Achilles vs. Legolas

Started by Robtard12 pages
Originally posted by Mindset
Legolas will wander the underworld blind, deaf, and dumb, and all the dead will know: This is Legolas. The fool who thought he could kill Achilles.

Achilles wanders the underworld blind, deaf and dumb, and all the dead know: There goes Achilles. The fool who though he could kill Paris, girly-man of Troy.

If he wasn't macking on that dumb broad he would have killed Paris.

And if Legolas is macking on Gimli Achilles may have a chance in this fight.

If Achilles deems Legolas worthy of his sword there's nothing Legolas can do to survive.

At best he can prolong his inevitable death.

Originally posted by Mindset
If Achilles deems Legolas worthy of his sword there's nothing Legolas can do to survive.

At best he can prolong his inevitable death.

Except defeat him with a combo of his superior Elven strength, speed, agility and accuracy you mean. Last I check, those mattered in a fight like this.

Originally posted by Mindset
If he wasn't macking on that dumb broad he would have killed Paris.

Achilles didn't have a shield in that scene, so the shot through his heel was mostly irrelevant.

Remove that first arrow from his foot; Achilles still dies to the arrow wounds in his abdomen.

Originally posted by Robtard
Except defeat him with a combo of his superior Elven strength, speed, agility and accuracy you mean. Last I check, those mattered in a fight like this.
Not when all he has is arrows which will be blocked. His stats are barely superior to Achilles' own anyway; Achilles is more skilled.
Originally posted by Robtard
Achilles didn't have a shield in that scene, so the shot through his heel was mostly irrelevant.

Remove that first arrow from his foot; Achilles still dies to the arrow wounds in his abdomen.

Remove the arrow in his heel and he's invulnerable.

Canon.

Originally posted by Mindset
Not when all he has is arrows which will be blocked. His stats are barely superior to Achilles' own anyway; Achilles is more
skilled.

Remove the arrow in his heel and he's invulnerable.

Canon.

Considering we've only seen Achilles block one arrow and nothing suggest that the archers in Troy come close to Legolas who has never missed, it's an unfounded statement, "he'll just block everything."

The director of Troy has specifically said he left out the mythical aspects of Troy; most importantly, Achilles did not show any divine powers/origins(unless you have some screen proof?), he was just a very highly skilled human.

Originally posted by Robtard
Considering we've only seen Achilles block one arrow and nothing suggest that the archers in Troy come close to Legolas who has never missed, it's an unfounded statement, "he'll just block everything."

The director of Troy has specifically said he left out the mythical aspects of Troy; most importantly, Achilles did not show any divine powers/origins(unless you have some screen proof?), he was just a very highly skilled human.

He just needs to block enough to get close to Legolas, which he will, with his shield that covers most of his body.

His mother can predict the future. Achilles has talked about meeting the gods. His brain explodes when he's shot through his heel.

Sorry, can't argue against canon, Rob. Achilles is invulnerable.

Originally posted by Mindset
He just needs to block enough to get close to Legolas, which he will, with his shield that covers most of his body.

His mother can predict the future. Achilles has talked about meeting the gods. His brain explodes when he's shot through his heel.

Sorry, can't argue against canon, Rob. Achilles is invulnerable.

Legolas' 100% hit rate > your wishes. The shield does not cover his whole body and he certainly needs to leave his head exposed.

So you don't have proof that movie Achilles was invulnerable like his poetic counterpart. Thought so.

Ignoring the film won't make your claims correct. Sorry, MVF rules.

He will hit his shield 100% of the time, cool.

His head has a helmet.

I provided the proof, not that he needs invulnerability to kill one pointy eared puff.

Originally posted by quanchi112
They were exaggerated and I did forget about Legolas failing to killing a Uruk Hai running in a straight line to blow up the wall in time. The guy was utterly exposed with no way to defend himself and with all that on the line Legolas utterly failed. /thread.

You realize that you're bringing up a moment of complete, obvious PIS?

Achilles's shield doesn't cover his entire body. Legolas aims for his enemies' weak spots. The Elf can fire an arrow every second. Based on Achilles' death scene, just a single arrow would be enough to slow him down.

Not to mention Legolas fires an arrow strong enough to pierce through a massive elephant's skull, I'm sure that the single arrow that hits Achilles packs more than enough punch to "Boromir" Achilles.

Originally posted by Robtard
Achilles wanders the underworld blind, deaf and dumb, and all the dead know: There goes Achilles. The fool who though he could kill Paris, girly-man of Troy.

😆 😆 😆

Originally posted by Robtard
Considering we've only seen Achilles block one arrow and nothing suggest that the archers in Troy come close to Legolas who has never missed, it's an unfounded statement, "he'll just block everything."

The director of Troy has specifically said he left out the mythical aspects of Troy; most importantly, Achilles did not show any divine powers/origins(unless you have some screen proof?), he was just a very highly skilled human.

We've seen Legolas fail to kill a Uruk Hai running in a straight line without even protecting himself. That scene kinda makes Legolas look really bad and when you throw him up against someone who have the presence of mind to easily deflect arrows while engage in multiple sword fights it's not even competitive.

Originally posted by Mindset
He will hit his shield 100% of the time, cool.

His head has a helmet.

I provided the proof, not that he needs invulnerability to kill one pointy eared puff.

Haha, nice try.

Helmets aren't necessarily arrow-proof, especially from a bow that and drill into an Oliphant's skull.

No, you said "his mother can predict the future" and some other nonsense.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We've seen Legolas fail to kill a Uruk Hai running in a straight line without even protecting himself. That scene kinda makes Legolas look really bad and when you throw him up against someone who have the presence of mind to easily deflect arrows while engage in multiple sword fights it's not even competitive.

LoL, we've gone over this multiple times, downplaying many great showings while focusing on one lesser showing doesn't fly here.

I understand why you continue to do it, as it's all you're capable of, so continue to dance for me like a good organ-grinder monkey.

Originally posted by Robtard
Haha, nice try.

Helmets aren't necessarily arrow-proof, especially from a bow that and drill into an Oliphant's skull.

No, you said "his mother can predict the future" and some other nonsense.

But his is.

Yea, his mother predicted the future. Didn't you see the movie?

Originally posted by quanchi112
We've seen Legolas fail to kill a Uruk Hai running in a straight line without even protecting himself. That scene kinda makes Legolas look really bad and when you throw him up against someone who have the presence of mind to easily deflect arrows while engage in multiple sword fights it's not even competitive.

Did you not read my post? 😕

P.I.S.

Originally posted by Mindset
But his is.

Yea, his mother predicted the future. Didn't you see the movie?

The role of clown has been filled already, sorry.

Originally posted by Robtard
The role of clown has been filled already, sorry.
I'm serious, you don't remember that part of the movie?

Originally posted by Mindset
I'm serious, you don't remember that part of the movie?

Obviosuly I do, why I said it doesn't equate to Achilles being invulnerable. But you know this and are just playing games. No worries.