Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Look man, you're actually trying to criticize me for listening to the creator, producer and writer of the movie. Don't you just look at sentence and go, yeah, maybe I'm being a little silly. His opinion is EXPONENTIALLY more important and valuable than yours correct? More valuable than any sids apologist correct? The reality is, he never not once said Sids threw the fight. In fact, he's been quoted and saying the EXACT opposite in many ways and even having then writer of the book say the same thing. Simple. Your opinion on inferences and this and that are utterly meaningless compared to that.Yes, I believe Windu won the fight. That is what we saw, so why would I say something different? He won, he disarmed sids of his weapon and had him at his mercy. That doesn't mean he would win every time, because he wouldn't, but that time he did. It's really that simple. Get over it
So because someone doesn't say something that according to you means it never happens he never said sidious didn't throw the fight and I'm not saying it bad you listen to the producer and all of them I'm just asking you to use your own sense into this if sidious can stalemate yoda a person who can defeat windu why would he lose to someone less sense yoda has more experience than both and all that sidious wanted to accomplish I can give you actual evidence to why it's possible and most likely true sidious threw the fight as he is the greater duelist and he wanted convert a akin which he knew would some how save him this his final test for his conversion to the dark side and this is proven by the commentary by George Lucas that that was the first test then killing windu was the second test and there are quotes that also points to my side and inferences are based on facts that you use so they hold the same weight since they use the same facts from the same source only adding ones knowledge of the subject to form a conclusion so they are meaningful