Favorite/Best Director thread.

Started by Cinemaddiction25 pages

I liked "FMJ" and "The Shining". "2001" was just a little too slow for me.

yeah i totally agree... 2001 was the hardest of his movies to watch, along with EWS. but what i love bout EWS is the score... that damn piano jsut gives me the chilly willies.

I love 2001..........but I must agree. It is slow and a tad boring............the plot of the movie is over shadowed by Kubrick's artistic style.

I stick with my recomendation for you to watch 2010 : The Year We Make Contact..............it wasn't directed by Kubrick and is nothing like 2001. It's pretty much a straight up sci-fi flick, no art to it...........the plot is very, very good as it explains what happened in 2001........Event Horizon stole alot of ideas from the movie.

I must admit........2001 isn't for everybody. If you're in the mood to just sit back, chill out and grab a bowl of popcorn.......might want to pop something else in the ol' dvd player. If you're in the mood to watch a visual and aurical masterpiece.......2001 is the flick for you.

Originally posted by Cinemaddiction
Note to self: Don't ever rent another Stanley Kubrick movie for as long as I live.

I was bored out of my skull with this one. After "Last House on the Left" and "Return fo the Living Dead", I feel as if I am destined to strike out when taking reccomendations from you people. 😮

that's going a little far, you seem to be very cocky 🙄
people have different tastes, just cuz you alone don't like it that doesn't mean it's a bad movie.

Cocky? Not at all, I am super selective as to what I watch, and there are alot of people here with good taste in movies, so I was kinda hoping that since we share things in common, I may get some good suggestions.

It was more of a rib than an insult anyway.

I am still going to find 2010. It was trailered 2001, and I liked what I saw there moreso. Like I said, I am not totally Anti-Kubrick, but it was a little too slow paced for me. There were parts that were kind of inventive for 1968, i.e. the videophone.

Cinemaddiction have you seen A Clockwork Orange? That’s a great Kubrick movie but my favourite is The Shining excellent film and great cinematography.

Yeah, it's been about 5 years since I last saw A Clockwork Orange. I'll probably grab it tomorrow, along with the new releases.

Stanley Kubrick by far. He was genius.
Spielberg!? what are you talking about? he sucks! He is the most overrated director ever.

Originally posted by Dario Argento

Spielberg!? what are you talking about? he sucks! He is the most overrated director ever.
it's safe to say you are probably one of maybe 5 people on this board that would ever be brave enough to say that in public.

Lord have mercy on your soul for whatever backlash may occur. 😠

Lets take a look at Mr. Spielbergs credentials in mass, then maybe you'll change your tune.

Directed:

Minority Report
Artificial Intelligence: AI
Saving Private Ryan
Amistad
Lost World: Jurassic Park, The
Schindler's List
Jurassic Park
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Empire of the Sun
Color Purple, The
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Twilight Zone: The Movie
Poltergeist
E.T. the Extra- Terrestrial
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Close Encounters of the Third Kind
Jaws
Duel

Produced: (Executive or otherwise)

Men in Black II
"Band of Brothers" (TV)
Artificial Intelligence: AI
Shrek
Saving Private Ryan
Deep Impact
Amistad
Men in Black
Twister
SeaQuest DSV
Schindler's List
American Tail: Fievel Goes West, An
Cape Fear
Arachnophobia
Gremlins 2: The New Batch
Back to the Future Part III
Back to the Future Part II
Land Before Time, The
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
Empire of the Sun
Harry and the Hendersons
American Tail, An
Money Pit, The
Color Purple, The
Back to the Future
Goonies, The
Gremlins
Twilight Zone: The Movie
Poltergeist
E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial

Writer of:

Artificial Intelligence: AI
Goonies, The
Poltergeist
Close Encounters of the Third Kind

..in addition to all the award winning Medal of Honor video games.

Overrated my ass. And yes, I am actually kinda mad that anyone would even think to say that outloud.

Thank You Cinemaaddiction. And remember AI was a Kubrick+Spielberg movie.

anyone some of guy richies other work besides
snatch
LSandTSB

i know he did one with maddona, a remake of a classic... anyone remember the name of that movie, or know of any other movies he contributed to?

That was "Swept Away", I am pretty sure. He actually hasn't done but 3 or 4 movies. "Lock, Stock" was a little flat. I think I disliked it because it just couldn't measure up to "Snatch", which would be hard.

Originally posted by Samas-adian
Thank You Cinemaaddiction. And remember AI was a Kubrick+Spielberg movie.

ah yes, AI, a good movie that easily could have been one of the greatest films ever had kubrick been able to make it, it was supposedly going to be his ultimate film, and he wanted to make it the modern 2001: A space oddesy, pushing the envelope of what film was, and what it could be. Instead, we got a good movie, but nothing more.

The problem with spielberg is that his movies, while being good, never really add anything new to the picture. His films are very formulaic, but not very innovative or unique. I think he is definately an over rated director in most regards, and should not be mentioned in the same sentance as truley innovative and inspiring film makers like kubrick, hitchcock, and other who changed the ways we looked at film.

1) Hitchcock without question- I've seen at least 30 of his films and was riveted by all 2) Kurasawa - an experimental and philosophical genius
3) Bertolucci who is underrated (www.budweiser.com/1 has a trailer for The Dreamers)
4) Kubrick- NOT including A Clockwork Orange -while as a stand-alone movie it was great, it was a bastardization of Burgess' novel. Don't argue until you've read it. The things in the book that were most meaningful and most disturbing were glossed over for the less important novelty aspects that made it in (along with outside crap that didn't contribute much). AND may I add that the pseudo-film geeks who run around with the "ultra-violence" t-shirts are complete morons who generally don't understand that that means "rape," even after you explain it to them. Real film geeks, however, are cool w me.

that is all.

oh, yeah-- and no lucas bc his real talent lies in imagination, editing, and producing. he's said in many interviews that he doesn't like directing and only started doing it in self-defense as an editor.

spielberg i love... maybe he's #5, followed by (fellow movie-brats) coppola & scorsese tied at #6

hmm...but i am also in love w tim burton whose films are most auteuristic out of anybody i mentioned (except Hitch)

But no Albert Broccoli bc Chitty Chitty Bang Bang should be legally considered torture.

I will kindly shut up now.

what about Quentin...whether you like him or not he has brought alot to film in his only 10 years of writing/directing. although his stories are ripped and have been told hundreds of times, he still adds a style of his own to each of his movies. so its the same story with a new take on it, and that to me is innovating...

The thing is ....Tarantino has only directed four movies. He has now directed 4 movies......in 4 different genres.......none of which set the standards for their genres, much less all of cinema.

He makes great films, I'm a fan ..............but to say his directing skills on those 4 movies even compare with Kubrick who directed masterpieces decade after decade after decade..........I don't believe I could go that far. If Quentin's movies are still as good 30 years from now and he's still churning them out with equal brilliance, he may rank up there with Kubrick.

i understand where you are coming from evil dead... but if anything i think that quentins dialogue and ablity to tell a story are marvelous. granite his visual shot are good but not extraordinary. but his writing on the other hand is out of this world.