Originally posted by zopzop
Cogito, I understand where you are coming from but even according to DC, the Presence by definition is NOT omnipotent.In scenario one, if Vertigo's God is the same being as mainstream DC's Presence, we got HUGE problems calling that being omnipotent. Like I mentioned before, GEB's very existence proves that statement to be a lie. GEB is NOT part of Vertigo God's creation and is totally independent of him/her/it. In fact, they are locked in a stalemate. You cannot have two TRUE omnipotent beings.
Then there's the Swamp Thing/Elemental Congress fiasco.
In scenario two, Vertgo's God isn't the same being as mainstream DC's God. Then they aren't truly omnipotent, just the most powerful (arguable see Primal Monitor and Mandrakk 1 and WF Mxy) in their respective creations. Each are independent of the other and boss (debatable) only of their little section of the greater DC Omniverse.
This isn't the case with the LT. He's omniversal in scope and the last line of defense before you involve TOAA (which in reality is the writer).
I understand your points, but disagree.
I've said this a hundred times before -- DC's hierarchy is far more abstract than Marvel's. It's filled with paradoxes and contradictions. And it's meant to, because it's more of a mirror to the way we real people view religion. The Judeo-Christian God, and I don't mean the one in DC, likewise is believed to consist of paradoxes and contradictions. We're told, by those in the Church/Mosque/Synagogue etc, that this is because we, as humans, can't fully comprehend God.
I truly believe that DC has tried to mirror this in it's own omnipotent. There are levels of complication and paradoxes that we aren't meant to understand and that aren't ever going to be explained, because that's not how it was intended.
All we know is that we're told the Presence is Omnipotent, Omniscient, Omnipresent, etc., and that's the way it is. He appears in different forms (Ultimate Light/GEB/etc), but it's all the same. It's abstract, it doesn't seem to make sense, but within DC the Presence reigns supreme.
Originally posted by Jynocidus
why can't you understand that you aren't omnipotent unless you're omnipotent everywhere? There is only 1 omnipotent being, anywhere.I sure can say that the Presence has no power over LT. Don't blame me for DC's God being portrayed as a false omnipotent, blame the writers. The Presence being "omnipotent in DC" doesn't stack up against a being who embodies necessity. Presence gets no mercy here, it is what it is.
I'm not saying Presence holds no power over LT because he's a Marvel character, I'm saying Presence holds no power over LT because necessity > creations (team 1). They don't have what is required to win, because LT embodies it. For team 1 to rely on Presence's false omnipotence will short change them for a harsh stomping courtesy of the LT.
And who, according to you, is that 1 omnipotent?
The LT may embody necessity in Marvel, but in DC it was the Presence who created the concept of necessity from nothing and who is necessity.