Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
I'm talking players in the "Rudy" mold where they are clearly inferior physically to College or Pro players and yet somehow through "teamwork" and for the sake of a feel good movie win. You wouldn't sit there and go... hmmmm that stinks of a little BS and isn't very logical this person/team would win and clearly happened for the sake of storyline? Your saying power sets aren't everything but really they are a crucial part of how we debate on KMC. We take into account PIS and CIS and who really should beat who based on power sets. When I see Supes beating Mandrakk or any Monitor or even DS sometimes (who forgets most of his powers but I can see Supes winning some) I think... well that shouldn't have happened but whatever it's Supes. It seems you go... well he just changed his mindset and forget that really he shouldn't be beating this person in a PIS and CIS free environment. So, to be clear, you view Supes wins over Mageddon, Mandrakk, COIE Monitor or insert universal threat here ___ as him just changing his mind and not that he probably shouldn't have won that fight.
Not good examples, there was a lot of characters and a lot of other variables at play in many of those scenarios.
However, if [insert threat] showed up as a regular villain and ran into Superman and caught beat-downs or every so often for a decade, or were shown as peers, regardless of how they're portrayed in other books, yeah, I'd say Superman is that good.
Power-set isn't everything, a characters power level itself is just as important. Iron Man's array of options is vastly greater than World War Hulk, how do you feel that fight goes down? How about Cyborg [Titans] vs Doomsday?
A characters prowess in battle is just as important as those two. What many street levelers do with minor powers, is typically less than what Bruce Wayne accomplishes without, because his fighting prowess is simply higher.
This is why we debate overall characters, and not just power-sets.
The comics, the stories within, the feats they accomplish are our guide in these endeavors.
Coincidentally, random Green Lantern of space sector 6672 [random numbers I pulled up.] has a power-set greater than Superman. Guess who'd win that fight?