Silver Surfer vs Doomsday

Started by MrMind51 pages

if surfer has opened a black hole on anyone during battle in comics

I will concede right here

Originally posted by h1a8
What's the likelihood of Surfer opening up a black hole on DD?
If he does then I guess he could win.
But it doesn't seem likely he would do that.

If anyone disagrees then they have to accept Surfer beating Thanos, Odin, etc that way.

Things have changed on the forum. If a character is capable of achieving something, then it can be used in battle. Surfer can create black holes. He stomps this.

I mean tbf he started that with "things have changed on this forum." And also tbf when he created the black hole, wasn't he like fleeing/rescuing? That's kind of like a battle he just chose flight over fight

Originally posted by carver9
Things have changed on the forum. If a character is capable of achieving something, then it can be used in battle. Surfer can create black holes. He stomps this.

Then DD stomps.

Faster than Flash 😈

Hyperbole. He obviously isnt faster than Flash unless you have fts.

Originally posted by carver9
Hyperbole. He obviously isnt faster than Flash unless you have fts.

He has the feats of not just fighting, but killing Superman, who specifically commented on his speed. Thanks.

Originally posted by carver9
Things have changed on the forum. If a character is capable of achieving something, then it can be used in battle. Surfer can create black holes. He stomps this.

If he can do a million things then how do you know he will think of that?
That's assuming he could even do that.

Originally posted by MrMind
if surfer has opened a black hole on anyone during battle in comics

I will concede right here

Put it this way.

Who wins, a guy with a gun, or a guy with a Swiss Army knife? I mean sure, Carv is right, Surfer is way more versatile, just like knife guy is way more versatile.

Doesn't mean anything when the gun is pointed at you.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Put it this way.

Who wins, a guy with a gun, or a guy with a Swiss Army knife? I mean sure, Carv is right, Surfer is way more versatile, just like knife guy is way more versatile.

Doesn't mean anything when the gun is pointed at you.

You mean depending on the starting distance and whether the gun is in its holster the knife user can have a distinctive advantage.

I guess that what you are trying to say here is that if Silver Surfer goes melee quick enough DD is phucked

Originally posted by Bentley
You mean depending on the starting distance and whether the gun is in its holster the knife user can have a distinctive advantage.

I guess that what you are trying to say here is that if Silver Surfer goes melee quick enough DD is phucked

500m starting distance, when the thread starter doesn't specify.

No, you can't trip me up that easily 😈

Assume of course that both combatants know how to use their weapons. THAT is the loophole you should have tried to go for, before I addressed it and closed it up.

But if you think a knife user (note, you haven't assumed it's in a pocket etc....Bias already showing!) Can cover 500m before a trained gunman can draw and fire....🙂

wasnt surfer just owned by a black hole? why in the **** would he use one here?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
He has the feats of not just fighting, but killing Superman, who specifically commented on his speed. Thanks.

So killing Superman is the key to having Flash like speed? Tred carefully with that question. Also, Superman did comment on his speed but he commented on other people speed around the same era that isnt anywhere close to Surfer level or Flash level speeds.

🙂

Originally posted by MrMind

He doesnt need to "in comics". You must've haven't seen the arguments going on throughout KMC as of late? Stay on track.

Originally posted by DeadpoolXXX
wasnt surfer just owned by a black hole? why in the **** would he use one here?

Are you talking about the Black Hole that he was in FOR YEARS? Yep, that did do some damage. I'm assuming Surfer isnt just going to stand inside of the black hole he created for yrs. Especially with him being able to, ya know, fly. Hell, he has even amped off of black holes before.

So surfer is going to do something he never done in battle before just cause. In theory Doomsday never die and will evolve from every attacks. This argument doesn't really work in your favor carv

Originally posted by MrMind
So surfer is going to do something he never done in battle before just cause. In theory Doomsday never die and will evolve from every attacks. This argument doesn't really work in your favor carv

Post one scan of him adapting in DOS. One. Also, what's the most powerful attack he has adapted too? Remember, he died via a punch but after his death, he was still getting blood punched out of his mouth. Physical attacks were still harming him.

Originally posted by carver9
Post one scan of him adapting in DOS. One. Also, what's the most powerful attack he has adapted too? Remember, he died via a punch but after his death, he was still getting blood punched out of his mouth. Physical attacks were still harming him.
Originally posted by carver9
He doesnt need to "in comics". You must've haven't seen the arguments going on throughout KMC as of late? Stay on track.

carver, the full capacity rule Pr spelled out for you a while back doesn't entail you just making up random, esoteric abilities that a character has never once used during a battle in their entire character history... and pretending like said ability will be their initial go-to tactic in a versus thread.