Originally posted by Sin Harvest
Alright first, don't post four times in a row.
F*ck you. If there are that many comments for me to reply to when I return to a forum, then I will reply to them accordingly. I don't see a moderator flag under your name, so tell it to someone who gives a damn.
Originally posted by Sin Harvest
Second the ROTS novelization isn't cannon because a lot contradicts the movies which is the ultimate form of cannon.
I agree, the novelization is not as canon as the movie, but, EU fanboys are keen to point out that when it is filling in or providing information not in the movie (so it can't be contradictory) then it is valid. There was nothing in the movie that suggested that Dooku was testing Anakin (although the whole 'throne room' was hardly a jailcell, but clearly an observation area, so that in itself is telling that something was not quite as it seemed) therefor, the novelization's view that Dooku was under orders (something I'm only going on what others have said, I haven't read the novelization) not to kill Anakin is a valid one (and can be backed up by Dooku's 'test duel' with Assaj, which was for Palpatine's benefit)
Originally posted by Sin Harvest
Anakin defeated Dooku fair and square
He did not. When you are dueling someone, you are supposed to be fighting them with a bladed weapon. It is not honorable to grab a person's weapon arm to imobilize their weapon so you can then use your own weapon against them. The end result of the duel was this: A 23 year old guy physically overpowered an old man in his 80s. Is that fair and square? Is beheading an unarmed (literally) and defensive prisoner honorable or fair and square? I thought not.
Originally posted by Sin Harvest
meaning Anakin is better then Dooku. Not a hard one to figure out.
Anakin is physically stronger than Dooku (not a hard one to figure out given their ages) That does not mean he is a better sword fighter, because he was not. Dooku cut Anakin's arm off while they were 'crossing blades', Anakin had to resort to grabbing Dooku and imobilizing his lightsaber to cut off his hands, and none of his swings (even when he lost his temper) touched Dooku, so he is clearly not as good a swordsman as the Count.
[Edit for SPAG]