DC's Angels Vs Marvel's Cosmics

Started by quanchi11218 pages

Originally posted by BullwinkleMoose
This is wrong. If something is within someone's Power Set and abilities, then they can do it even if we have not see it on panel. You don't need to see the LT have super reaction feats on panel to know that he cannot be speedblitzed by Flash. Likewise, I don't need to see Fulcrum defend against Time Freezing to suggest Odin or other Sky Father's couldn't do that to him.

Not allowing Michael to use his full abilities goes against the Forum Rules.

I wouldn't argue Lt is super fast either but he can see into the future and knows what will occur next so it's all good. Michael has full access to his abilities it just isn't in his character to nuke someone right out of the gate. You can't cbr him just because you like him. I argue what I read you don't.

It might not be in his character to Nuke the field but he has the capacity to and if fighting to the best of his abilities would do so if needed to win.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Michael dies near the end of the book.

Michael's gives his power (which is him, remember) to Elaine. He does not "die" in the sense you're trying to portray.

As for the rest of your post, you continue to ignorantly spout nonsense so I won't bother ripping your arguments to shreds again, because yo so stubbornly defend your ignorance and ABC logic with what you claim to be "on panel facts".

Have a good day. 🙄

Feat wise I go with Marvel.

kinda tired of the implied power argument. it has no place in forum battles.

There are more feats than implied, my friend.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
There are more feats than implied, my friend.

Indeed. They're just not combat feats.

Originally posted by Nietzschean
Feat wise I go with Marvel.

kinda tired of the implied power argument. it has no place in forum battles.

Without implied power arguments, debates spiral into "on panel evidence only" style arguments, which can be infinitely stupid. Especially when a lot of writers and stories feel that their readers are smart enough to put two and two together to get four. Vertigo characters don't have drop down, drag out battles like conventional Marvel/DC ones as a rule or needless displays of battleboard style feats. That doesn't make them not powerful.

Originally posted by Cogito
Indeed. They're just not combat feats.

Some are like the Michael/Spectre or Gabriel/Lucifer. Doesn't Michael have untold amounts of experience in war?

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Some are like the Michael/Spectre or Gabriel/Lucifer. Doesn't Michael have untold amounts of experience in war?

Michael is described as Heaven's greatest warrior as well as its most powerful being next to God.

Originally posted by BullwinkleMoose
It might not be in his character to Nuke the field but he has the capacity to and if fighting to the best of his abilities would do so if needed to win.
Not unless you can show him doing so.

If you take his powers and use them yourself but that's taking the character out of the fight.

Originally posted by Cogito
Michael's gives his power (which is him, remember) to Elaine. He does not "die" in the sense you're trying to portray.

As for the rest of your post, you continue to ignorantly spout nonsense so I won't bother ripping your arguments to shreds again, because yo so stubbornly defend your ignorance and ABC logic with what you claim to be "on panel facts".

Have a good day. 🙄

So yes Michael dies. You said he didn't which is a lie.

Run away while I'll continue to beat my chest.

Originally posted by Cogito
Yawn...and DCnU Merlin held all of space/time in his hands.

Proof? There were some that said that was a visualization.

Anyone trying to claim Marvel wins this clearly wants cut and dry rankings -- you want everything lined up and spelled out for you. DC cosmics, especially Vertigo related, are far more complex and abstract. Relationships between characters and how one fits into another and the hierarchy at large is really vague and, I believe, intentionally made so for the reader to interpret as he or she wants.

Talk about "yawn". Ok, so I interpret them as weaksauce.

Some people don't like that approach, and I get it. There's still some undeniable and absolute facts that we do know for sure:
1. The Presence/God is a true omnipotent. He created everything, and exists in everything (see Lucifer series; Zauriel). Characters like WF Mxy and such did not and cannot kill the Presence/God.
2. Michael and Lucifer are second only to God. No, they don't have combat feats. They don't need combat feats, and that's not how their characters are supposed to be. TOAA doesn't have combat feats, and he doesn't need them either.
3. Michael is the embodiment of God's power. He is an abstract. People don't generally get that. He is power. All of it. He also can't die.
4. Lucifer is the embodiment of God's will. He is also an abstract. He has God's infinite reality shaping power. He cannot create something from the void (only Michael can), but if it's already there, he can literally do anything. He doesn't do in comics for two reasons. First is that it would make the most boring comic ever. Second is that he prefers to work through others. He's not oblivious to cosmic design and the natural order of things.
5. The Great Evil Beast is the darkness/evil to the Presence's light/good. Even if you considered them separate, which I think is foolish, they merged and are complete now anyways. "The fight ended in perhaps a stalemate". Wow, do you really need it spelled out for you? Perhaps a stalemate because God was challenging himself, and neither side won or lost. There's no words to accurately describe something like that, hence how it was worded.
6. DCs God has never been explicitly challenged -- except by himself.
7. It is unknown how the Primal Monitor fits into the DC hierarchy. It is quite possible that the Primal Monitor and the Presence are one in the same. It's possible that the Primal Monitor is a representation of the reader or the writer. We don't know, and I doubt we'll ever know. Without being explicitly told otherwise, the Presence/God remains supreme.
8. The Spectre fluctuates in power constantly. You can't use his low feats as a gauge to measure other characters. You can use his high feats as a gauge though (e.g. ZH and the like).
9. The Spectre, with Hal and Crispus as hosts, has been consistently written weaker than he has appeared in the past.
10. Forgot one related to Lucifer/Michael. They are canonically greater than the Endless such as Death, Sandman, etc.
11. Everyone in Marvel has low feats too, that are constantly ignored by Marvel fanatics. LT, with all his power, has been surpassed, BFR'd, and absorbed. Death has been killed and run off. I could write a book about Eternity's low showings. The point of this is not to say that Marvel characters are weak, but that some people pretend like DC cosmics have so many low showings and Marvel is so consistent that ABC logic can get you anywhere and blah blah blah and it's all bullshit.

A lot of this is so wrong I don't even know where to begin, but let's start with the GEB.

He's NOT a part of Vertigo's "God" but his opposite/equal. This alone proves Vertigo's God < TOAA (who has NO opposites, peers, or superiors). And they did not merge, I even provided a scan from the GEB's respect thread that stated "He" and Vertigo's "God" are locked in "at best, a stalemate". Unless you have a more recent scan proving they merged.

The GEB also sh|ts all over the claim that Michael is "second only to "God" since GEB is at least "God's" equal. So Michael is second to him also.

Then there's the Swamp Thing/Elemental Congress fiasco that almost had Swamp Thing replace Vertigo's "God" as the new supreme being! 😆

Regarding the Presence (since some on this thread said he's not the same being as Vertigo's "God"😉, WF Mxy sh|ts all over him. Destroying and recreating the entire DC OMNIVERSE (which by definition would include the Presence) on a whim.............WEEKLY.

So claims by Team Angel that these feebs are "second, third, and fourth only" to their feeb "God" is meaningless for us on Team Marvel.

Going by feats and fights ON PANEL, not in some made up scenario in Team Vertigo's head, Team Marvel wins.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Michael is described as Heaven's greatest warrior as well as its most powerful being next to God.

Odin/Odinforce is described as omnipotent. And according to the Watcher in both the Dark Phoenix Saga and in a What If Phoenix (it was narrated by 616 Uatu), the Phoenix Force is a primal force second only to the Creator in power. So it must be true right?

Zop zop I don't agree with everything you say but your making some killer points here. 👆

Originally posted by zopzop
Odin/Odinforce is described as omnipotent. And according to the Watcher in both the Dark Phoenix Saga and in a What If Phoenix (it was narrated by 616 Uatu), the Phoenix Force is a primal force second only to the Creator in power. So it must be true right?

Except those are examples that within their shared universe have been shown to be untrue and contradicted- we've seen that Odin isn't omnipotent and we've seen other forces > PF.

But in the shared universe of the Vertigo books, nothing has ever contradicted the fact that Michael is God's second, and it was emphasised to be a fact throughout the entire run of Lucifer...

Originally posted by AlmightyKfish
Except those are examples that within their shared universe have been shown to be untrue and contradicted- we've seen that Odin isn't omnipotent and we've seen other forces > PF.

And we've seen that Michael isn't "second only to (feeb) God". We've seen that Vertigo's "God" isn't the supreme power and has, at least, an equal in GEB. Didn't someone have a scan of Vertigo's "God" admitting there were forces above even him!? 😆

But in the shared universe of the Vertigo books, nothing has ever contradicted the fact that Michael is God's second, and it was emphasised to be a fact throughout the entire run of Lucifer...

Michael CANNOT be "second only to (feeb) God" because GEB is (feeb) "God's" equal (at least). So Michael is AT LEAST third. Hell he's possibly FOURTH if you consider the Swamp Thing/Elemental Congress fiasco. Who knows what else is out there. That's just off the top of my head.

Michael is only second to god in the vertigo title which isn't canon to the dcu. I have read far more impressive beings from the dcu than I did from vertigo imo.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Michael is described as Heaven's greatest warrior as well as its most powerful being next to God.

👆 and one of the most bad ass warriors I have seen.

Originally posted by zopzop
Odin/Odinforce is described as omnipotent. And according to the Watcher in both the Dark Phoenix Saga and in a What If Phoenix (it was narrated by 616 Uatu), the Phoenix Force is a primal force second only to the Creator in power. So it must be true right?

Yeah, when the Odinforce or Odin is capable of destroying all of creation or molding it to his will, I'll be the first one to lose my cookies. Or when Odin takes on a being equal to or even close to the Spectre Michael dismissed (though I'm sure you're loath to give Spectre any credit), I'll be sure to write home about it.

Unfortunately, we know the Phoenix Force isn't second only to TOAA.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Yeah, when the Odinforce or Odin is capable of destroying all of creation or molding it to his will, I'll be the first one to lose my cookies. Or when Odin takes on a being equal to or even close to the Spectre Michael dismissed (though I'm sure you're loath to give Spectre any credit), I'll be sure to write home about it.

Unfortunately, we know the Phoenix Force isn't second only to TOAA.

Just like we KNOW Michael isn't "second only to "God" because GEB is at least "God's" equal. Just like we know that Swamp Thing with Elemental Congress amp almost overthrew "God" so that would make him more powerful than Michael, which drops him down in power rank even further.

We also know that the "God" of Vertigo has admitted that there are beings greater than him in power and we know he has at least ONE equal : GEB and one potential equal (superior) : Swamp Thing with Elemental Congress amp.

So you'll excuse me if I'm less than impressed with they hype surrounding Michael and crew.

Michael's power is infinite. So says God himself.