Anakin (ROTS) v. Sidious (ROTS)

Started by Lightsnake10 pages


A considerable feat which we have next to zero details about. And Count Dooku is an old aristocrat. But he also happens to be Mr. Lee, and a total badass. Nick Gillard is a raving fanboy.

We have quite a bit more other than that on Cin besides Nick...moreover, we have more than a bit on the fight with Cin. In fact, we do have all the details.


Well, going by the novel and videogame. . . meh, I'll go along. Jurokk, being the gatekeeper, got stabbed in the face without so much as grabbing his lightsaber. So, Anakin gets no credit for that whatsoever.

You mean stabbing him before he could get his lightsaber?
And Jocasta Nu? The librarian who probably hasn't seen combat since before TPM? Yeah, right.

A former council member described as a skilled master, ready to fight to save the younglings? Come on, now...

I fail to see how this compares with Dooku's considerable list of accomplishments that are actually related to his skill in the Force; in case you hadn't noticed, none of your examples show any remarkable skill on his part whatsoever.

He lifts Jocasta up in the air with the Force, immobilizing her completely and runs her through. I think the Force plays a BIT of a part....and not to mention the Durge fight..

Again, I've already stated that I believe Anakin to have more power available to him than Dooku. However, it's very clear that he does not come close to having the considerable degree of control and mastery that the Count displays. Hell, Obi-Wan has greater mastery over the Force than Anakin, and he managed to get his ass stomped by Dooku's Force prowess.

Obi-wan was unable to so much as budge Durge with the Force-in fact, very few Jedi ever could. Anakin is able to control Durge with the Force, throw Durge across the room with the Force and using the Force, directs a pod into the sun.
Does he have the same control Dooku does? No. I fail to see how this'll matter if Anakin unleashes it fully on one person.

Okay, so he kills a librarian before she can respond and he out fights someone else. Again, no bearing on his Force power whatsoever. Regarding the O66 article, care to link it or post passages?

For starters, Nu is an ex-council member and described as a skilled Jedi, with a reason to give her all-saving children.
Passages, this from mostly memory:


Which is all I'm actually trying to debate here, as I've made very clear numerous times already. . .

Where is this? I remember him tossing mines at Durge to cripple him, allowing him to fall into an escape pod, and then launch the thing and nudge into a path that would lead to the sun - but I don't remember the "mind control" part. And really, you act as if knocking an object into a certain path in zero gravity is a considerable feat.


I consider forcing a large object off a course into a sun as certainly pretty impressive....in the comic, we see Anakin, concentrating, hands outstretched as he diverts the pod....also, Durge is NOT put out of commission by the mines...it melts his voicebox and blows off his helmet, but Anakin ends up having to fight him on a very physical scale and forces him in the pod with the force...Obsession #3 for reference.

No, I'm not trying to downplay him at all. I even stated that he had one really good move on Dooku when he severed his hands, at that was through skill. But the part that everyone seems to hail as proof for his undeniable superiority is when he drives him back. In the novel, this is "zoMg anikin nox litesbr in2 shulde w/ strngth?!!" In the movie, it's represented in a much better fashion. And honestly, I don't see Anakin beating Dooku in a serious confrontation - the Count has dueling skills that at least rival those of Anakin, but more importantly he has vastly superior Force prowess to call on. And if he's not high on martini-inspired arrogance like he was in RotS, he could very likely win.

The thing is, at the end, that was a serious confrontation. According to the New Essential Chronology and Visual Guide, Dooku at the end of the fight once Anakin goes overboard, feels his real power and is forced to fight for his life.
If Anakin goes out on Dooku like that, Dooku will lose more often than not.

The fact is, Anakin's saber style focuses on power and Anakin used that to defeat Dooku's Makashi. Fact is, that's using your advantage to overcome an opponent's disadvantage and that made Anakin better in that instance...

While Anakin lacks Dooku's fine control over his power, he's still got it in abundance and directed fully upon Dooku, the result could be very bad for the Count. You also can't remove the arrogance from Dooku so easily, given Dooku's very nature.

The only thing I'm disputing is the claim that Anakin has superior Force abilities when compared to the likes of Dooku or Sidious.

No one is suggesting that Anakin > Dooku in Force prowess as of Revenge of the Sith, let alone the Emperor. At most, we've said that Lucas implied in that one interview that Anakin's strength was equal to Palpatine's as of RotS; if he's equal to Palpatine, he's better than Dooku (and by quite a bit), and there's no disputing it.

But that's a big if.

The only thing I'll argue is lightsaber prowess.

Edit: By the way, Lightsnake is correct. The script, the novelization, the Visual Guide, and the New Essential Chronology state that Anakin's victory over Dooku was a legitimate one. He simply became a force that Dooku just literally could not stop at that point.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
We have quite a bit more other than that on Cin besides Nick...moreover, we have more than a bit on the fight with Cin. In fact, we do have all the details.
Would you like to provide some?

You mean stabbing him before he could get his lightsaber?
The guy wasn't expecting a fight, as was evidenced by his actually greeting Anakin. He just opened the gate, and Anakin stabbed him. Impressive.

a former council member described as a skilled master, ready to fight to save the younglings? Come on, now...
And the fact that she - the one who hasn't seen combat in 13+ years - is probably one of the better Jedi in the Temple at the time of the Purge speaks for the complete lack of resistance faced by Anakin and the clones.

He lifts Jocasta up in the air with the Force, immobilizing her completely and runs her through. I think the Force plays a BIT of a part....and not to mention the Durge fight..
I've played the game, LS. He just picks her up and pulls her onto his saber.

Obi-wan was unable to so much as budge Durge with the Force-in fact, very few Jedi ever could.
I don't remember any Jedi ever trying. He's had things thrown at him, but that's it.

Anakin is able to control Durge with the Force, throw Durge across the room with the Force and using the Force, directs a pod into the sun.
The first two of which you have yet to provide evidence for, and third being of little importance. It's zero gravity, LS, and not that big of an escape pod.

Does he have the same control Dooku does? No. I fail to see how this'll matter if Anakin unleashes it fully on one person.
Oh, you mean like he did on Obi-Wan.

I consider forcing a large object off a course into a sun as certainly pretty impressive....in the comic, we see Anakin, concentrating, hands outstretched as he diverts the pod....
The escape pod isn't that big, and again, it's not like there's any, you know, gravity affecting the thing. Unlike Yoda, who deflected a missile falling at thousands of miles per hour. In atmosphere. After dueling Dooku. That is impressive.

also, Durge is NOT put out of commission by the mines...it melts his voicebox and blows off his helmet, but Anakin ends up having to fight him on a very physical scale and forces him in the pod with the force...Obsession #3 for reference.
So he Force pushes a non-Force sensitive? Damn. I guess Dooku taking out Sora Bulq - you know, the Vaapad co-creator - with his lightning and immediately dropping a ceiling on Thome's head counts for nothing.

If Anakin goes out on Dooku like that, Dooku will lose more often than not.
Unless Dooku just decides to do what he did to Obi-Wan. . .

The fact is, Anakin's saber style focuses on power and Anakin used that to defeat Dooku's Makashi. Fact is, that's using your advantage to overcome an opponent's disadvantage and that made Anakin better in that instance...
Then I suppose Obi-Wan is better in his duel with Anakin because of the exact same reasons. So if this logic implies that Anakin is better than Dooku, it makes Obi-Wan better than Anakin.

While Anakin lacks Dooku's fine control over his power, he's still got it in abundance and directed fully upon Dooku, the result could be very bad for the Count.
I seem to clearly remember him doing just that to Obi-Wan, and still getting put on his ass. The same Obi-Wan who got tossed around like a ragdoll and couldn't do anything about it. No, Count Dooku can actually manage to successfully direct all of his considerable power at his opponents. Anakin, obviously, can't.

Fantastic, Faunus. You really beat me to the punch. Well said.

I will say that Cin is said to be a bit of a badass.

Meh. I hate Gillard with a burning passion. Ray Park all the way!

I don't see the argument. As of ROTS, Dooku has more control and mastery over the force than Anakin, while Anakin has the raw abilities on his side. However, those abilities are meaningless against someone as experienced as Dooku, and he will almost always lose in a force battle. Now as of ANH, he is superior to Dooku because not only has he mastered the force and gained control, but he's had 20 extra years to study the dark side. This isn't a debate really. Dooku>Anakin as of ROTS.

Originally posted by Faunus
Meh. I hate Gillard with a burning passion. Ray Park all the way!

Lmao.

In Labyrinth of Evil, Count Dooku listed upper-tier Jedi that, in a duel, would make him pity General Grievous (he was listing Jedi who would essentially kick the General's ass).

The same General Grievous that Count Dooku mentions is more dangerous than Ventress in Dark Rendezvous, the same General Grievous who soundly defeated Ventress and Durge simultaneously, and - most especially - the same General Grievous that Dooku admitted he was hard-pressed to defeat.

So we conceivably have a guy who is on par with Obi-Wan in skill, who would defeat Grievous, and potentially make Dooku work for his victory.

And Anakin curbstomped him. I sincerely believe you all underestimate his raw power. In the context of a lightsaber fight, it really would go a long way.

Originally posted by Faunus
Would you like to provide some?

Certainly: The visual dictionary mentions Cin as an extremely formidable Jedi Master and an exceptional duelist, who's mastered the first sixth forms. He's the Battlemaster of the Jedi Temple, and I believe Dooku held him in very high esteem-enough to mention him as one of the Order's best...

In the fight with Cin, Whie and Bene: Anakin starts by killing Whie instantly and engages Cin while force choking Bene. Cin is described as being 'no match' for Anakin despite 'formidable skills' and Anakin slices through his shoulder and watches him die.

[quote]
The guy wasn't expecting a fight, as was evidenced by his actually greeting Anakin. He just opened the gate, and Anakin stabbed him. Impressive.


They do have a conversation before hand and Anakin kills him before he can react. that should count for something
[Quote]
And the fact that she - the one who hasn't seen combat in 13+ years - is probably one of the better Jedi in the Temple at the time of the Purge speaks for the complete lack of resistance faced by Anakin and the clones.

I've played the game, LS. He just picks her up and pulls her onto his saber.


I haven't played the game, personally, so I'm going on a bit of hearsay, but shouldn't that Anakin lifts up Jocasta and spears her on the spot be a bit of a nod to him in regards to power? The woman is described as a formidable Jedi, after all.

I don't remember any Jedi ever trying. He's had things thrown at him, but that's it.

In Durge's first appearance, he laughs off an attempt in a Mind Trick, and Obi-wan and Glaive can't budge him with the Force...he just laughs "Like THAT'S never happened before!"
I can't recall the exact 2, but the collection it's in is CW vol. 2

The first two of which you have yet to provide evidence for, and third being of little importance. It's zero gravity, LS, and not that big of an escape pod.

I'm not seeing the relevance to the gravity there, especially considering we've seen others fail and strain to move things in space.

And I sourced the first two, thank you. Obsession issue 3. SWtimeline is down, so I can't get any pics from it.


Oh, you mean like he did on Obi-Wan.

I mean the power that made Dooku realize he was a dead man, actually. You can't deny Dooku felt Anakin's power with the Force and realized he couldn't stand to it.

The escape pod isn't that big, and again, it's not like there's any, you know, gravity affecting the thing. Unlike Yoda, who deflected a missile falling at thousands of miles per hour. In atmosphere. After dueling Dooku. That is impressive.

Would I ever deny Yoda's a very impressive guy? Heck no. Moreover, an escape pod's about as big as your average star craft and you're still guiding it from course all the way to the sun? And again: considering we've seen people fail to affect things already in space, I don't see how the authors giving much thought to the gravity issue

So he Force pushes a non-Force sensitive? Damn. I guess Dooku taking out Sora Bulq - you know, the Vaapad co-creator - with his lightning and immediately dropping a ceiling on Thome's head counts for nothing.

Quit downplaying things.
We've seen two Jedi try at the same time to Force push Durge and he only rocked back on his heels, laughing. Anakin focuses and Durge is hurled across the room. Durge isn't just another non Force sensitive, he's been killing Jedi for about two thousand years and killed both Jedi and Sith during the Great War. He's not a feather weight

Unless Dooku just decides to do what he did to Obi-Wan. . .

Which, I'm sure, will work without a hitch on Anakin.
If Dooku could do that as easily on Anakin, it's very doubtful he'd have died

Then I suppose Obi-Wan is better in his duel with Anakin because of the exact same reasons. So if this logic implies that Anakin is better than Dooku, it makes Obi-Wan better than Anakin.

Or we look at how fighting works and conclude that such properties are faulty due to the nature of the duels, environments, mindsets and the like.
The factor is? Anakin loses to Obi-wan because he makes an arrogant mistake in that duel. Dooku loses to Anakin because Anakin out fights him. Simple enough. There is nothing hinting Anakin did not defeat Dooku legitimately throughout SW lore.

I seem to clearly remember him doing just that to Obi-Wan, and still getting put on his ass. The same Obi-Wan who got tossed around like a ragdoll and couldn't do anything about it. No, Count Dooku can actually manage to successfully direct all of his considerable power at his opponents. Anakin, obviously, can't.

The same Count Dooku who realizes nothing he does against Anakin will be of any use? Same Count Dooku who realizes Anakin is more powerful than he imagined and that when Anakin has decided to kill Dooku the rest is detail?
OH, and you'll have to remind me: Who's hit harder during the force push duel? Anakin is certainly the one who finds his feet first.

OK I'm confused. So Obiwan couldn't force push Durge, but Grievous was more powerful than Durge, and yet Obiwan wtfpwned Grievous with a force push. Man, I love the inconsistencies. GL needs to stop rolling around in his cash and start filling in the blanks.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
OK I'm confused. So Obiwan couldn't force push Durge, but Grievous was more powerful than Durge, and yet Obiwan wtfpwned Grievous with a force push. Man, I love the inconsistencies. GL needs to stop rolling around in his cash and start filling in the blanks.

General Grievous managed to incapacitate Durge, not terminate or permenantly defeat him. The difference is that Grievous was (of course) the superior tactition by far, and he was more skilled.

Interesting. In terms of sheer power, was he not the superior as well?

Whatever LS; I don't see a point in arguing this anymore if you're going to skirt around every one of my points. I don't like repeating myself, so I don't think I will.

Don't talk to me about 'skirting points,' Faunus. I acknowledge Dooku has a greater control over the Force than Anakin does. Whether that will help him any more than it did when he needed it most on board the Invisible Hand is another matter.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
It's flawd. OH, why's this? IT contradicts your opinion? Considering there aren't points where the visual dictionary contradicts the movie, your point is incredibly flawed.
Especially considering it remains a part of SW canon that, shockingly, agree with one another...in fact, Nai, the only thing that doesn't agree with you.

Lmao, Lightsnake. It contradicts the movie and because of that it is flawed. Where did you see Anakin and Obi-Wan using different forms or developing uber teamwork against Dooku ? I must have missed that one in the movie.


Oh, yes. What portion of this would it be? Oh, right, the Lucas approved portion that states they hold back to draw Dooku into a false sense of security?

Lmao, Lightsnake. It was Lucas approved, yes. But based on an older version of Lucas vision of the fight. The movie shows pretty clear that they aren't holding back unless you want to tell me that they actually fight better while holding back and using unfamiliar styles than with their actual styles while not holding back.


Now, then, where in the movies do Obi-wan and Anakin state 'We're using Forms V and III!"
Right. what was the point you're making here?

The two handed overhead super-power slash which is Anakin's initial attack in the fight actually screams "Hello. I'm using Djem So !" while Obi-Wan's close distance blaster bolt deflection against the droids says "Hello. I'm using Soresu !" Not to mention that they - if you want to apply the novel timing on the movie - did fight better against Dooku using faked styles while holding back than with their original forms (when Dooku completely owned them). What was your point again ?


Oh, and it's great the visual dictionary does indeed have things to say on characters' motivations and thoughts, especially considering it's putting down information that should be obvious visually.

Lmao, Lightsnake. That one was just great. The Visual Dictionary is made to give additional information on things appearing visibly in the movie. Motivations and thoughts clearly don't belong to that department.


Yes, and if you bother to read the novelization, Dooku nearly dies because he's taking them too lightly, gets serious, regains control and then leads Anakin on a merry dance, gets overconfident and then realizes "Hey, maybe I shouldn't have provoked this kid, he's way stronger than I thought!"
The latter portion of that? Happens right in the films. The movie shows Anakin defeating him when provoked, the ROTS novelization has Dooku's own thoughts-which according to Chee, etc, etc- the visual dictionary, chronology, Visual Guide....

You are somehow again failing to get the point, Lightsnake. Nowhere in the movie is Dooku in any kind of danger until he provokes Anakin. It doesn't matter what happened in the novel - it didn't happen on screen. On screen Dooku is completely controlling the fight until the point where he provokes Anakin.

I'm not even arguing that Anakin was too powerful for Dooku to control after Dooku provoked him. The point is that Dooku could still have unleashed a barrage of force lightning on Anakin (as we saw him doing this while fighting - and he's still using only one hand against Anakin) while Anakin was forcing him backwards. Not to mention that he could easily have killed or defeated Anakin when Anakin was on the ground, hadn't he taken the time to drop that metal construction on the already knocked out Kenobi.


Again: maybe you ought to reevaluate your opinion just a bit when everything but you says you're wrong on this subject

Which is another nice irrelevant missdirection because you seem to argue a completely different subject than I do...


And when that came under any sort of scrutiny in this debate until you mentioned it now?

Tell it to Chee, not me.
Next point, please.

Nope. I'd rather let it Chee tell to you:
"G-canon is "George Lucas" canon; the six Episodes and anything directly provided to Lucas Licensing by Lucas (including unpublished production notes from him or his production department that are never seen by the public). Elements originating with Lucas in the movie novelizations, reference books, and other sources are also G-canon, though anything created by the authors of those sources is C-canon."

That's the second time I quoted this to you. If something is not fitting the latest interpretation of events within the SW universe by Lucas it's simply C-Canon. Lucas may have approved the novel version completely, even word by word. Point is: After that he obviously changed certain things in his vision making the interpretation of events offered by the novel (or the VD for that matter) pretty useless, because they don't mirror what happened in the movie any longer.


Based on one single force push? That still sends Obi-wan flying back harder?

The point is that Obi-Wan was fully capable to put up a suitable defence against Anakin's force attack and even affect Anakin himself, while he appeared to be completely defenseless when Dooku force choked him, lifted him from the ground and tossed him across the room knocking him out.


Dooku himself realizes that 'Anakin is more powerful than he had imagined?'

Yes. But how does "more powerful than Dooku had imagined" translate into "more powerful than Dooku himself" ? Going by sheer potential Anakin definetly was more powerful than Dooku but he wasn't capable of controlling all of his potential yet. Not even remotely close to it.


Palpatine comments in the movie Anakin>Dooku?
Anything else?

I wonder where Sidious said that Anakin is superior to Dooku ? Because he mentioned he will get himself a younger and more powerful apprentice ? Of course. But he was thinking in long terms all the time in a similar fashion he did when telling Yoda, that Anakin will become more powerful than Yoda and himself. Doesn't mean that Anakin already was more powerful in RotS.


Ah, right. Palpatine must be referring to '[potential'...not 'power' as in 'power' when we just saw Anakin defeat Dooku when Dooku taunted him about not 'using his anger and hate' and in a similar state as when he defeats Dooku, Anakin simultaneously defeats Cin Drallig and his students.

And in a similar state he can't overpower Obi-Wan and ends up with taking a nice lava bath. It's a little bit irritating for me that people come here and try to give 239.5 billions reasons for Anakin losing against Obi-Wan instead of coming up with a single reason why the people Anakin actually defeated were killed by him. One could actually develop the oppinion that this place is littered with Anakin fanboys.

As you said yourself: Dooku was surprised by Anakin's power because he didn't expect Anakin to be as powerful as he was once using the Dark Side. Obvious conclusion: Anakin took a surprised Dooku out. What would have happened if Dooku - like Kenobi - would have been aware of the extend of Anakin's power in terms of force powers and lightsaber mastery ? Do you want to argue that Obi-Wan is superior to Dooku in one of that departments ? I hope not. Obvious conclusion: Dooku would have been very well capable of defeating Anakin, had he been aware of Anakin's actual power like Obi-Wan was.

And the temple ? Yay. You are of course aware of the fact that the Jedi must have been pretty much surprised when their "great hope" the "Chosen One" the guy that was said to "bring balance to the force" and to "destroy the Sith" came marching into their freaking temple with a legion of Clone Troopers and actually attacked them. I guess they might have been a little bit shocked because of that. And going by the influence the death off some Jedi had on Yoda (when Order 66 was given) I guess that feeling the death of hundrets or thousands of Jedi right next to you might also have a bad influence on your fighting abilties if you happen to be a Jedi yourself.


Different fights, different environments, different circumstance.
The movie, AKA, G-canon says clearly Anakin is more powerful than Dooku. Where in the world do you pull 'potential' from? Why do you ignore in RODV that Palpatine tells Anakin if Dooku had been more powerful, he'd have ended up walking over Anakin's corpse to sit at Palpatine's right hand?

Well. The movie says so ? I was under the impression that Sidious says so. Haven't people lectured you enough already about the fact that character oppinions happen to be fallible ? And you really believe that words of Sidious in RoDV ? You really think that Sidious would sacrifice Anakin for keeping an apprentice like Dooku who was not only less powerful than Sidious but also older - meaning that keeping him as apprentice would ultimately have lessened the power of the Sith ? No really, dude.


anything that really backs up your opinion, Nai? Anything that even makes a dent in anything official?

You mean aside from the movie that shows us that Anakin and Obi-Wan are equal when it comes to actual force mastery, when the same movie shows us that Dooku is far superior to Obi-Wan in that department ?


But, hey, why even bother taking this into consideration? I don't recall many hints of the idea that Dooku was supposed to throw the fight in the movie...

You mean aside of Dooku's face when Sidious commands Anakin to kill him ?

Actually Nai, in regards to what Sidious said in RODV, yes I believe it. If Dooku was more powerful than Anakin, it would make no sense for Sidious to keep Anakin since Sidious wants the strongest apprentice possible. So he'd keep Dooku and meanwhile look for someone more powerful.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Lmao, Lightsnake. It [b]contradicts the movie and because of that it is flawed. Where did you see Anakin and Obi-Wan using different forms or developing uber teamwork against Dooku ? I must have missed that one in the movie.

Except...it doesn't contradict the movie. Not one iota. The visual guide shows pictures of the fight and elaborates.
That's it. The idea of what it contradicts is your opinion, that's all.
Get it through your head: the novelization and the visual dictionary are different


Lmao, Lightsnake. It was Lucas approved, yes. But based on an older version of Lucas vision of the fight. The movie shows pretty clear that they aren't holding back unless you want to tell me that they actually fight better while holding back and using unfamiliar styles than with their actual styles while not holding back.

It does? Really? Good thing how official material doesn't seem to back you up on the matter.
So, unless you have something from Lucas or anything that isn't your own interpretation? I'll be glad to go with what canon says over you.


The two handed overhead super-power slash which is Anakin's initial attack in the fight actually screams "Hello. I'm using Djem So !" while Obi-Wan's close distance blaster bolt deflection against the droids says "Hello. I'm using Soresu !" Not to mention that they - if you want to apply the novel timing on the movie - did fight better against Dooku using faked styles while holding back than with their original forms (when Dooku completely owned them). What was your point again ?

Wow. Blocking blaster bolts from droids just screams a form never named in the movie. Notice Anakin's attacks aren't nearly as powerful as they are later?
Or how Obi-wan deflects said blaster bolts when he attacks DROIDS and not Dooku? OR how you're referring to bits not in the direct opening engagements as specified? Right.


Lmao, Lightsnake. That one was just great. The Visual Dictionary is made to give additional information on things appearing visibly in the movie. Motivations and thoughts clearly don't belong to that department.

Oh, sorry. Didn't realize you worked for LFL as to identify the direct purpose of their materials.


You are somehow again failing to get the point, Lightsnake. Nowhere in the movie is Dooku in any kind of danger until he provokes Anakin. It doesn't matter what happened in the novel - it didn't happen on screen. On screen Dooku is completely controlling the fight until the point where he provokes Anakin.

Which is kind of the point: When he provokes Anakin, he's a dead man. He knows it, Anakin knows it and Palpatine knows it.
Hence the point I've kind of been making: When provoked, Anakin>Dooku

I'm not even arguing that Anakin was too powerful for Dooku to control after Dooku provoked him. The point is that Dooku could still have unleashed a barrage of force lightning on Anakin (as we saw him doing this while fighting - and he's still using only one hand against Anakin) while Anakin was forcing him backwards. Not to mention that he could easily have killed or defeated Anakin when Anakin was on the ground, hadn't he taken the time to drop that metal construction on the already knocked out Kenobi.

So Dooku's own flaws prevented him from winning the fight? Good to know there.
IF your'e not arguing that when provoked Anakin was more powerful than Dooku, what's this about?

Nope. I'd rather let it Chee tell to you:
"G-canon is "George Lucas" canon; the six Episodes and anything directly provided to Lucas Licensing by Lucas (including unpublished production notes from him or his production department that are never seen by the public). Elements originating with Lucas in the movie novelizations, reference books, and other sources are also G-canon, though anything created by the authors of those sources is C-canon."

That's the second time I quoted this to you. If something is not fitting the latest interpretation of events within the SW universe by Lucas it's simply C-Canon. Lucas may have approved the novel version completely, even word by word. Point is: After that he obviously changed certain things in his vision making the interpretation of events offered by the novel (or the VD for that matter) pretty useless, because they don't mirror what happened in the movie any longer.


That's wonderful! I asked Chee questions on the matter-and you saw the results.
So, according to Chee, thoughts, narrative and the like could definitely be considered G-canon if they are non-contradictory. Stover himself had something to say on what constituted Star Wars fact on the matter and since the sources don't contradict, I'm very willing to take Chee's word on the matter long before I even consider yours. Unless Lucas makes a special edition of the prequels that goes against all narration and thought process, it stands


The point is that Obi-Wan was fully capable to put up a suitable defence against Anakin's force attack and even affect Anakin himself, while he appeared to be completely defenseless when Dooku force choked him, lifted him from the ground and tossed him across the room knocking him out.

And Dooku realizes he can do absolutely nothing to affect Anakin when he's on the warpath. And how Obi-wan fails to budge Durge with the Force and Anakin hurls him across the room
A>B>C doesn't apply here


Yes. But how does "more powerful than Dooku had imagined" translate into "more powerful than Dooku himself" ? Going by sheer potential Anakin definetly was more powerful than Dooku but he wasn't capable of controlling all of his potential yet. Not even remotely close to it.

Occam's Razor might hAve a little to say, especially when several other sources do state anakin was more powerful than Dooku. Including the movie itself. And I don't recall 'potential' mentioned...in fact, RODV seems to do away with the idea of 'potential' being referred to.


I wonder where Sidious said that Anakin is superior to Dooku ? Because he mentioned he will get himself a younger and more powerful apprentice ? Of course. But he was thinking in long terms all the time in a similar fashion he did when telling Yoda, that Anakin will become more powerful than Yoda and himself. Doesn't mean that Anakin already was more powerful in RotS.

Right, he's thinking long term.
Yeah, prove it. HE tells Anakin flat out in RODV that if 'Darth Tyranus was more powerful, you'd be dead.' Palpatine doesn't seem to be thinking long term in regards to this when his master plan is days away from implementation and
The difference is? He tells Yoda Anakin WILL become more powerful than them. The difference with Dooku? He states Anakin was and is more powerful than Darth Tyranus


And in a similar state he can't overpower Obi-Wan and ends up with taking a nice lava bath. It's a little bit irritating for me that people come here and try to give 239.5 billions reasons for Anakin losing against Obi-Wan instead of coming up with a single reason why the people Anakin actually defeated were killed by him. One could actually develop the oppinion that this place is littered with Anakin fanboys.

Quite potentially because Obi-wan is able to hold his own given Anakin's current lack of sanity, control and knowing Anakin's style backwards and forwards and winning in the end due to Anakin's arrogance in combination with the environment. Hardly a matter of what happened with Obi-wan and Dooku.
Again: Fights aren't perfectly linear. Anakin being capable of defeating Tyranus doesn't mean he's capable of defeating Obi-wan in a totally different scenario


As you said yourself: Dooku was surprised by Anakin's power because he didn't expect Anakin to be as powerful as he was once using the Dark Side. Obvious conclusion: Anakin took a surprised Dooku out. What would have happened if Dooku - like Kenobi - would have been aware of the extend of Anakin's power in terms of force powers and lightsaber mastery ? Do you want to argue that Obi-Wan is superior to Dooku in one of that departments ? I hope not. Obvious conclusion: Dooku would have been very well capable of defeating Anakin, had he been aware of Anakin's actual power like Obi-Wan was.

Uh, no. Dooku is described as using all of his energy just trying to holding Anakin off and is still slaughtered like a sheep regardless. Anakin defeats a Dooku describes as using all of his power to fight for his life.
If Dooku had been aware of the extent of Anakin's power, he would've likely surrendered on the spot.


And the temple ? Yay. You are of course aware of the fact that the Jedi must have been pretty much surprised when their "great hope" the "Chosen One" the guy that was said to "bring balance to the force" and to "destroy the Sith" came marching into their freaking temple with a legion of Clone Troopers and actually attacked them. I guess they might have been a little bit shocked because of that. And going by the influence the death off some Jedi had on Yoda (when Order 66 was given) I guess that feeling the death of hundrets or thousands of Jedi right next to you might also have a bad influence on your fighting abilties if you happen to be a Jedi yourself.

The surprise fades pretty damn quickly considering more than a few Jedi go after Anakin with sheer intent to kill. Cin, Jocasta and Serra sure weren't holding back when they went after him. Anakin executing Jurokk in front of the Temple kind of confirmed that it was time to slash first, question later. You overlooked Anakin effortlessly defeating Cin Drallig, by the way.

Well. The movie says so ? I was under the impression that Sidious says so. Haven't people lectured you enough already about the fact that character oppinions happen to be fallible ? And you really believe that words of Sidious in RoDV ? You really think that Sidious would sacrifice Anakin for keeping an apprentice like Dooku who was not only less powerful than Sidious but also older - meaning that keeping him as apprentice would ultimately have lessened the power of the Sith ? No really, dude.


Hm, would Palpatine keeps Dooku around if Anakin were less powerful? Let me think abou- yes. He makes it clear to Dooku in Labyrinth of Evil if Anakin isn't strong enough, he's expendable, and that if he 'gets the upper hand', Palpatine will save Dooku.
since when does age even enter into this? A Jedi of Dooku's power can live another ten-twenty years easily and Palpatine already had a lavish set up plan with Dooku. You're telling me he's going to throw away one of the most powerful Jedi the Order ever produced who got stronger under Palpatine, for an untested boy on an entire assumption ? Do you really think Palpatine would be willing to give up Dooku if Anakin wasn't an already worthy replacement in power and ability?

Yes, Nai, considering I've seen the opinions based on what someone in G-canon says. Or is Palpatine aiming for a totally nefarious scheme that requires a lie to General Grievous? Considering there is absolutely no direct motive behind the lie, the context makes it pretty clear Palpatine isn't lying in either scenarios and we have numerous sources offhand saying that Anakin's power>Dooku, including one that was personally reviewed by Lucas, I'd say yeah, it's pretty open and shut, unless you suddenly want to claim they're all invalid in favor of an opinion which not one single piece of official work supports whatsoever.


You mean aside from the movie that shows us that Anakin and Obi-Wan are equal when it comes to actual force mastery, when the same movie shows us that Dooku is far superior to Obi-Wan in that department ?

i'm sorry, I forget where a single Force Push-that hits Obi-wan harder than it does Anakin- is definitive proof of anything.
Different fights, different scenarios. Anakin is not in control. Obi-wan is. Both are hit and Anakin doesn't hit the ground as hard nor does he stay down as long


You mean aside of Dooku's face when Sidious commands Anakin to kill him ? [/B]

Oh, right, it must mean there's an elaborate plan in place, not that Dooku isn't shocked that Palpatine is ordering his death. Nope, his loss must've been planned....couldn't possibly be that he's just surprised his master isn't saving him...

Even if Dooku was stronger then Anakin, that doesn't mean much. He was about three and a half times the Chosen One's age. Sidious neaded new aprentice. Someone with more potential, someone younger, someone that was more easy to manipulate. Dooku had his own ambitions, he wasn't just another Maul...He used to be a Jedi master for crist's sake...One of the better ones 😄

Originally posted by Lightsnake Quite potentially because Obi-wan is able to hold his own given Anakin's current lack of sanity, control and knowing Anakin's style backwards and forwards and winning in the end due to Anakin's arrogance in combination with the environment. Hardly a matter of what happened with Obi-wan and Dooku.
I just love the vast number of excuses people can make to justify Anakin's defeat.

And for the record, Anakin himself states in RoDV that he "wasn't strong enough" to beat Obi-Wan; hence his getting mauled. His arrogance and overestimation of his own power got to him, yes, but just as you say Dooku's arrogance is with him forever, so is Anakin's. So any version of Anakin willing to fight Obi-Wan to the death is always going to have that hot-headed streak, and so will usually be met with defeat.

Uh, no. Dooku is described as using all of his energy just trying to holding Anakin off and is still slaughtered like a sheep regardless.
In the novel.

Anakin defeats a Dooku describes as using all of his power to fight for his life.
Again, in the novel.

If Dooku had been aware of the extent of Anakin's power, he would've likely surrendered on the spot.
Bullshit. He didn't surrender to Yoda, did he? Or Mace? Both Anakin's vast superiors? No, Dooku wouldn't surrender, but if he found himself hard-pressed he would find a way out.

You overlooked Anakin effortlessly defeating Cin Drallig, by the way.
Which isn't that big of a deal. Dooku's effortlessly defeated half of the PT.

Hm, would Palpatine keeps Dooku around if Anakin were less powerful? Let me think abou- yes.
You've got to be kidding me. Palpatine already knew that Anakin was more valuable than Dooku, hence his stalking the kid for thirteen years.

He makes it clear to Dooku in Labyrinth of Evil if Anakin isn't strong enough, he's expendable, and that if he 'gets the upper hand', Palpatine will save Dooku/
Uh, did you miss the part where Dooku lost his head?

since when does age even enter into this? A Jedi of Dooku's power can live another ten-twenty years easily
As opposed to Anakin, who could easily live for another century.

and Palpatine already had a lavish set up plan with Dooku.
LS, this is pathetic. The "plan" Sidious had told Dooku about was all a complete sham. He obviously never intended to convert the entire Jedi Order into an army of dark acolytes; wiping out all the Jedi in the galaxy after Dooku died would've put a dent in that plan.

You're telling me he's going to throw away one of the most powerful Jedi the Order ever produced who got stronger under Palpatine, for an untested boy on an entire assumption ? Do you really think Palpatine would be willing to give up Dooku if Anakin wasn't an already worthy replacement in power and ability?
Yes. Because Anakin isn't untested, and that is why Palpatine was counting on him to win.

i'm sorry, I forget where a single Force Push-that hits Obi-wan harder than it does Anakin- is definitive proof of anything.
Different fights, different scenarios. Anakin is not in control. Obi-wan is.
WTF is this, some kind of joke? The entire ****ing point of the argument was that Obi-Wan had far greater control and mastery over his powers, and that is why they stalemated in the fight. Now your excuse is that Anakin lacks control? Well no shit.

Both are hit and Anakin doesn't hit the ground as hard nor does he stay down as long
No, they both hit the tables equally hard, and neither are down for more than a second. The difference being that Anakin gets up and bounds across the room while Obi-Wan gets up and just waits for the attack.

That's wonderful! I asked Chee questions on the matter-and you saw the results.
So, according to Chee, thoughts, narrative and the like could definitely be considered G-canon if they are non-contradictory. Stover himself had something to say on what constituted Star Wars fact on the matter and since the sources don't contradict, I'm very willing to take Chee's word on the matter long before I even consider yours. Unless Lucas makes a special edition of the prequels that goes against all narration and thought process, it stands
Uh, did you even read the quote? Seriously. . .

It says anything created by the authors is to be considered C-canon. Nothing about contradictions. If it's created by the authors, it's C-canon. Since we don't see the thoughts of Anakin and Obi-Wan, everything we are told about it is to be considered C-canon. Since we don't see Anakin and Obi-Wan switching up forms but the authors tell us it happens, it's C-canon.

Hell, let's pretend they do switch forms between the first and second sequences. The first - when they're supposedly faking - ends with all of them standing up, exchanging one-liners and being happy. The second - when they're supposed to be all serious and adherent to their new forms - Obi-Wan gets put on his ass. Now, going all out Djem So and Soresu, Anakin meet Dooku at the stairs and what happens? They get destroyed. Damn, that's a perfect argument to use in support of the Jedi!