Originally posted by RobtardRob, even a basic Protego will block a force attack. Harry is well capable of this.
So Potter never actually cast this spell you think will net him a victory here?Dude, just stop. You'll gimp-horse Vader to ridiculousness, yet break basic rules because it benefits Potter.
HP magic is stronger than the force.
The force is energy.
Protego is an energy barrier.
The energy that is the force cannot get past the stronger energy barrier. It's quite simple.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The shields were up? Really now? Proof?Also, it was not a Protego shield.
Lol, the shields on any ship are always up, they only turn them off to converve energy, or divert the energy to something else.
And if anything, the shield generator on a star destroyer are much more powerful than a protego, RJ, this is ridiculous man, the lengths you go to so that your side wins is crazy.
Oh, and there's no way Harry can cast Protego before Vader chokes his ass, it's use is instantaneous, while Harry has to shout protego, which takes quite a bit longer.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Vader force choking that guy from across the galaxy was a simple game of connect the dots. The force is everywhere, he simply applied his will and the force did the rest.The force being everywhere doesn't help him here.
No, it does from your argument here.
You're trying to say that magic is more powerful, ergo a shield can block the Force. Ignoring that the Force can go anywhere and the user doesn't need to physically see his target speaks volumes of the power out-put the Force has.
Originally posted by KingD19
Lol, the shields on any ship are always up, they only turn them off to converve energy, or divert the energy to something else.And if anything, the shield generator on a star destroyer are much more powerful than a protego, RJ, this is ridiculous man, the lengths you go to so that your side wins is crazy.
Oh, and there's no way Harry can cast Protego before Vader chokes his ass, it's use is instantaneous, while Harry has to shout protego, which takes quite a bit longer.
Shields are always up? The why did Piett, while chasing the Falcon, say "shields up?" No, they are not always up.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Rob, even a basic Protego will block a force attack. Harry is well capable of this.HP magic is stronger than the force.
The force is energy.
Protego is an energy barrier.The energy that is the force cannot get past the stronger energy barrier. It's quite simple.
Pure speculation and Potter-masturbation on your part.
The Force can [likely] travel anywhere and is in everything, can magic say the same?
Originally posted by RobtardSo it can go anywhere. And? Can't go through a Protego, that's all that matters.
No, it does from your argument here.You're trying to say that magic is more powerful, ergo a shield can block the Force. Ignoring that the Force can go anywhere and the user doesn't need to physically see his target speaks volumes of the power out-put the Force has.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
So it can go anywhere. And? Can't go through a Protego, that's all that matters.
Considering it "permeates all things" and Vader was able to use it from great distances in space without even having to physically see the target, it stands to reason a magic shield won't stop it, it will be a non-factor.
Do keep ignoring that Potter wouldn't be able to react first though, he's too slow and he has no precog.
Shields are always up? The why did Piett, while chasing the Falcon, say "shields up?" No, they are not always up.
At what point? Becuase if it was the point I remember then it would be becuase they had just been bombaded by asteroids for hours and he wanted to make sure he wasn't going to get a comet through his windshield.
Originally posted by NephthysWhen the Falcon "attacked" his vessel in ESB.
At what point? Becuase if it was the point i remember the it would be becuase theyhad just been bombaded by asteroids for hours and he wanted to make sure he wasn't going to get a comet through his windshield.
"Shields up", he said. Watch the scene again.
Originally posted by RobtardHarry is more than fast enough to cast a Protego before Vader attacks. Rob.
Considering it "permeates all things" and Vader was able to use it from great distances in space without even having to physically see the target, it stands to reason a magic shield won't stop it, it will be a non-factor.Do keep ignoring that Potter wouldn't be able to react first though, he's too slow and he has no precog.
It permeates all things within the SW galaxy, a Protego shield is NOT in the SW galaxy. 😉 Also, it permeates "all living things."
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Harry is more than fast enough to cast a Protego before Vader attacks. Rob.It permeates all things within the SW galaxy, a Protego shield is NOT in the SW galaxy. 😉
So Harry is faster than Vader's precog? Because from the movies, he's a boy with the reaction time of a normal human.
You're the one that was talking about both being "energy". Same thing can be said and turned around. The Force/Force-choke is not in the Potter galaxy. So what's your point?
To answer your question about Vader's precog failing, those two instances were against other Force-users, no?
Originally posted by Robtard
So Harry is faster than Vader's precog?You're the one that was talking about both being "energy". Same thing can be said and turned around. Froce-choke is not in the Potter galaxy. So what's your point?
To answer your question about Vader's precog failing, those two instances were against other Force-users, no?
Point is, as I have said many times, HP magic is stronger than the force. The force choke will not penetrate the more powerful protego. 1 + 2 = 3, babe.
One was against Solo. No force in Solo.
And HP magic, being stronger than the force, uses stronger energy smileFunny, it was admitted by some that HP magic is stronger. Now that I closed the argument, those same people are denying it.
Funny.
No it isn't. The wielder is what matters, not the weapon. If Vader can get through the shields of a Star Destoyer, which is muuuuuch stronger than anything Harry freakin' Potter can produce, how do you think he's going to be stopped by Harry's protego, which is entirely featless.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Point is, as I have said many times, HP magic is stronger than the force. The force choke will not penetrate the more powerful protego. 1 + 2 = 3, babe.One was against Solo. No force in Solo.
You ignored the question, do you really think Potter is fast enough to counter Force-precog?
Lol, no, you have yet to prove that. While Vader's ability to choke someone from great distances who he can't see in person speaks volumes of the general out-put of the Force.
Remind me which scene exactly? If you're saying the space-battle, that's a poor conparison. It was a massive space battle. But like I said before, I'd give you your Potter winning 1% of the time.