Abraxas vs Dream of The Endless

Started by Mr Master15 pages

Originally posted by leonidas

i'm curious though--if you think 616 eternity is just one
universe, where do you place things like all the splinter realms
(hell, cyttorak's universe, vishanti's universe, etc....)? asgard?
olympus? are they within 616 eternity? we've seen alternate
versions of all these things. so, where do you put them if not inside
616 eternity? do they exist on their own somehow? and if they are
within eternity (which is what i believe) then eternity (616) can
indeed be viewed as multiversal. the term 'universe' is too limiting
and forces a hierarchy that doesn't consistenly fit. eternity is also
referred to the totality, the sum of all things, etc..... those terms fit
better my impression of what 616--and all eternities--are.


Cyttorak's reality is outside 616.
Vishanti's reality is outside 616.
Asgard and Olympus, those are pocket realms.
Hell, another pocket realm.

This gives no reason at all to consider 616 Eternity being a Multiverse.

Originally posted by leonidas

again, we see that dormmy created his own world.
how you or anyone can go and say he ruled completely over the
entire multiverse (so NO alternate universes existed that were not
ruled by dormmy?) i have no idea. what you're saying is that there
was no alternate where dormmy chose NOT to act. where the exis
did NOT shift in that way.


There's literally ten references to it being far more than universal.

It was even directly mentioned at-least five times that it was Multiversal.

"It always comes down to conquering the Universe,

well ... Multiverse in my case"

-------------------------------

If the writers had Dormy only re-created 616,
it's doesn't take away from the power in possession.
Then again, it could be interpreted as the Multiverse indeed.

Dormy was also jobbering to ridiculous levels in that story.

Originally posted by leonidas

it's been said in comics (in what ifs and other places) that each
time a choice is made, a divergent universe is born. and yet, to
say that dormmy took control over the entire multiverse means
nothing--no what ifs, no nothing, existed that he didn't absolutely
control. i have problems with this pov. we only saw him in control
of ONE 'place', not ALL places. then we have the simple issue that
multi-eternity is never named at all. you think the author wrote
that assuming readers would just.....figure it out for themselves? IF
he were aware of the multi-entity, you'd think he'd have mentioned
that.


There is no "multi" Eternity. So I can see why a writer wouldn't include that.

All the other references and direct statements cover the Multiverse issue.

Also,
just cause Dormy wasn't artistically shown controlling each
individual universe doesn't mean he did not, after all, that would be a daunting to ask to achieved artistically anyway, actually impossible.

No, we know Dormy/Umar were Multiversal because that's what the
writer repeated through out the story, across all the books.

Originally posted by leonidas

then, if not mentioning his name and forcing readers to make
assumptions many wouldn't even be aware of in the first place
wasn't enough, the writer goes out of his way to TELL us that was
616 eternity that faced dormmy. man, that's a LOT of confusion
he's put in there. yet on top of that we have to assume that
dormmy took control of multi because something happened where
dormmy 'somehow'..... took over multi from WITHIN 616 eternity?


All Eternities share the same consciousness.

When one speaks, it's as though all of them are speaking.

I remember the Reality Korvac nullified, an alternate universe.
Yet, when it spoke, it stated that this was one aspect of its totality.

Now, that sure wasn't 'Multi' ... or 616, or a Multiverse,
it was the singular reality Korvac lived in,
but it speaks as though it is the sum of All Eternity.

Simple, ... one consciousness ... spread across infinity.

Originally posted by leonidas

616 eternity has always been comprised of numerous
dimensions/universes/etc, and that viewpoint HAS been supported
on panel. if we take that view, dormmy took over the 616 version
of eternity, no missing names, no wild assumptions. he did what
was shown. simple and crystal clear, imo.


I disagree.

616 Eternity contains numerous pocket dimensions/universes,
but not a single other entire universe.

Originally posted by leonidas

whew. sorry for the lengthy reply. cosmology is interesting stuff.


That's cool true debater,
I'm glad your being reeled into this since I always enjoy your perspective.

You also make me work to win. 😠

Originally posted by Mr Master
I don't just believe it, I know it.

Ok, so you don't "believe" it, ... and?

You believed the Galactus Head was what mind wiped & comatose Uatu,
you also believed it was the cause of the Multiversal Space-Time Continuum's disruption.
you also believed Abraxas attacked Uatu when his wraith-like state appeared even though Abraxas attacked Uatu from UniverseS away,
you also believed Abraxas was merging realities by killing Galactuses.

So, when we add this up,
I certainly am not concerned with your beliefs concerning Abraxas.

Your opinion is respected although it's wrong.

Alternate Galactuses have died in other stories and the reality suffered no ill affects.

So how do you explain beings popping in and out near the head if not it was the center of the gap and causing a disturbance in the space-time continuum left by it??? Even when the FF moved it and Abraxas showed up he showed up on the moon, not where he wanted to be!
😑
Also it is incorrect to believe he just passed by the universes and they collapsed, he roamed them he killed every version of Galactus he found. It even states this in the handbook.

The alternate Galactuses that have died and the realities was not effect could have been because the main 616 Galactus was still alive, something in this story he was dead. I haven't read that story about the other Galactuses dying and realities not being effected I admit, but it would make sense that was why they remained fine.

I respect your opinion as well, but I don't agree with everything. I am going by the comic's. Btw Abraxas is a powerful, no disrespect to him at all.

👆

Originally posted by kevdude

So how do you explain beings popping in and out near the head
if not it was the center of the gap and causing a disturbance in the
space-time continuum left by it??? Even when the FF moved it and
Abraxas showed up he showed up on the moon, not where he wanted to be!


facepalm

Come on Kev, stop this already.

Originally posted by kevdude

Also it is incorrect to believe he just passed by the universes
and they collapsed, he roamed them he killed every version of
Galactus he found.

It even states this in the handbook.


They didn't just collapse.

Abraxas' presence merges realities, which ultimately leads to collapse.

Oh, and not true on the handbooks stating Abraxas was
collapsing anything via killing Galactuses.

In fact,
what the handbooks do tells us is that Abraxas under his own power,
destroyed entire Universes:

[img=http://s3d3.turboimagehost.com/t/10720801_Ab6.jpg]

Originally posted by kevdude

The alternate Galactuses that have died and the realities was not
effect could have been because the main 616 Galactus was still
alive, something in this story he was dead. I haven't read that
story about the other Galactuses dying and realities not being
effected I admit, but it would make sense that was why they
remained fine.


Abraxas was not affecting realities by killing Galactuses.

So long as we got that clear.

Originally posted by kevdude

I respect your opinion as well, but I don't agree with
everything. I am going by the comic's. Btw Abraxas is a powerful,
no disrespect to him at all.


I'm going by the comics too.

So as the old saying goes, we'll agree to disagree. 🙂


All Eternities share the same consciousness.

When one speaks, it's as though all of them are speaking.

I remember the Reality Korvac nullified, an alternate universe.
Yet, when it spoke, it stated that this was one aspect of its totality.

Now, that sure wasn't 'Multi' ... or 616, or a Multiverse,
it was the singular reality Korvac lived in,
but it speaks as though it is the sum of All Eternity.

Simple, ... one consciousness ... spread across infinity.

100% correct :

Here is my note, This seperation of these characters allows us to put practical limits on how far each entity’s influence extends. With Eternity as a cap we see that all the natural forces of a universal reality are part of him so to say. But we cant ignore that there are powers that exist higher than Eternity ..Hunger, the Infinites, possibly the Beyonders – the LT, of course –and powers within the unverse that can destroy or control Eternity (the Infnity Gems, the M’Kraan Crystal… and the Phoenix Force), but that’s where their influence ends.

Originally posted by Mr Master
^^^ I can't see why you would say that friend.

And I'm not saying that.

I know it's 616 Eternity.

But that's also my point, it was from the Infinity Crusade arc,
where there was a being trying to change the Multiverse.

There is no single Universe that holds or supports entire extra Universes within it.

The 616 Reality/Eternity is one Universe.

[B]Earth 616: (616 Universe)

"Core Continuum designation given to the Prime Earth of the Marvel Universe,
Reality from which most Alternate Earths derive
"

***

It's just that the power of all realities comes from this center point,
which is 616 Eternity/Infinity are depicted as containing the power
of all Space-Time that make it up.

[/B]

Originally posted by Mr Master
facepalm

Come on Kev, stop this already.

👇 Come on Mm, if you want to ignore whats happening thats fine but other's need to see this! Its in the comic so it needs to be discussed!

This scan shows the problems started when the dead Galactus head appeared and fell to Earth.
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/831/image10lb.jpg/

This shows that Abraxas controlled it and it fell to Earth in the spot he wanted!
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/707/image12eh.jpg/

Reed moves it to try to seize the advantage of having it on another battlefield!

http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/546/image13s.jpg/

Abraxas shows up on the moon where the hole in space and time is at that the FF moved the head! He even laughs at their attempts to slow him down and stop him saying "Veni, Vidi, Vici" "I came, I saw, I conquered."

http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/252/image11za.jpg/

I'm going by the comics too.

So as the old saying goes, we'll agree to disagree. 🙂

👆 Good ta hear!

🙂

Originally posted by kevdude

Come on Mm, if you want to ignore whats happening thats fine
but other's need to see this! Its in the comic so it needs to be
discussed!

This scan shows the problems started when the dead Galactus head appeared and fell to Earth.
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/831/image10lb.jpg/
This shows that Abraxas controlled it and it fell to Earth in the spot he wanted!
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/707/image12eh.jpg/
Reed moves it to try to seize the advantage of having it on another battlefield!
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/546/image13s.jpg/
Abraxas shows up on the moon where the hole in space and time is
at that the FF moved the head! He even laughs at their attempts to
slow him down and stop him saying "Veni, Vidi, Vici" "I came, I
saw, I conquered."
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/252/image11za.jpg/


facepalm ... This is your brain on drugs.

That aside ...

For the last time ... geesh.

The Galactus Head was nothing more than a homing beacon for
Abraxas to find 616 in the infinity of universes around it.

Secondly, Reed moved the Head, to attract Abraxas to that part of the city,
because he wanted to change the battlefield,
since well he knew Abraxas would attack where ever the Head was at.

----------------------------

Nearly two entire issues before Abraxas appears in 616,
he's already wiped away Uatu's memory, stolen his emblem and further comatose him later:

If there's any doubt Abraxas did this (under his own power) BEFORE he entered 616:

Originally posted by zopzop
Dream BORED him to sleep. Plus there were people that thought the entire thing was a story made up by Mxy. I provided links to the scans from Comicvine.

comicvine isn't 100% accurate good friend

Originally posted by Mr Master
facepalm ... This is your brain on drugs.

That aside ...

For the last time ... geesh.

The Galactus Head was nothing more than a homing beacon for
Abraxas to find 616 in the infinity of universes around it.

Secondly, Reed moved the Head, to attract Abraxas to that part of the city,
because he wanted to change the battlefield,
since well he knew Abraxas would attack where ever the Head was at.

----------------------------

Nearly two entire issues before Abraxas appears in 616,
he's already wiped away Uatu's memory, stolen his emblem and further comatose him later:

If there's any doubt Abraxas did this (under his own power) BEFORE he entered 616:

facepalm

I don't do drugs so I wouldn't know.. I've said all there is to say about Abraxas, nothings changed my mind and nothings changed yours. Nice chatting with you about this even if we don't agree on some of the things.

Originally posted by guy222
comicvine isn't 100% accurate good friend

I got the scans (using both comicvine and Galan's Mxy respect thread) Guy. They are correct. The entire thing could be just a story Mxy made up. I noticed in the scans, Dream doesn't even bore him to sleep. Mopius the ZZZandman (aka the Lord of ZZzz's) does.

cool buddy

comicvine's info on tiamut and spidey isn't correct

i have some dream feats and galan's thread is always excellent

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dream_%28comics%29

and gaiman is the ****

Originally posted by guy222
cool buddy

comicvine's info on tiamut and spidey isn't correct

i have some dream feats and galan's thread is always excellent

See Guy :
http://i272.photobucket.com/albums/jj172/galan007_pics/mxycomic13.jpg
http://i272.photobucket.com/albums/jj172/galan007_pics/mxycomic14.jpg

It wasn't Dream. If the event even took place, and is not just a story by Mxy to impress Superman/Lois(?), Mopius the ZZZandman did it. He bored Ultimator to sleep.

All of the comics Mxy pulled Ultimator into were part of his personal 'magical comic collection.' None of the characters they encountered in said comics were intended to be the 'actual' versions... They were spoofs. Knockoffs.

Did no one else notice the titles of said comics?: Logjam of Super-Heroes, Just-Us League of America, Aquamint Man, Jack Kirbptlk's Farce World, Lobo's Nephews, etc. etc. They were Mxy's version of the comics/characters we read.

Originally posted by Galan007
All of the comics Mxy pulled Ultimator into were part of his personal 'magical comic collection.' None of the characters they encountered in said comics were intended to be the 'actual' versions... They were spoofs. Knockoffs.

Did no one else notice the titles of said comics?: Logjam of Super-Heroes, Just-Us League of America, Aquamint Man, Jack Kirbptlk's Farce World, Lobo's Nephews, etc. etc. They were Mxy's version of the comics/characters we read.

I did but there were people arguing that since "Dream" "beat" Ultimator he could beat Abraxas. I was merely pointing out that a) it wasn't "Dream" that did anything to Ultimator (assuming the story is true at all and not Mxy spouting BS) and b) all Mopius did was bore Ultimator to sleep.

It wasn't the actual Dream, but rather, Mxy's interpretation of him.

That said, what 'Mopius' did within the pages of Mxy's 5-d comic collection is not indicative of what the real Morpheus can do--as the real thing may be more powerful than Mxy's version, or he may be weaker. We simply never saw him cope with a threat on Ultimator's level, so there's no way to be sure.

Well we can say Abraxas is a one time wonder and we will never see him again as a threat. MU has already put forth newer Cosmic threats. Plus can never die cus he will comeback in another form.

Originally posted by Galan007
All of the comics Mxy pulled Ultimator into were part of his personal 'magical comic collection.' None of the characters they encountered in said comics were intended to be the 'actual' versions... They were spoofs. Knockoffs.

Did no one else notice the titles of said comics?: Logjam of Super-Heroes, Just-Us League of America, Aquamint Man, Jack Kirbptlk's Farce World, Lobo's Nephews, etc. etc. They were Mxy's version of the comics/characters we read.

galan, does he defeat the dark man

I think he has a good chance, personally.

same