Bat Girl (cassie) vs Punisher

Started by Deadline18 pages

^ Serioulsy man I'm not even really being a dick, just check there respect threads. This is street level 101.

So basically anyone who isn't a Marvel Zombie says Cass?

Cool.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
So basically anyone who isn't a Marvel Zombie says Cass?

Cool.

It has nothing do with that. Heres the question why on earth would we think that Batgirl is superior to Daredevil, Daken, Alyosha Kravinoff and Deadpool? I'm confused isn't that a reasonable question?

Why would we think that Cass can dodge Punisher when hes shot the likes of Spiderman, Daredevil and Sabretooth?

All the evidence that has been provided is of her doing things that any street level can do, hell one feat had been done by Punisher himself. You haven't provided any proof or made a counter argument you just assume you know what you're talking about.

Originally posted by Deadline
It has nothing do with that. Heres the question why on earth would we think that Batgirl is superior to Daredevil, Daken, Alyosha Kravinoff and Deadpool? I'm confused isn't that a reasonable question?

Why would we think that Cass can dodge Punisher when hes shot the likes of Spiderman, Daredevil and Sabretooth?

All the evidence that has been provided is of her doing things that any street level can do, hell one feat had been done by Punisher himself. You haven't provided any proof or made a counter argument you just assume you know what you're talking about.


Why does she have to be superior to those people to beat Frank if they've all beaten Frank?

in any rational analysis of what should happen between these two, Punisher comes out on top everytime

in comics, where streets can do things like this:

Originally posted by Q99
David Cain trained her by shooting at her head with a sniper rifle while blindfolded (her blindfolded, not him).

cass wins

so, cass wins, but only because writers are hacks

Originally posted by inimalist
in any rational analysis of what should happen between these two, Punisher comes out on top everytime

in comics, where streets can do things like this:

cass wins

so, cass wins, but only because writers are hacks


Because Punny has guns?

To paraphrase a certain movie: he doesn't have guns, he has bullets and the hope that when they're all gone Cass won't be still standing. 😛

After the events of Frankencastle, Punisher got de-aged about 20 years, and prior to his de-aging he was already good enough to contend with Daredevil in h2h and deliver some of the best street vs street fights in comicdom. Anyone who thinks this isn't a fight is delusional.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Because Punny has guns?

To paraphrase a certain movie: he doesn't have guns, he has bullets and the hope that when they're all gone Cass won't be still standing. 😛

i don't get the reference

but generally, yes, and huge amounts of tactical training. anything larger than a pistol should tear her to shreds from far further than she could do anything before she could respond. That bullets travel at 1/1000th their speed when shot at a hero is the only thing that saves her life in this conflict. A city gives her some cover, but it also gives Frank choke points and height.

I suppose it depends on what he is carrying, but basic equip for Frank is generally an AR of some kind. idk, cass could have that "deflects sniper bullets" helmet that Batman apparently has, but iirc she isn't bulletproof

Originally posted by inimalist
i don't get the reference

but generally, yes, and huge amounts of tactical training. anything larger than a pistol should tear her to shreds from far further than she could do anything before she could respond. That bullets travel at 1/1000th their speed when shot at a hero is the only thing that saves her life in this conflict. A city gives her some cover, but it also gives Frank choke points and height.

I suppose it depends on what he is carrying, but basic equip for Frank is generally an AR of some kind. idk, cass could have that "deflects sniper bullets" helmet that Batman apparently has, but iirc she isn't bulletproof


V for Vendetta, c'mon son!

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Why does she have to be superior to those people to beat Frank if they've all beaten Frank?

None of those guys have beaten Pun for the majority and some of them are more dangerous than Cassie. Daken killed pun but he had:

1. A broken leg
2. Gashes on his back that hadn't healed
3. He was suicidal.
4. Traumitized collar bone

He did incredibly well to last that long.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
After the events of Frankencastle, Punisher got de-aged about 20 years, and prior to his de-aging he was already good enough to contend with Daredevil in h2h and deliver some of the best street vs street fights in comicdom. Anyone who thinks this isn't a fight is delusional.

cosigned.

Batgirl is far more skilled and can take out Punisher easily once she gets in close. His only chance is a distance attack.

Richard Vasseur
www.jazmaonline.com

Originally posted by Richv1
take out Punisher easily
[

Daredevil cannot
Captain America cannot
Spider-man cannot
Daken cannot

Frank has fought on even keel with Wolverine, and yet with all that, cassie comes along and does it easily? 🙄

Cassie winning H2H, sure, id buy that, but there's nothing easy about it.

Originally posted by Richv1
Batgirl is far more skilled and can take out Punisher easily once she gets in close. His only chance is a distance attack.

Richard Vasseur
www.jazmaonline.com


No she can't. Daredevil is just as skilled as her and stronger to boot. Punisher handles him self quite fine in those fights. There zero reason to assume he wont handle him self against bat girl.

Punisher has only able to go against Wolvie if he loaded with weapons.

Originally posted by Richv1
Punisher has only able to go against Wolvie if he loaded with weapons.

He has weapons in this match. His standard equipment is pretty stocked.

Originally posted by Q99
Yes, and David Cain and Deathstroke are really good shooters. We aren't talking bush league here, Cain taught Deadshot how to shoot and Slade is superhuman.

She'd have a pretty good shot against Capt, assuming no shield.

Pretty much.

Thats got to be a sock.

How many times does Punisher need to go the distance with Daredevil/Wolverine/Deadpool/Captain America, before he can be considered a legitimate fight for a character who can narrowly edge out Lady Shiva largely due to CIS?

Shiva> Punisher.