Batman vs. John McClane

Started by Rogue Jedi55 pages

Originally posted by Impediment
I don't need to. The same thing can be said for McClane. It's not fanboyism, it's common damn sense. Nobody is just going to stand there and become a target.
So Batman is faster than a bullet? Because you know Mac is gonna open fire right off the bat.

1. He took on a dozen or so heavily armed thugs at the dock in BB.
2. He took out Lau and his armed bodyguards in Hong Kong.
3. He incapacitated Joker and his thugs in his penthouse.
4. He incapacitated a SWAT team at the Prewitt building.

like fifth time i posted this.bats ducks like a mutha****a,at the same time shooting 1-2 batarnags mcclanes hands.in the seconds mcclane's tending to his hands,batman runs up to him,makes sure the gun is knocked out of his hand,probably by twisting his arm,and,angry that he was shot at,proceeds to feed mcclane his teeth

Originally posted by Darth Martin
1. He took on a dozen or so heavily armed thugs at the dock in BB.
2. He took out Lau and his armed bodyguards in Hong Kong.
3. He incapacitated Joker and his thugs in his penthouse.
4. He incapacitated a SWAT team at the Prewitt building.

don't need to say more

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Name one time when he faced a gunman half as skilled as Mac, armed with a full auto rifle to boot.
McClane wasn't that skilled with his sub-machine gun. He rarely fired it properly. But okay........
1. He took on a dozen or so heavily armed thugs at the dock in BB.
2. He took out Lau and his armed bodyguards in Hong Kong.
3. He incapacitated Joker and his thugs in his penthouse.
4. He incapacitated a SWAT team at the Prewitt building.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
1. He took on a dozen or so heavily armed thugs at the dock in BB.
2. He took out Lau and his armed bodyguards in Hong Kong.
3. He incapacitated Joker and his thugs in his penthouse.
4. He incapacitated a SWAT team at the Prewitt building.

Batman also had the element of surprise in 3 if not all of those scenarios. Per the OP, Batman's doesn't have that element here, McClane sees him; he sees McClane.

So Batmman's going to have to be actively dodging, ducking, taking cover while making his way to McClane. I don't think it's as easy for Batman, as you make it.

Originally posted by Robtard

So Batmman's going to have to be actively dodging, ducking, taking cover while making his way to McClane. I don't think it's as easy for Batman, as you make it.

read my above post

Originally posted by Darth Martin
McClane wasn't that skilled with his sub-machine gun. He rarely fired it properly. But okay........
1. He took on a dozen or so heavily armed thugs at the dock in BB.
2. He took out Lau and his armed bodyguards in Hong Kong.
3. He incapacitated Joker and his thugs in his penthouse.
4. He incapacitated a SWAT team at the Prewitt building.
McClane rarely fired it properly? Are you high? He was pwnage with it.

And how many of those guys have McClanes skill? None.

We need a more precise sceanrio. like WHERE in Nakatomi plaza?

Originally posted by gobstakid777
read my above post

Can you cite one example of Bale-man dodging/avoiding active gunfire while simultaneously throwing multiple batarangs that knock 'guns out of hands'? I can't recall.

Originally posted by Robtard
Can you cite one example of Bale-man dodging/avoiding active gunfire while simultaneously throwing multiple batarangs that knock 'guns out of hands'? I can't recall.
Not to mention gunfire from a person of McClanes skill level, with a submachine gun.

Originally posted by Robtard
Can you cite one example of Bale-man dodging/avoiding active gunfire while simultaneously throwing multiple batarangs that knock 'guns out of hands'? I can't recall.

alright fine.he ducks behind the check in place,whatever thaat's called,and then throws multiple batarangs at him,or if he's really pissed,uses some of his sticky bombs,or whatever that batrope thing is he uses to swing around.mcclane is getting pwned no matter wat

He wasn't pwnage with it. Like I said he rarely fired it properly. He was no Swagger with it that's for sure.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
He wasn't pwnage with it. Like I said he rarely fired it properly. He was no Swagger with it that's for sure.
He was no Swagger, true, but he was more than good enough to kill Batman.

Wait a second, is Batman trying to kill or apprehend McClane?

ok here's how it goes.
1.john starts shooting.bats quickly ducks behind the clerk's desk.as mcclane approachs.batman quickly shoots 2 batrangs at his mcclane's hands.mcclane looks down at his hands for a second,and looks up just in time to see bats swirve behind him and break his arm,and then ko him with a punch.al comes on the walkie-talkie
Al-"John,are you there?"
(batman picks up the walkie)
Batman- "Who is this"
Al- "This is Sergeant Al Powell of the LAPD"
Batman- "This is Batman"
(dialouge goes on that proves it really is batman)
Al-"Where is John?"
Batman- "I was forced to incapacitate him"
Al- "Oh.That's okay.He is a prick anyway.What's your status?"

2.john starts shooting at bats,while calling him a freak in a batsuit.bats quickly ducks behind the clerk's desk.as mcclane approachs.batman quickly shoots 2 batrangs at his mcclane's hands.mcclane looks down at his hands for a second,and looks up just in time to see bats swirve behind him and break his arm,and then punch him in the face,causing him to fall.a weak mcclane looks up to see an enraged batman,angry he was called a freak.bats then proceeds to bash mcclane's head in ala Hartigan doing to TOYB in sin city (what a coincidence).al comes on the walkie-talkie
Al-"John,are you there?"
(batman picks up the walkie)
Batman- "Who is this"
Al- "This is Sergeant Al Powell of the LAPD"
Batman- "This is Batman"
(dialouge goes on that proves it really is batman)
Al-"Where is John?"
Batman- "he was shot down"
Al- "Oh.That's okay.He is a prick anyway.What's your status?"
after the conversation is over,bats easily kos one of han's henchmen,and goes back to the lobby to unload the henchmen's gun into mcclane

Again, more of the Batman is faster than a speeding bullet bullshit.

He aint.

He dies.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Wait a second, is Batman trying to kill or apprehend McClane?
Since this is a thread I'd assume they're trying to kill each other.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Again, more of the Batman is faster than a speeding bullet bullshit.

He aint.

He dies.


he's the goddamn batman.he wins

I ask again, for the umpteenth time. When has Batman ever faced someone half as skilled with a gun as McClane, armed with a machine gun to boot?