Midnighter vs Daredevil

Who wins?

"I've already played this fight out a thousand times in my mind from every possible angle. You were beaten before you even came here."

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
"I've already played this fight out a thousand times in my mind from every possible angle. You were beaten before you even came here."

Originally posted by juggernaut66666
"million" not "thousand". 😛

after reading midnighters bio, this seems abit lopsided

poor dd 🙁

although

DD's combat "precog" seems like it might equalize midnighters extremely useless mass-calculations here

Hm...common knowledge about the character would not give Midnighter info on Daredevil's radar sense.

Thus, Midnighter would play out a million different scenarios, but they'd all be flawed since he'd be lacking a very important piece of information--DD's radar sense.

After careful consideration, I think I'm going to give this fight to Daredevil.

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Hm...common knowledge about the character would not give Midnighter info on Daredevil's radar sense.

Thus, Midnighter would play out a million different scenarios, but they'd all be flawed since he'd be lacking a very important piece of information--DD's radar sense.

After careful consideration, I think I'm going to give this fight to Daredevil.

🙄

Midnighter, although his ability to calculate "a million possibilities before the fight begins" is just a stupid PIS ability which Im not too fond of, but he's still cool.

Midnighter, he's prob faster then DD could physically avoid (sure he might see it, but he can't always dodge it)

Originally posted by boriquaking55
Midnighter, although his ability to calculate "a million possibilities before the fight begins" is just a stupid PIS ability which Im not too fond of, but he's still cool.

It has to do with his combat implants, which allow him to see upgrades in others as well as run combat scenarios, millions per second.

So no, it's not just a PIS power that he magically does....it has a logical backing.

Originally posted by DigiMark007
It has to do with his combat implants, which allow him to see upgrades in others as well as run combat scenarios, millions per second.

So no, it's not just a PIS power that he magically does....it has a logical backing.

even with the implants it seems silly

Originally posted by boriquaking55
even with the implants it seems silly

Fair enough. Hearing well enough to see better than regular humans seems silli-er to me, but to each his own.

😉

Walking around with a magical hammer and carefully trimmed goldilocks spouting out Olde-English threats and swears is silliest.

I win. 😐

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Hm...common knowledge about the character would not give Midnighter info on Daredevil's radar sense.

Thus, Midnighter would play out a million different scenarios, but they'd all be flawed since he'd be lacking a very important piece of information--DD's radar sense.

After careful consideration, I think I'm going to give this fight to Daredevil.

im starting to think about it more

and im starting to agre with you

plus
how could i betray my dear daredevil?

Originally posted by Soljer
🙄

Oh come on, Soljer. Don't give me that. Debate with me. Convince me otherwise.

I'm not convinced that Midnighter could counter DD's radar sense--ESPECIALLY when he doesn't know about it beforehand.

Originally posted by ExtraMision5555
im starting to think about it more

and im starting to agre with you

plus
how could i betray my dear daredevil?

I mean, it does make sense, doesn't it?

Originally posted by DigiMark007
Fair enough. Hearing well enough to see better than regular humans seems silli-er to me, but to each his own.

😉

well that has some basis in RL, I guess it works like bat's radar

Originally posted by Metalmanx
I mean, it does make sense, doesn't it?

it does

becuase any calculation he could make about his attacks could be countered just as easily by DD
seeing how he has extra sensory preseption of movements

Originally posted by Metalmanx
Oh come on, Soljer. Don't give me that. Debate with me. Convince me otherwise.

I'm not convinced that Midnighter could counter DD's radar sense--ESPECIALLY when he doesn't know about it beforehand.

I don't think Midnighter would HAVE to counter Daredevils' radar sense. That's not how the 'combat scenario' works. He views every possible move, and then every possible counter, and then every possible counter to every possible counter, and then....

The fact that Daredevil uses a radar sense doesn't come into play.

Especially when you consider that the Midnighter is quite a bit faster and stronger than Matt.

The only reason I rolled my eyes is because, honestly, I've seen you give a heavy favoritism to Daredevil on more than one occasion.

😬. As far as the actual fight goes, Midnighter should be the clear winner.

Originally posted by Soljer
I don't think Midnighter would HAVE to counter Daredevils' radar sense. That's not how the 'combat scenario' works. He views every possible move, and then every possible counter, and then every possible counter to every possible counter, and then....

The fact that Daredevil uses a radar sense doesn't come into play.

Especially when you consider that the Midnighter is quite a bit faster and stronger than Matt.

😬. As far as the actual fight goes, Midnighter should be the clear winner.