points but has he ever disabled some just by touching them.

Standard gear: slight edge to batman wining lets say 6 wins over Capt's 5.

No. Batman is NOT better than Cap in H2H. He's equal on Cap's worse day. Cap was fighting wars before Batman was even born. I mean, I know Batman was created a long time ago, but the character is not seventy or eighty years old. He's only like mid-thirties. Cap's character DID fight in WWII and he fought with his shield and bare hands.

What's more, he's physically P-E-R-F-E-C-T. On a genetic level. Batman cannot and will not ever reach true absolute peak, simply because he's genetically inferior to Captain America. You have to be genetically perfect, to reach physical perfection. Get it?

Cap didn't just work out and eat right. The SSS made him perfect on a genetic level. That's why he's perfect. Batman is just really, really fit. Nothing any other genetically normal guy can't achieve with the same regime. But to hit Cap's heights of perfection, the SSS is the only way to go. Not even Superman is genetically superior. He's not perfect either. Just a standard humanoid alien who, out of sheer luck, was sent to Earth and got enormous superhuman powers from our sun.

And calling it a drug(while technically accurate), you have to keep in mind it was an experimental serum. Steve volunteered to take it only knowing what it was suppose to do, not what it WOULD do. But he wanted to serve his country. His courage and valor earned him the reward he got. Not to mention he was only a college kid when he volunteered. College kids can't reach Batman level fitness. It's been medically shown that people don't finally stop developing until mid-twenties. And before he even took the serum, he went through combat training, and he was selected based on performance. That means he was at least a military-grade combatant BEFORE the serum. And THEN he was given the SSS, which enhanced every last part of him to physical perfection.

Batman's feats have not at all outmatched Cap's. Many are lower. Great, Batman dodged a sniper bullet. I'm aware of the physics involved and that it was a good feat(depending on the distance of the shot) for a genetically normal human. However, Cap, again, has dodged countless bullets from numerous shooters firing fully automatic weapons at close range. And usually not being hit. And he does this while charging TOWARDS the shooters, and then beats the shit out of them. When he is hit, he shrugs it off.

Batman gets hit, which he has before, he drops, or slows down. Once, the cops shot him in the leg, he struggled to get up a set of stairs to reach the roof. He gets injured like any other normal man. This means either Cap is much more durable, which is likely considering he's physically superior in every way, or Cap has more resolve. I don't want to bash the heart of either character, so we can say their resolve is equal. After all, I recall Batman ignoring the bullet wound, meaning it didn't mentally slow him down. But Cap has never been slowed down in any way by a bullet that didn't kill him. And he's never been crippled, even after being hit by opponents like the Hulk or Iron Man. A little breather, and he's up and at it again.

Batman, without the gadgets, it outclassed in every way. Batman's cunning often requires his gadgets, and that's where he shines. And guys Batman has beaten up without the gadgets would be just as easily(or more easily) beaten by Cap.

Bare naked with nothing but boxers and briefs, Cap wins 10/10.
Standard gear and anything goes, Cap wins 6-7/10.

Cap isn't 70 or 80.

He was frozen for about 30 years.

Wrong Superman is the cream of the crop it was stated on panel 🙂

Yeah Batmans usual suits are bulletproof he dodges the bullets for the lulz

Cap catches the bullets in his teeth.

Batman deflects them with the batstick 😬