Originally posted by DarkC
I posted them because, again, they were the only sources of visual examples of Gouki performing Shungokusatsu displayed anywhere, with a bit of background. I shouldn't have to keep reminding you this, so pay attention for once.I've already justified my reasoning for bringing them up, despite their non-canonity, you're simply continuing to insist on using that non-canon tirade, over and over again. You did not specify what evidence you wanted, aside from it being a visual example, so you are in no grounds at all to call me out on it, especially considering that I clearly pointed out in my original post that they were non-canon.
No, YOU pay attention, like i said, posting non-canon crap is retarded, even for "visual example" i can post of drawing of Sephiroth blowing up worlds, non-canon is non-canon and should NOT be brought up in debates even for "visual example" no one cares about non-canon crap, it proves no point, and are pointless to be brought up in debates, let alone even allowed to, if you knew they were non-canon then you shouldn't have posted them in the first place, i'm just letting you know that non-canon things hold no basis for claims, or grounds, or points, or anything like that, so pay attention and stop trying to defend non-canon things.
I didn't, and I never said that anywhere so try not to pretend that something happened when it obviously didn't. Thanks.
Uh yes you basically said that earlier:
"Once again, you asked for me to "show" you when it's been done - not specifying canon or non-canon sources, so technically you're still just beating a dead horse here, as far as I am concerned.
And I "showed" you."
Read above.I posted it because they were the only visuals I could find. Why do you think I bothered to mention that it was non canon in the first place? They were to assert their state as stated, but not official - in other words, to prevent you from immediately replying with "They're non-canon", which you did anyway. It's like trying to counter water with water, just ridiculous.
It doesn't matter, if you knew it was non-canon you shouldn't have posted it because it holds no weight in this debate, the fact that you're trying to make it hold some weight is ridiculous.
Its the same as trying to amp Gouki's strength in a debate from that comic where he punched and blew up that meteor twice the size of earth, i'd post it if i could find it.
But either way, non-canon is non-canon and shouldn't be taken for anything.
I will end this part of the debate right here, considering how terribly unproductive you're being with it:You have had absolutely nothing new to add.
-You continue failing to understand basic points, despite me attempting to take baby steps to make them simpler.
No, i think you're just getting frustrated because you failing to prove anything at all
-You're trying to prove something with non-canon material (ridiculous)
-You come up with ridiculous claims that shungokusatsu is instantaneous with no proof or even logical reference.
-You tried to claim Gouki's effort against Ryu was the "exact same effort" Sephiroth treated Cloud with, which is wrong.
-You tried to claim Gouki can teleport from chinese urban location to the great wall in a couple seconds which failed
-You tried to claim Sephiroth took several seconds to warp into the entrance which failed
Sorrry but you've been failing this entire debate.
There you go again.Once more, read my posts properly. I'm seeing less and less to do with what I say, and more of an obsession to keep on posting. It's part of the reason why right now, you're being highly unproductive to this debate. Stop.
It's not being able to land them that counts; it's the state that Gouki's opponent is in, or when in comparison to the state of Gouki's opponent. If Rugal was fully aware and facing his opponent, then do you really think that he would have let such a slow (according to you) move hit him, especially from where they were standing?
If I predict correctly, your next post in relation to what I just said will simply consist of dismissing this entire paragraph that I just wrote with "Well it's non-canon, so what you just said is moot".
Something along those lines, anyway.
But yeah, Gouki was beaten by Gouken, and he still managed to pull off a Shungokusatsu on his brother.
I've asked you this i'm not sure how many times now, i'm not sure if you're purposely avoiding the question or whatnot, but you said Gouki was beaten by Gouken, then he pulled off shungokusatsu, again PLEASE PROVIDE THE QUOTE ON HOW THE FIGHT WENT FROM A RELIABLE SOURCE <--- Read and reply please.
One more thing, the main reason why Goku was able to land such a move as a Kamehameha in a real battle was because the opponent was either strong enough to take it or counter it with another beam (etc), stupid enough to attempt to take it, or because he was able to land it using his nifty teleport move (on Perfect Cell, and Pikkon, beating them both).By a matter of coincedence, it just so happens to be called the "instant" transmission, lol.
But in short, your DBZ analogy was very poorly thought out.
No, a lot of the times they just have their eyes open stupid and took it, or he shot it and they couldn't avoid it in time,
Well see:
Instant Transmission
Transmit = to send or forward, as to a recipient or destination; dispatch; convey.
Hence, Instantly send to a destination
Instant Transmission.
It describes the move perfectly.
Right now you've sunk to the point where you're ranting, and you're taking what I said completely out of their context (see above) to suit your own needs, simply because of your obsession to continue to reply. It's disappointing to say the least.So me showing you materia that I myself asserted to be non-canon translates to "not showing you at all", and that I should have just said that. You're altering logic now in an attempt to form an argument, which is outrageous.
It was to show you what Capcom thought what the Shungokusatsu MIGHT look like, but they're still unsure - hence, it being non-canon.
No i'm stating out the truth, i originally asked you to show me "proof", non-canon things are not "proof"
Yes, unless it has been proven to be canon, they're non-canon, or else we'd have people like Zack doing this to opponents:
YouTube video
Or Cloud busting out Knights of the round on everyone
"Might" doesn't help an arguments, "might" is where we start at, everyone is a possibility, Sephiroth MIGHT beable to bust a planet, but him doing it in Kingdom Hearts wouldn't help a debate at all if the debate is with FF7 Sephiroth.
I just did, that came from an exerpt from a Street Fighter Zero 2 document.This right here is proof that you haven't been bothering to read my posts properly. If you had, you would not have brought Gouken up because he does not pertain to his fight - or you thought that Gouken was Gouki's master. Neither option makes you look good, Terry.
I brought that up because as you can see, after the move was executed it apparently took several HOURS for the move to finish.
Here it is again, in its proper context.
----
"The forbidden move was done. He selected Master Goutetsu as his opponent. As there was about to be a fight to the death, the opponent had no deficiencies.
"...arm yourself now!!!"
The spirit kept secretly inside exploded, the cells of Gouki's entire body rose in sound with a resonating sensation.....several hours later, Gouki's entire body in blood returned a scarlet hue, as he moved and saw the master's corpse."
----
(And yes, it is officially confirmed that Goutetsu WAS killed by a Shungokusatsu, so that was the move being described)
So as you can see, the course of the move itself is far from instant, so it basically is just a "hell murder". Considering now the translation of the move, there's no other reason to make it "instant hell murder" other than the startup of the move itself.
Considering I have negated both your arguments to the point of irrefutability, I fully anticipate your next reply to be filled with peripheral noise.
This is also from SFZ2
Shungokusatsu
Master Goutetsu spoke of a forbidden technique, "shungokusatsu." With this move, it was said that one's own life would be cut off in a moment of unparalleled intensity. That is, control utilized by "satsui no hadou", was said to run wildly until that life's very end.
Gouki, pronouncing all ancestors "fools" for sealing this "shungokusatsu," selected his path to break that ban on his own.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/moment
Moment: an indefinitely short period of time; instant
So it seems the description of "instant" in the name actually refers to what i've thought all along, the instant in "instant hell murder", actually refers to when the person is caught: "one's own life would be cut off in a moment of unparalleled intensity."
Thats the description from GOUKETSU himself, perhaps him AND the ancestors have never before experienced "Shun Goku Satsu" before and named it incorrectly, Gouketsu thought it only took a "moment", maybe the ancestors did too thus they put the "instant" in the name. Either way, Gouketsu and the ancestors thought it only took a "moment" and THEY were the ones who named it what it is.