Achilles vs. Legolas

Started by Mindset12 pages

I don't think you do.

You shouldn't be thinking.

One of us has to.

Looks like it has to be me.

You're thinking again; we just went over how you shouldn't. Tsk tsk.

Don't feel insecure, Rob, you're not the only person I'm superior to.

Quancho's already corned the market on self back-patting. You need a new angle, sir.

Quanchi is one of the others.

Shhh, I'm almost done with season 5.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
You realize that you're bringing up a moment of complete, obvious PIS?

Achilles's shield doesn't cover his entire body. Legolas aims for his enemies' weak spots. The Elf can fire an arrow every second. Based on Achilles' death scene, just a single arrow would be enough to slow him down.

Not to mention Legolas fires an arrow strong enough to pierce through a massive elephant's skull, I'm sure that the single arrow that hits Achilles packs more than enough punch to "Boromir" Achilles.

😆 😆 😆

No, it's called a moment of failure. He's a person who can and has made mistakes and failed. I can site gandalf or this moment. The guy isn't hitting people's earlobes from hundreds of yards away. You can't dismiss and praise his higher showings against fodder.
Originally posted by Korto Vos
Did you not read my post? 😕

[B]P.I.S. [/B]

I don't ignore failure.
Originally posted by Robtard
LoL, we've gone over this multiple times, downplaying many great showings while focusing on one lesser showing doesn't fly here.

I understand why you continue to do it, as it's all you're capable of, so continue to dance for me like a good organ-grinder monkey.

I factor in everything. He's really great against fodder while he still can fail and against a skilled opponent such as Gandalf look utterly ineffective.

Originally posted by quanchi112
No, it's called a moment of failure. He's a person who can and has made mistakes and failed. I can site gandalf or this moment. The guy isn't hitting people's earlobes from hundreds of yards away. You can't dismiss and praise his higher showings against fodder. I don't ignore failure. I factor in everything. He's really great against fodder while he still can fail and against a skilled opponent such as Gandalf look utterly ineffective.

No, it's PIS. Legolas kills every other armored Orc in the films handily- suddenly, he fails to kill to slay the one unarmored Orc whose sole purpose is to be the suicide bomber that causes the Deeping Wall to explode, and hence drive the plot. Yes, that would fall under PIS.

Skilled opponent?

Legolas single-handedly kills a gigantic pachyderm and its entire howdah crew.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
No, it's PIS. Legolas kills every other [B]armored Orc in the films handily- suddenly, he fails to kill to slay the one unarmored Orc whose sole purpose is to be the suicide bomber that causes the Deeping Wall to explode, and hence drive the plot. Yes, that would fall under PIS.

Skilled opponent?

Legolas single-handedly kills a gigantic pachyderm and its entire howdah crew. [/B]

That shows he can fail but come on he was hitting him just didn't kill him in time. You can't dismiss it just because you want to. I view pis as he's struggling in a fight and there's a dagger in the perfect place when he needs it to end the fight but won't ignore anything.

Mere canon fodder. Skilled opponents would be Saruman, Gandalf, Aragorn, the Nazgul or someone of note.

Originally posted by quanchi112

Mere canon fodder. Skilled opponents would be Saruman, Gandalf, Aragorn, the Nazgul or someone of note.

If the Olyphant and crew were "mere canon fodder" as per your words, then it tells us Achilles isn't up the the task of killing cannon fodder from the LoTR universe.

Legolas therefore wins on that merit alone, he easily walks through cannon fodder that would crush Achilles. Good job at destroying your own argument.

Originally posted by Robtard
If the Olyphant and crew were "mere canon fodder" as per your words, then it tells us Achilles isn't up the the task of killing cannon fodder from the LoTR universe.

Legolas therefore wins on that merit alone, he easily walks through cannon fodder that would crush Achilles. Good job at destroying your own argument.

Legolas is better suited with his ranged weapon against certain foes than Achilles but this is abc logic when comparing these two. In the movie they were fodder.

Achilles would have jumped the wall and killed the bomb carrying Uruk-Hai himself unlike Legolas the failure elf.

Achilles would have soloed the entire army.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Legolas is better suited with his ranged weapon against certain foes than Achilles but this is abc logic when comparing these two. In the movie they were fodder.

Achilles would have jumped the wall and killed the bomb carrying Uruk-Hai himself unlike Legolas the failure elf.

LoL, you call an Oliphant and crew "canon fodder" in one breath and then ignore that said cannon fodder would demolish the guy you're fanboying. Legolas took out the Oliphant at close range, watch the clip and pay attention.

Hahahaaaaa, "jumped the wall", good one. That wall was several hundred feet high, so you're fanboying again. Do stop destroying your own points now, that's twice in as many points, leave some for me to crush.

What does Timothy Olyphant have to do with anything?

Originally posted by Mindset
What does Timothy Olyphant have to do with anything?

I used an 'y' instead of a 'i', calm down.

Originally posted by Robtard
LoL, you call an Oliphant and crew "canon fodder" in one breath and then ignore that said cannon fodder would demolish the guy you're fanboying. Legolas took out the Olyphant [u]at close range[u], watch the clip and pay attention.

Hahahaaaaa, "jumped the wall", good one. That wall was several hundred feet high, so you're fanboying again. Do stop destroying your own points now, that's twice in as many points, leave some for me to crush.

I didn't say they'd destroy Achilles I said his ranged attacks were better suited for the situation he was in. You really don't comprehend very well do you ?

Achilles jumps on the Uruk Hai and while in mid air spears his head. You're a bitter Achilles hater.

Originally posted by Robtard
I used an 'y' instead of a 'i', calm down.
You calm down!

Originally posted by quanchi112
I didn't say they'd destroy Achilles I said his ranged attacks were better suited for the situation he was in. You really don't comprehend very well do you ?

Achilles jumps on the Uruk Hai and while in mid air spears his head. You're a bitter Achilles hater.

So you think Achilles can take down an Oliphant and crew? LoL. What you said doesn't follow with what happened in the film, Legolas took down the Oliphant at close range as you've been told. So you're arguing based on something that isn't true yet again. Please stop destroying your own points.

Yeah, further fanboying.