Nova Prime vs Green Lantern (Kyle)

Started by "Id"15 pages

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

Oblivion being reabsorbed and Valkyrie being banished is a false distinction. Valkyrie possessed the skills from the start. Leading into Blood and Thunder, Thor wasn't going around stomping on the most skilled fighters in the universe with his own H2H skills. And don't even go on to imply that the non-reabsorption of Valkyrie ended up banishing that skill set from Thor's mind. That's as attenuated as assuming Kyle could do everything Oblivion did.

Funny your find it attenuated, when Oblivion was using his knowledge as a bargaining tool with Kyle. Now Oblivion is part of Kyle’s psyche, all Kyle has to do is recall that information.

I don’t really care if you doubt, or accept Thor skill set. If she is the manifestation of Thor skill. Chances are Thor is simply that skillful.

Originally posted by "Id"
Chances are Thor is simply that skillful.

I wish.

Please tell me this isn't the fight that shows OMFG Gamora + skills?
http://img291.imageshack.us/img291/13/thor47017.jpg
http://img42.imageshack.us/img42/7789/thor47018.jpg
http://img534.imageshack.us/img534/3452/thor47019.jpg

^ It's not. Read Thor #469, where she beats Gamora straight up 1v1. Your scans are from Thor #470. Though kicking the crap out of Moondragon isn't a exactly child's play either.

Originally posted by "Id"
Funny your find it attenuated, when Oblivion was using his knowledge as a bargaining tool with Kyle. Now Oblivion is part of Kyle’s psyche, all Kyle has to do is recall that information.
Please. There's a difference between knowing what to do, having the power to do it and having the mindset to do it. Analyzing your projection of Oblivion's feats onto Kyle reveals a significant dubiousness in all three facets.
Originally posted by "Id"
I don’t really care if you doubt, or accept Thor skill set. If she is the manifestation of Thor skill. Chances are Thor is simply that skillful.
When all else fails, adopt the absurd argument whole-heartedly. Yeah. Been seeing more of that lately. You can have your own opinions. I disagree.

sam

P.S. Nice gif you edited in there. Real classy. kinda

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ It's not. Read Thor #469, where she beats Gamora straight up 1v1. Though kicking the crap out of Moondragon isn't a exactly child's play either.

This is the oh so monstrous display of skill? Yeah I am sure that this on top of demonstrating how to hip toss, can not be learned by eons of Asgardian training.
http://img839.imageshack.us/img839/9066/thor46917.jpg
http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/6411/thor46919.jpg

Please. There's a difference between knowing what to do, having the power to do it and having the mindset to do it. Analyzing your projection of Oblivion's feats onto Kyle reveals a significant dubiousness in all three.

The only dubiousness taking place, was that God awful point of reference using Thor Dark persona. Power, and mind set are not a factor in this scenario.

Kyle has the power to replicate Oblivion's feat. Oblivion was nothing more then a persona empowered by his ring. Hence the reason why Oblivion seeks out Kyle’s ring. The mind set? Are you aware that these battle take precedent on the fact that they want to kick each others asses? Of course Kyle has the mind set, otherwise what would be the point of pitting them in a fight to begin with? facepalm

Originally posted by "Id"
This is the oh so monstrous display of skill? Yeah I am sure that this on top of demonstrating how to hip toss, can not be learned by eons of Asgardian training.
http://img839.imageshack.us/img839/9066/thor46917.jpg
http://img21.imageshack.us/img21/6411/thor46919.jpg
Try finding a 1v1 fight where Gamora gets straight up pounded without circumstance or plot device in a H2H battle. Nice ploy trying to bring down Gamora's own skill down to the level of routine Asgardian training. Did you not notice that Gamora was pounding Thor with his "eons of Asgardian training" and dancing around him in the subsequent fight from #470 which you confusedly posted above? Or are you now going to further corner yourself into absurdly arguing that Valkyrie's manifestation actually sucked all of Thor's fighting prowess away in order to explain the clear disconnect?

Awesome deflection. Lovin the classy gifs. kinda

Originally posted by "Id"
The only dubiousness taking place, was that God awful point of reference using Thor Dark persona. Power, and mind set are not a factor in this scenario.

Kyle has the power to replicate Oblivion's feat. Oblivion was nothing more then a persona empowered by his ring. Hence the reason why Oblivion seeks out Kyle’s ring. The mind set? Are you aware that these battle take precedent on the fact that they want to kick each others asses? Of course Kyle has the mind set, otherwise what would be the point of pitting them in a fight to begin with?

Try recognizing that projecting Valkyrie's skill onto Thor is as idiotic as projecting Oblivion's skill onto Kyle.

They're not factors because the idea is implausible in the first place. Kyle's had immense opportunity to kick it up a notch with these fantastical notions of power display and ingenuity. There's something lacking. And you're not going to hide that beneath the cover of "full capacity." I'm arguing viability in the first instance; you're arguing thread conditions and arbitrarily assuming viability.

Man, this is tough! I gotta give this to Kyle but by a veeeeeery slight margin.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Try finding a 1v1 fight where Gamora gets straight up pounded without circumstance or plot device in a H2H battle. Nice ploy trying to bring down Gamora's own skill down to the level of routine Asgardian training. Did you not notice that Gamora was pounding Thor with his "eons of Asgardian training" and dancing around him in the subsequent fight from #470 which you confusedly posted above? Or are you now going to further corner yourself into absurdly arguing that Valkyrie's manifestation actually sucked all of Thor's fighting prowess away in order to explain the clear disconnect?

Awesome deflection. Lovin the classy gifs. kinda Try recognizing that projecting Valkyrie's skill onto Thor is as idiotic as projecting Oblivion's skill onto Kyle.


There is nothing me to dumb down here, I see those scans for what they are. Absolutely nothing. In the spam of two panels you wish to sell the idea that Valkyrie sits on even ground with Gamora. For what? To argue that Kyle can not replicate Oblivion feats, by associating your exaggerated claims. No not exaggerate, but flat out lie? we never even get to see a clear dominance from Valkyrie as you so oh-so humbly commented.

Find a different point of reference, because this one is borderline retarded. Your probably going respond, and continue to endorse this Gamora+ shenanigans. Go ahead, don’t be surprised if I decided to ignore your bullshit.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0

They're not factors because the idea is implausible in the first place. Kyle's had immense opportunity to kick it up a notch with these fantastical notions of power display and ingenuity. There's something lacking. And you're not going to hide that beneath the cover of "full capacity." I'm arguing viability in the first instance; you're arguing thread conditions and arbitrarily assuming viability.

The comic book makes it very clear that each, and every one of those constructs are Kyle. This entire argument of yours isn’t about viability, but inability to accept the fact. The only way to claim that feats from his constructs are not viable, would be if they never happened in the first place. Tough they did happen, and now Kyle retains their experience in his mind.

I sit comfortably with my comment for three simple reasons, which you have failed to debunk; those are his constructs, they are now part of his conscious mind, and he has the power to replicate the their feat.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
That'd be like arguing Thor can fight as well as his dark Valkyrie who beat Gamora straight up.

nono

Funny you should bring that up. awesome

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=12203353#post12203353

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=12203792#post12203792

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=12294814#post12294814

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=12295028#post12295028

This still open? Kyle wins.

I'm not sure whether I should be flattered or creeped out that you had those links Philo. Possibly on hand.

The Thor fanboyism aside, I don't think I'd agree with using Valkyrie's feats for Thor -or I'd have posted them in my thread by now- at the very least not a Thor who operates in his standard mindset.

I can see the logic behind it -even Odin described her as nothing more but a bit of mental debris, a side effect birthed by Thor's troubled mind- as she was created by Thor's subconsciousness and it's not as if she'd have gained the skills from anywhere else. Thor also did defeat her in combat rather swiftly IRCC. Although that was on the landscape of his mind so I don't know if it counts.

I guess you could argue that if Thor digs deep, he can operate on that level. srug

I have a good memory and know how to use the search function.

You should feel flattered that out of all the idiocies spilled on this board on a daily basis, yours was one of those that didn't fade away with the rest.

Originally posted by "Id"
There is nothing me to dumb down here, I see those scans for what they are. Absolutely nothing. In the spam of two panels you wish to sell the idea that Valkyrie sits on even ground with Gamora. For what? To argue that Kyle can not replicate Oblivion feats, by associating your exaggerated claims. No not exaggerate, but flat out [b]lie? we never even get to see a clear dominance from Valkyrie as you so oh-so humbly commented. [/b]
Excuse me, even ignoring your completely transparent attempts to drag Gamora down to Thor's level, are you really suggesting that the power of Oblivion was retained by Kyle AFTER he gave up the Ion energies? Because the only post classic-Ion amp he retained were the tweaks he made to his ring. A considerable amp to be sure, but the power of Oblivion? No. The power of Oblivion was enmeshed with the Central Battery energies Hallax stole and that was the Ion energies. And that's what Kyle mostly gave up to restore Oa and the Guardians.
Originally posted by "Id"
Find a different point of reference, because this one is borderline retarded. Your probably going respond, and continue to endorse this Gamora+ shenanigans. Go ahead, don’t be surprised if I decided to ignore your bullshit.
Yeah. Trying to ignore the exact parallel between your Oblivion/Kyle and Valkyrie/Thor was really defused when you suggested that "trained-for-eons" Asgardians could tool Gamora and Moondragon. Except Gamora literally played rope-a-dope with Thor in THE VERY NEXT ISSUE. You even scanned that next issue and posted the scans. What? Tell me you see a difference between how Valkyrie fought Gamora and how Thor fought Gamora. Do that much for yourself, please. Otherwise, good job ignoring that Valkyrie actually demonstrated the chops to beat Moondragon and Gamora each down in 1v1 H2H combat. They are arguably two of the best martial artists in Marvel. Try and ignore that. And Valkyrie was a product of Thor's subconscious dark feelings. Try and ignore that.
Originally posted by "Id"
The comic book makes it very clear that each, and every one of those constructs are Kyle. This entire argument of yours isn’t about viability, but inability to accept the fact. The only way to claim that feats from his constructs are not viable, would be if they never happened in the first place. Tough they did happen, and now Kyle retains their experience in his mind.

I sit comfortably with my comment for three simple reasons, which you have failed to debunk; those are his constructs, they are now part of his conscious mind, and he has the power to replicate the their feat.

Same old Valkyrie/Thor argument. You can pout til you're blue in the face about it. It's the same rationale. And if you love that rationale, by all means that's your opinion. In the meantime, I'll call it how I see it: Thor runs around with Gamora+ martial arts, he just never uses them. Like Kyle runs around with Oblivion feats, he just never uses them.

Comic book makes it very clear that the power of Oblivion merged with the Central Battery energies and turned into the Ion energies. Kyle doesn't have the Ion energies anymore. He gave them up, remember? At best, it's arguable he retains his post classic-Ion tweaks to his ring. Arguable, because dispositive evidence exists which suggests that Ganthet gave Kyle a normal GL ring during Sinestro Corps War -- and not the original one he abandoned. And for the sake of argument -- because it's all too easy to recognize this simple fact -- those ring tweaks =/= power of Oblivion. Fact.

[i]P.S. No more classy gifs? kinda

Gamora simply struck a blow and dodged one - and a grab I guess. Let's not overdo it. That scene along with Bill outmaneuvering Thor so easily when he relied on skill instead of power could be explained by Thor fighiting as nothing more than a brute relying on sheer raw power during Blood and Thunder. Warlock also outmaneuvered him pretty easily using skill. Or maybe you can explain it as the Blood and Thunder Thor as simply not being as skilled as the real Thor. The Thor were familiar with was trapped in his mind. The one in Blood and Thunder was a twisted version of Thor created due to the fact Thor was reduced to bits and pieces. srug

That way everybody is satisfied. At least on the Thor side. 😛

Originally posted by Philosophía
I have a good memory and know how to use the search function.

You should feel flattered that out of all the idiocies spilled on this board on a daily basis, yours was one of those that didn't fade away with the rest.

You can use the search function to search for such specific posts? mhmm

With this new revelation in mind, I think I'll go and re-read your theory that Superman proved he has dynamic strength. What was the evidence again? He told Darkseid this time he'll be stronger? It's always educational reading your posts. ✅

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
What was the evidence again? He told Darkseid this time he'll be stronger?
No.

I guess I'll find out.

Thread = Officially wrecked 😆

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Excuse me, even ignoring your completely transparent attempts to drag Gamora down to Thor's level, are you really suggesting that the power of Oblivion was retained by Kyle AFTER he gave up the Ion energies? Because the only post classic-Ion amp he retained were the tweaks he made to his ring. A considerable amp to be sure, but the power of Oblivion? No. The power of Oblivion was enmeshed with the Central Battery energies Hallax stole and that was the Ion energies. And that's what Kyle mostly gave up to restore Oa and the Guardians. Yeah. Trying to ignore the exact parallel between your Oblivion/Kyle and Valkyrie/Thor was really defused when you suggested that "trained-for-eons" Asgardians could tool Gamora and Moondragon. Except Gamora literally played rope-a-dope with Thor in THE VERY NEXT ISSUE. You even scanned that next issue and posted the scans. What? Tell me you see a difference between how Valkyrie fought Gamora and how Thor fought Gamora. Do that much for yourself, please. Otherwise, good job ignoring that Valkyrie actually demonstrated the chops to beat Moondragon and Gamora each down in 1v1 H2H combat. They are arguably two of the best martial artists in Marvel. Try and ignore that. And Valkyrie was a product of Thor's subconscious dark feelings. Try and ignore that. Same old Valkyrie/Thor argument. You can pout til you're blue in the face about it. It's the same rationale. And if you love that rationale, by all means that's your opinion. In the meantime, I'll call it how I see it: Thor runs around with Gamora+ martial arts, he just never uses them. Like Kyle runs around with Oblivion feats, he just never uses them.

Comic book makes it very clear that the power of Oblivion merged with the Central Battery energies and turned into the Ion energies. Kyle doesn't have the Ion energies anymore. He gave them up, remember? At best, it's arguable he retains his post classic-Ion tweaks to his ring. Arguable, because dispositive evidence exists which suggests that Ganthet gave Kyle a normal GL ring during Sinestro Corps War -- and not the original one he abandoned. And for the sake of argument -- because it's all too easy to recognize this simple fact -- those ring tweaks =/= power of Oblivion. Fact.

[i]P.S. No more classy gifs? kinda

LOL

^ Far healthier than what his own arguments were originally inflicting on himself:

biscuits