Wizards vs Mutants

ALright, whatever on that argument, my point still stands that since this is the 5th movie, and no Dementor was summoned or shown, they aren't allowed. Or if they are, it takes them a helluva a long time to come all the way from Azkaban to Hogwarts.

Dude, stop. Dementors are there as the battle starts. Umbridge can control them. She doesnt have to "summon" them from Azkaban, they are already there.

Why are they already there? They weren't there in the movie, they were expelled from Hogwarts, and you're forgetting that they don't really distinguish from who they're soul sucking, so if you do let them fight, they'll probably suck up a good portion of Hogwarts residents as well.

Originally posted by KingD19
Why are they already there? They weren't there in the movie, they were expelled from Hogwarts, and you're forgetting that they don't really distinguish from who they're soul sucking, so if you do let them fight, they'll probably suck up a good portion of Hogwarts residents as well.

Dementors are controlled by magic. They will be "ordered" to strike Xavier. How do you think the Dementors found Harry in OOTP?

And if they go after a wizard, expecto patronum, simple.

So they know who they're attacking? WHy did they get Dudley then then?

And can you show where he okayed it? Because I didn't see it.

Originally posted by KingD19
So they know who they're attacking? WHy did they get Dudley then then?

And can you show where he okayed it? Because I didn't see it.

Originally posted by Dr Will Hatch
Just for clarification, I did give permission for dementors to be in the battle.

Because Dudley was right there next to Harry. And Dudley cannot produce a Patronus.

Well, since Dudley was near Harry, then that means the Dementors will attack whoevers near the mutants.

Originally posted by KingD19
Well, since Dudley was near Harry, then that means the Dementors will attack whoevers near the mutants.

Every wizard knows Patronus I suspect? And let's not forget, we go by movie feats, not every wizard can do it, and it was stated that even full wizards aren't always good at it.

Originally posted by KingD19
Every wizard knows Patronus I suspect? And let's not forget, we go by movie feats, not every wizard can do it, and it was stated that even full wizards aren't always good at it.

No they don't all know it, only the advanced defense against the darkarts wizards. But the Dementors get taken out pretty easily. One mind-controlled wizard gets the with a Protronus. End of Threat.

Was that shown to work on Dementors? And not every wizard knows that spell either.

Originally posted by Nephthys
No they don't all know it, only the advanced defense against the darkarts wizards. But the Dementors get taken out pretty easily. One mind-controlled wizard gets the with a Protronus. End of Threat.

So you are saying that Xavier will control a wizard and make them do a Patronus? There are so many things wrong with that statement I dont know where to start. First of all, the wizards that can do a patronus can be protected with a protego totalum and OCCLUMENCY. Also, if Xavier is busy having one wizard doing a patronum, he will be wide open for a death spell.

A Protronus always works against the Dementors. And there are plenty of people here who can do it, its standard for Aurors for a start.

Saying xavier doesn't see a dementor is foolish. Why does he need to see something when his mind can "see" things much more clearly than crude eyes can?

And anything with a mind is raped by Xavier. That's anything. Raped.

I meant the protecty thingy, not patronus. Was the other spell shown to work on Dementors.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Saying xavier doesn't see a dementor is foolish. Why does he need to see something when his mind can "see" things much more clearly than crude eyes can?

And anything with a mind is raped by Xavier. That's anything. Raped.

So you are saying that Xavier will control a wizard and make them do a Patronus? There are so many things wrong with that statement I dont know where to start. First of all, the wizards that can do a patronus can be protected with a protego totalum and OCCLUMENCY. Also, if Xavier is busy having one wizard doing a patronum, he will be wide open for a death spell.

So even the crappy students harry teaches it too can do occlumency and Protego totalum? No, didn't think so.

And you (still) seem to be under the delusion that they are fighting in a massive field, where everyone is easy to find. They're not, the Dementors will have to look for Xavier (though why they would be targetting him specifically is beyond me) inside labyrinthine Hogwarts, giving him plenty of opportunity to take them out, with protronus or telepathy.

Originally posted by Nephthys
So even the crappy students harry teaches it too can do occlumency and Protego totalum? No, didn't think so.

And you (still) seem to be under the delusion that they are fighting in a massive field, where everyone is easy to find. They're not, the Dementors will have to look for Xavier (though why they would be targetting him specifically is beyond me) inside labyrinthine Hogwarts, giving him plenty of opportunity to take them out, with protronus or telepathy.

The Dementors found Harry in a sewer, there were people all around (driving overhead in cars), they zeroed in on him. They will have no trouble zeroing in on Xavier. They will be targeting him because they will be instructed to do so, simple.

Fighting inside Hogwarts is a great advantage for the wizards, any fool can see this. And the thread starter said "At Hogwarts", thats all. He never said where the battle starts. Xavier will have his hands full with the wizards, no way no how does he fight off Dementors too. But hey, he has no defense against dementors. Get it got it good.

You seem to think that Xavier will be ALLOWED to do all the things you are saying. He will have death spells, dementors, legilimency, and god knows what else to deal with.

And the wizards will have torrents of flame, ice blasts, disintigration, optic beams, localized lightning strikes, mini tornadoes, speedsters, shockwaves, and all other types of stuff to deal with. And while they might not stop them, alot of those powers can slow a dementor down.