Originally posted by nvrbeenwthagirl
You do realize that each Imprint is a seperate a multiverse unto themselves as well as being connected to each other.
But then Heaven and Hell exist outside the constraints of such definitions as universe and multiverse. And Heaven and Hell no longer exist as per Lucifer, which is turn tied to Sandman
In 1995 I would have agreed that it is canon, but Vertigo comics imprint had taken such a change that it nearly alienated itself completely from DC canon.
Vertigo comics is an imprint where writers can ignore DC canon material. And do not follow the guidelines of DC comics. It's non-canon merely by nature. It's just a collection of good stories more or less. Even ones written long before it's inception were moved to the imprint and mostly disregarded by continuity...
Hell....It doesn't even have a canon to itself. Preacher, Lucifer, Testament, Pride of Bhagdad among everything else all appear in different self contained stories.
It was originally created as a place where more mature books would go, but with more mature books, such as Spectre volume 3[freaturing heavy violence, lots of blood, and even nudity.], and others appearing in DC continuity, it becomes clearer that they are merely alienating these books from the DC canon.
The appearances of Vertigo characters in DC comics, and vice versa appear more as simple Crossovers than anything else.
The only one that could even remotely be included is Sandman, as references in Green Arrow current run number 9, flashes back to Sandman 1. And in Justice League of America 154, the JLA battled Dr Destiny with Morpheus' gem, however in contunuity this could never have happened in 1988 as said in Sandman.[Which is the date given]
Yet, Morpheus' imprisonment is mentioned in the timeline in the back of Zero Hour.
Giving the idea that it does indeed take place in the DCU.
However, Lucifer is the same Lucifer from Sandman.
"Out of the pages of Sandman" it says on the very first issue.
Then a lot of events happen in Lucifer, that do not happen in DC continuity at all. - Such as Elaine taking over for God, and getting rid of Heaven and Hell and merging multiple creations, and demons and men and angels walking hand in hand down the streets.
Stuff like this is why, unless it has a DC logo, it shouldn't really be considered part of DC's canon.