Silver Surfer (Exiles) vs Superman Prime

Originally posted by quanchi112
When has the 616 Surfer killed anyone as easily as the exiles one. Point is he was way to powerful and vicious to be armbarred. Do you honestly think the exiles powers werent the exact same as the 616. He was just evil and a badass. 😉

You mean basic blasts = his powers being exactly the same?
Also, 616 Surfer beat someone with the IG. 🙂

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Why does anyone need to kill anyone to win a fight? Jesus never killed anyone... I suppose he loses to Wolverine... 😐
Wait, Surfer hasn't killed people as easy as Wolverine either...

You mean basic blasts = his powers being exactly the same?
Also, 616 Surfer beat someone with the IG. 🙂

Your 616 Surfer also lost to an armbar. 😄

What would Captain America's signature move be?

Sheild Bash? Pressure Point hits? Justice punch?

Shield bash.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am saying this Surfer killed someone like the Gladiator with ease and caught his punch like nothing. Of course he doesnt have the feats he was in 2 issues but to assume his power cosmic was different isnt logical now is it?

Your 616 Surfer also lost to an armbar. 😄

So? If 616>Exiles, then Armbar>>Exiles. 😬

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Shield bash.

Surfer destroyed Rune's hand with ease... with the IG...
Is it logical to assume it's the same, and tuned to the same level of 616's?

So? If 616>Exiles, then Armbar>>Exiles. 😬

The 616 pacifist Surfer would get dominated by his exiles evil self.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Nah the 616 Surfer always held back and never had the balls to really lay into someone like the exiles one did. The way he killed Gladiator was to impressive to ignore.

The 616 pacifist Surfer would get dominated by his exiles evil self.

That's your opinion based off one feat... he got chopped in half by Blink, and utterly embarrassed by Sabertooth.

Also, you know who else holds back? Thanos. I guess he loses to Exiles too... and Black Adam, and Superboy Prime. 🙂

This is pure speculation, but it almost seemed like that universes Galactus gave his Heralds more power than the 616 Galactus. This would make sense as the Exiles Galactus was a pacifist, and it would be logical to create beings that could stave off universal threats, if he would not. Does this make any sense?

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
This is pure speculation

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Agree.

Hey is that all you got from what i said? you can't just casually ignore the fact that a pacifist with a super inteligence would leave himself open to attack by a hostile force... i mean you can but, my theory is possible.

Ummm....really? People were actually impressed with Exiles Silver Surfer?

Uhmmm.... why not he tore into Gladiator alot like Tyrant did. Who is to say that he was not on Tyrants level?

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Hey is that all you got from what i said? you can't just casually ignore the fact that a pacifist with a super inteligence would leave himself open to attack by a hostile force... i mean you can but, my theory is possible.

So, a pacifist would make a super powerful killer, but a ravager would make a weaker herald?

Makes complete sense...

Gladiator is all over the place power-wise and even in 616 has been on a down-ward slope in power 😬. There is no PROOF to say what Exiles Gladiator's power level was at. To say he was at/above/below the level of 616 Gladiator is silly as once again there is no PROOF to say so.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Uhmmm.... why not he tore into Gladiator alot like Tyrant did. Who is to say that he was not on Tyrants level?

First off, he used a sword like object... not exactly raw power. Second, using this logic, this would make him a lot more powerful than Tyrant...

😐

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Yes I can... as you said, it is pure speculation.

So, a pacifist would make a super powerful killer, but a ravager would make a weaker herald?

Makes complete sense...

......Quite interesting indeed.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
It's canon. Deal with it.

Please define PIS for me please.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Please define PIS for me please.

Also, that didn't involve you. 🙂

Originally posted by Alfheim
Please define PIS for me please.

Hmmm.... that would be Plot Induced Stupidity. For example Jimmy Olsen punching out Clark because he was not in his Superman costume.

Originally posted by Mr. Slippyfist
Captain America knocking out Hulk?

Also, that didn't involve you. 🙂

PIS is contingent with consistency. So looking at Caps showings its possible but not probable. How many times has BP but class 100s heralds in an armbar? None...PIS.

Originally posted by CaptainStoic
Hmmm.... that would be Plot Induced Stupidity.
]For example Jimmy Olsen punching out Clark
because he was not in his Superman costume.