Proof that the compass pointing to Will in Jacks direction is a fake!

I have captured some screen caps at the beach scene where it proofs that this whole bolony story of the compass poiting at will in jacks direction is all caca.

Supposedly, Mr Ted said that the camera was blocking(right) and that Where Jack was standing its where Will was standing...uh right. Ted is not that stupid to make a bull poop(not cursing!) story like that. fake-made up crap*cough*kttc*cough*

so like the first time the compass pointed to jack will was also standing in that direction-that exact spot where jack was..some miracle eh? We werent born 5 minutes ago.

well here are some proof.

^^in this scene we can see where jack is standing, on the grass.

points to jack

Compass dont lie...watch again where Jack is standing.

hold on theres more lol

EDIT - crap sorry chiki I thought you had finished with the post 😂

LOL and davy/dutchman/Will is in FRONT! of her to the north west at that moment!! 😂

BEHIND THE HUGE BLOCKING! right near where they left Pintell and Ragetti to look after the boat which was on the opposite end of the isle

we are shown this right after she says "it doesnt show you what you want most" that shot clarifies to the audience that she wants Jack most out of the 2 men because Davy/Will/dutchman is no where near where Jack is standing when it points to him.

Will is in front (N/W) on the dutchman hiding behind the massive blocking

Jack is S/W and it clearly points S/W

here is what was posted by "ted" or "terry" I dont know which:

"If you watch the blocking in the scene on the beach before Elizabeth says the compass doesn't work and doesn't show you what you want (and the blocking immediately after), you'll know something that Elizabeth doesn't."

I studied the whole scene and the little tiny sand dune Jack was standing on right after she says that line?? I learn NOTHING that she doesnt know about

but then it cuts to the huge blocking located in the opposite direction of where the compass pointed, we learn the dutchman/Will is hiding behind it. and Liz didnt see it and she cant see it...her compass is telling her she wants Jack and its JACK not Will who she wants most.

both men are present and it points slap bang at Jack..actually all 3 men are present

AGAIN watch closely

captain eunich will appear any moment like in 40 mins tops

uhg! bloody eunich is here!

hmmm...thats interesting...

jack looks like hes about to barf lol

If you'd like to call Ted a liar, then by all means do so. Better do it to his face though, since talking behind someone's back is rude.

Apparently, Ted's belief is that the compass is pointing at Will, which I find extremely interesting. Besides, we don't know exactly where Will got off the ship (I somehow doubt he waited until the ship went underwater to get off. Probably as soon as they came in view of the island he was in the water, swimming away from the ship), so when the compass 'points' at Jack, it could actually be pointing at Will.

Also, when she's wandering around on the beach, looking for the chest, and the compass keeps swinging around, she actually heads in the direction that Will appears from before she turns back around.

The compass still worked to find the chest. She just misread what the compass said. She thought it pointed at Jack, it was actually pointing at the chest.

Sorry, guys, but nice try. Will and Elizabeth are in love, and will probably get married. If Will does end up dying (though I've seen nothing that supports that truth except a nasty magazine article that looks rather suspicious), I somehow doubt that Elizabeth is just going to fall into Jack's arms.

She has a better chance of ending up with Norrington than she does with Jack. Just because Jack and Elizabeth look nice together doesn't mean that they should or will end up together.

Everything that you point out as being a J/E moment (Oh look, the sky is blue!!!) can be easily and logically explained away. The ONLY way YOUR ship works is if Will dies or suddenly vanishes. That fact alone should tell you that your ship has more holes in it than swiss cheese.

Normally I wouldn't get this riled over J/E shipping. I can debate politely with anyone, given the opportunity. You can even call me any name that you like, but when you DARE to insult the WRITER of this film and try to pass off his opinion as LIE because it intrudes on your false little dream of a ship...That is IT.

You have absolutely NO BUSINESS calling Ted a liar just because you don't like what he said. Nor should you ever, EVER call someone's ideas crap. People are allowed to write or believe what they want about the movie, and until it comes out, you are just going to have accept it. You can debate all you want, but NOT LIKE THAT.

Got it?

All I can say is Lets see who's going to have the last laugh.
We based ourselves on facts. Not just visual concept. We use our intelligence to decipher the meaning of things. There are reasons why the writers use meanings and symbolisms on their movies thats the magic of it. Thats why they are such great writers. I don't see no one insulting them or calling the writers liers. You are putting words in to other peoples mouths. The writers didn't specifically say that the compass was pointing to the eunuch. That is why they use symbolisms, because is up to us the viewers to decipher them. Oh and the writers wouldn't put pointless scenes in the movie. Each and every one of the scenes has a meaning. Writing is more than making up a story. Thats why the writer are such smart people. They used a lot of symbolisms in both POTC movies. You would have to be blind or dumb to not see what was going on. Therefore all I can say is that I rest my case. And on May 27 2007, we will see what ship is gonna still be afloat. So I suggest for you to take it easy, calm down you sound a bit tense. And start opening your mind to possibilities 😄

Im curious who it is you think is going to have the last laugh?

Originally posted by Pirates life fo
Im curious who it is you think is going to have the last laugh?

Do I have to tell you? 😄

I thought it was May 25th 😕

Originally posted by evilm0nki3
I thought it was May 25th 😕

ok it is May 25. I was close though

Oh, I do have a correction in my quote from Ted...

I had saved it from a conversation with someone, who quoted it to me, and the last paragraph actually shouldn't be there. I honestly should not try to post when I have a fever. At any rate, I apologize to Ted, my friend, and anyone else who read the quote.

However, the argument still stands that the WRITER of the film says we would learn something Elizabeth doesn't already know. She already knows that she's feeling attracted to Jack, so it must be something else.

I still apologize for the confusion, however. Thank you for bearing with me and my poor feverish mind. 😉

And all I have to say to you, Misty, is that if the writer himself indicates that W/E is the likely ending, then maybe, just maybe you need to rethink your theory.

The point is, sometimes a canon is just a canon in PotC. Not everything is secretly all about J/E. It isn't, it isn't and it isn't. The fact that you have to over-analyse everything and to put meaning into absolutely smacks of absolute and complete desperation to prove that your ship is right.

I'm not calling your ideas stupid, but I do think that they are misguided and not based entirely on the truth, but more on a desire on what you want to see, as opposed to what actually IS.

I believe In Jack and Liz😄 lol

I still stick to my ship that no one will end up with Liz. Or maybe the monkey will. I should start a monkey/Liz thread

lol I like the monkey, hes a cutie!

I went to KttC to see what the big deal was. There are as many Jack/Liz people as there are here. It just seems like there are so many Will/Liz because they have 10 times the number of people. There ideas are as well thought out as everyone's here are. They also have insiders with friends on set and access to casting info.

Aside from the occassional moment when someone has a bad day, KTTC is actually a rather calm place to be, and the people there are great to debate with and to discuss things with.

So are the people here...they're just a bit more...passionate and blunt than those at KTTC. It's one of the reasons I came here, so I could be a bit more blunt in my arguments, and because I think it's a fun forum.

Actually, Liz with no one would suit me just fine...It'd be good, actually, for the female to toss off the bonds of love and to just go do her own thing, but I think W/E will end up together.

Though, I won't cry if J/E end up together...I just fail to see, in this time and moment, how it could possibly happen.

I could care less who she ends up with as long as its an entertaing movie. I just dont see the character of Jack Sparrow settling down with a rail thin, young woman. It just doesnt seem to be his style. Is he attracted to her? Maybe he is. Is she attracted to him? Perhaps. Just because there is an attraction doesnt make it a sure thing.

The point is, sometimes a canon is just a canon in PotC. Not everything is secretly all about J/E. It isn't, it isn't and it isn't. The fact that you have to over-analyse everything and to put meaning into absolutely smacks of absolute and complete desperation to prove that your ship is right.

I'm not calling your ideas stupid, but I do think that they are misguided and not based entirely on the truth, but more on a desire on what you want to see, as opposed to what actually IS.

Oops you are misunderstanding me. Didn't I explained myself, I thought I did. Oh well here I go again. I didn't say that they used double meanings in the entire movie. I understand, that a palm tree with coconuts, it's just a palm tree with coconuts. What I'm saying is that the writers use symbolisms in order to create a good and likable movie
:coughs: I billion. Again thats the magic of movie making. There are reason why they use it. And all I'm saying is, that they wouldn't put pointless scenes in it. I am not desperate to prove anything I just go by facts. I didn't have to over analyzed anything I just saw the movie once. I wasn't even a J/E shipper. But some people are just blinded that they can't even see pass their noses. In fact my "ideas" aren't just ideas, they are pretty much facts. And thats the magic of movie making.

So its a fact that Jack and Liz will end up together then?

Originally posted by Pirates life fo
So its a fact that Jack and Liz will end up together then?

I was just saying that the writers use symbolisms in order to create movies. And that is very much fact. Film studies classes are given in college, if you are a college student ask around, they'll tell you about it. Or better ask lovely she is a member of this forum, she is a films studies student. The college that i go to offered that degree. So I was only talking about that. I don't know if they will end up together or not. It looks that way, or all of those scenes would be pointless and meaningless.

I know what symbolism is. And if Jack and Liz dont end up together it doesnt make scenes from DMC pointless. Like I have been saying all along. Wait until 3 comes out and we see what how it's written. It will all make sense regardless of who ends up with who.