Originally posted by batdude123did you not see what battlehammer said?
Ad Hominem Abusive fallacy.
I mean that has been the argument for why Black Panthers feats can't be used, because it was hudlin and hudlin is biased, despite the fact priest and other writers have written t'challa at a high level for years.
but can I hear your opinion for why t'challa shouldn't b in the top tier, or who deserves it over him?
not sure i remember you voting one way or the other, but I'm curious.
Originally posted by Juk3nhe's definitely one of the greatest swordsmen in marvel, i don't think he's ever had a hand-to-hand fight, that i remember at least. not saying I don't get your point, but t'challa definitely has the feats, no arguments have been made for psylocke thus far.
i think Wolverine and Elektra would call him one of the greatest martial artists theyve ever fought, not currently regarded as a top tier.I certainly couldnt justify him being in the same tier as..Bucky, for instance.
Neither could you, nor anyone else.And if T'Challa isnt going to take the marvel spot, and Psylocke isnt going to take the Marvel Top tier slot show me someone in Tier 2 who matches Gorgon..i suppose 😕
Originally posted by OneDumbG0i'm not sure if this was directed at me, i just want to clarify that i don't believe anyone is racist, merely that it's illogical to call hudson biased when t'challa was performing at that level years before
Everyone needs to stop being racist and just nominate a white man to the top tier spot instead of a black guy and an asian guy and girl. ermmThat'll solve everything. ermmhappy
Originally posted by Trackz
he's definitely one of the greatest swordsmen in marvel, i don't think he's ever had a hand-to-hand fight, that i remember at least. not saying I don't get your point, but t'challa definitely has the feats, no arguments have been made for psylocke thus far.
im for Tchalla, but im getting the impression that he wont be acepted by the majority, and all im saying is if he's not and psylocke isnt , then theres a whole host of tier 2 choices
that fall well below Gorgon.
Originally posted by Trackz
did you not see what battlehammer said?I mean that has been the argument for why Black Panthers feats can't be used, because it was hudlin and hudlin is biased, despite the fact priest and other writers have written t'challa at a high level for years.
but can I hear your opinion for why t'challa shouldn't b in the top tier, or who deserves it over him?
not sure i remember you voting one way or the other, but I'm curious.
I'm saying the "Hudlin used to be president of BET, therefore, his depiction of Black Panther should be disregarded," is a classic example of Ad Hominem Abusive fallacy.
Originally posted by batdude123
I'm saying the "Hudlin used to be president of BET, therefore, his depiction of Black Panther should be disregarded," is a classic example of Ad Hominem Abusive fallacy.
The problem is some of his showings are consistent with other writers eg owning Karnak. So bias isn't always a good argument.
Originally posted by Juk3ni know what you're saying, but I'm not sure an argument could be made for gorgon, he might be a beast in H2H, but he's used a sword in all of his fights if i'm not mistaken.
im for Tchalla, but im getting the impression that he wont be acepted by the majority, and all im saying is if he's not and psylocke isnt , then theres a whole host of tier 2 choicesthat fall well below Gorgon.